Has Warren Buffett got it completely wrong?

Jan 21, 2010

In this issue:
» Warren Buffett's perplexing act
» What do Indian fund managers think of the Sensex in 2010?
» Auto companies to hike their R&D spends
» Bond yields all set to rise in the US
» ...and more!!

----------------- Defeat SPAM! -------------------
A lot of readers have been complaining that they have not been getting their regular Equitymaster e-mailers. So, if you feel that you are not getting your 5 Minute WrapUp daily or you missed out on the recent Equitymaster WebSummit or our great subscription offers, please whitelist us. This is the only way to make sure that Equitymaster mail does not go into your SPAM box and that you stay well informed about our events and the world of investing... regularly.

Regular readers of this column are perhaps well aware of our admiration for Warren Buffett. It is also a fact that we are not big fans of the current US Fed Chairman Ben Bernanke. Thus, we were left puzzled when Buffett became quite generous in his praise for Bernanke in a recent interview. It is not that Buffett has not praised Bernanke before. But this one surely took the cake.

This is what Buffett said of Bernanke, "He did a magnificent job over this period, when I look back at September, October 2008, he took action. Maybe he extended his authority, but he did what he should have done in response to the economic Pearl Harbor."

We disagree. We believe all that the US Fed has done is just paper over the problems. It has tried to solve a problem of excessive money supply and leverage with still more money supply. Currently, injecting more money is looking like a great step what with asset prices enjoying a great deal of recovery. But we believe that we have set ourselves up for an even bigger blow up in the future.

So, what explains Buffett's fascination with Bernanke? Maybe self-interest? His net worth is so inextricably linked to the fortunes of the US economy that he is forced to take Bernanke's side. Alternatively, it could also be due to his affinity for an entirely different school of economics. Whatever be the reason, for once, we tend to disagree with Warren Buffett.Do you think Buffett is right in his assessment of Ben Bernanke? Please share your views with us.

The Indian stock market outlook for 2010 is locked. The intelligentsia has given its verdict. If you are looking to invest in stock markets from a one year perspective, expect your returns to be in the region of 10%-20%. No, we are not saying it. This conclusion was drawn from a survey among India's top fund managers who manage a whopping Rs 1.7 trillion collectively between them. The survey that was published in one of India's leading dailies has fund managers believing that insurance money could be a big driver during the next stage of rally and the same could help the Sensex move in a narrow band in 2010 with an upward target of 18,000 on the Sensex.

We would however refrain from giving such exact numbers. But even we would want to side with the majority of the fund managers in the survey. Our research is not throwing up as many fundamentally good stories available at attractive valuations as it used to do say about a year back.

 Chart of the day
Taking the finding of the survey forward, today's chart of the day also tries to depict something along similar lines. The chart shows the yearly returns for the stock market index for emerging markets since 1994. It clearly highlights that whenever the index has tended to rise in the region of 45%-50% in any particular year, the return for the next year has been far less and has even gone into the negative. The index returned 63% in 2009 and thus if history is any indication, the returns for the current year i.e. 2010 are likely to be far less than 2009. Some sort of vindication for the fund managers in the survey we should say.

Source: Morgan Stanley

The impact of economic stimulus is being seen nowhere better than China. The dragon nation has just recorded the quickest pace of economic growth since 2007 in the fourth quarter of 2009. Its GDP grew by 10.7% during the quarter.

Data Source: IMF, Bloomberg report

In normal times, such a growth will bring cheer for any country's policymakers. But if times are bad and if such a growth is built upon nothing but cheap money, it's a fearful feeling. Such strong growth in fact must add to the pressure on Chinese central bankers to rein in surging credit. Otherwise, it threatens to destabilize the world's fastest-growing major economy. And with it the entire global economy.

Keep aside stocks, real estate and gold. This time the speculation about bubble-like symptoms is being associated to the bond markets as well. Typically known to be a haven for risk-averse investors, even the bond markets are no more the place to be for the long term. This is particularly in reference to the US bond markets. With budget deficit hovering at 10% of GDP, the treasury yield curve is showing record steepness. The biggest bond fund manager in the US, Mr Bill Gross believes that US Treasury bond yields could go above 4%. The same would mean correction in bond prices. At the same time, with short term interest rates at 0.5%, investors would have to wait for 1,000 years for their money to double. Indeed a difficult situation for investors looking for safe and reasonable returns. No wonder emerging markets are luring them in hoards.

Rising inflation has cropped up as a serious concern; one that the Indian government will have to address on an urgent basis. And the first chief statistician of India Pronab Sen seconds this view in an interview with Mint. Sen is of the opinion that given the poor monsoons and the subsequent adverse impact on food production, prices were bound to rise. Further, the devaluation of the rupee meant that imports would also be expensive. But he has pointed out two interesting facts. One is that there does not seem to be a vociferous protest against inflation. Does that then mean that nominal income has risen so much that the price rise is not hitting hard as it would have otherwise? The second point to be noted is that inflation has manifested itself strongly in retail prices but not as much as in wholesale prices. The other worrying factor is that signs of inflation are beginning to appear in non food items as well. Indeed, it will be interesting to see how the government chooses to tackle this problem in the months ahead particularly when it does not want to compromise India's GDP growth.

As per a leading business daily, Indian automakers are expected to increase their expenditure on Research and Development (R&D) by 25% to 30%. The move is expected on the back of fierce competition from global auto giants. They are keen on India, which is among the most promising auto markets. In fact, they have designed compact cars specifically for the Indian market. Toyota's Etios, Volkswagen's Polo, General Motors' Beat and Ford's Figo are prominent examples.

It may be noted that the international giants have much higher R&D expenses as a percentage of sales than their Indian counterparts. As a result, barring Tata Motors' Nano, few Indian models have managed to grab headlines. However, Maruti Suzuki will soon launch its first fully India configured small car. In our view, advertising and R&D are examples of the expenses that actually aren't. Actually, they are more like assets. In fact in many cases, they hold the key to the competitive advantage of companies. Even nations. Hence, it is not surprising that India's and China's total R&D spending as a percentage of GDP is at 0.8% and 1%. Compare that to 2.7% and 3.3% for the US and Japan and that too on a higher GDP base of these two countries.

Meanwhile, key market indices plunged in the afternoon session today, reportedly on the back of both global as well as domestic economic concerns. At the time of writing, BSE-Sensex was down about 380 points whereas NSE-Nifty was trading lower by around 110 points. Weakness in engineering and power heavyweights were weighing heavy on the indices. While Asian markets closed mixed today, European markets have opened the day on a strong note.

 Today's investing mantra
"I don't want a lot of good investments; I want a few outstanding ones." - Philip Fisher

Today's Premium Edition.

Recent Articles

All Good Things Come to an End... April 8, 2020
Why your favourite e-letter won't reach you every week day.
A Safe Stock to Lockdown Now April 2, 2020
The market crashc has made strong, established brands attractive. Here's a stock to make the most of this opportunity...
One Stock that is All Charged Up for the Post Coronavirus Rebound April 1, 2020
A stock with strong moat is currently trading near 5-year lows.
Sorry Warren Buffett, I'm Following This Man Instead of You in 2020 March 30, 2020
This man warned of an impending market correction while everyone else was celebrating the renewed optimism in early 2020...

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Has Warren Buffett got it completely wrong?". Click here!

89 Responses to "Has Warren Buffett got it completely wrong?"

Murali Krishnan K

Jan 21, 2010




Jan 21, 2010

I agree with the view. As right now prices of commodity, stock etc are increasing, hence we are happy. The question remain whether the problem has been solved or problem has been shifted. It is time , which will prove that action of Bernanke was correct or not but, it seems that again we can see the effect of depression. Sir Buffet is a man who has great vision, but we have the right of disagreement.
In my view period of January'10 to June'10 will be very important/vital , as no Goverment is trying or announcing any Stimilus. Further, as no new supply of paper will be made into the market , hence we have to wait & watch, the real effect,




Jan 21, 2010

Pratik Gandhi has hit the nail on its head. Most of the people here (including me, EM, ... ) do not understand head or tail of running any economy. So stop critizing Warren.


atul prakash

Jan 21, 2010

Money goes where it generates a return. At present India is in the lime light as the largest democracy in the World. It has got relatively conservative banking institutions and a Capital Market which is more than 130 years old ( started by the Dutch East India Company to safeguard the sea transport of cargo from India to Holland and place that risk on the shareholders. Hence, it is a Capital Market much older than that of USA.

Even the London Stock Exchange was formed much after the Dutch East India Company.

Money from India fled to all parts of the world for the past 4 centuries. After the Liberlization of the Indian Economy by Mr. P.V. Narasimha Rao, the licence permit raj grip of existing industrial houses broke loose.

The industrial might of our young educated entrepreneurs started to put India into the Industrial Map of International recognition.

Capitalization in the Capital Market in India is extreemy low by western standards, and lots of money now needs to flow back into the Indian Economy.

The Western Countries keep the USA as the bulwark, in trying to prevent Financial Muscle in the form of money going to Asia. However the continuous growth figures in GDP are forcing the greed of the educated west to place more and more trust in the Indian Economy.

Mr. Warren Buffet is an extreemly successful Stock Market Guru. He has made trillions based in the USA. USA itself has grown tremendously in the past 50 - 60 years and due to it's extreemy successful World Media Blitzkreig advertizing its explosive growth coupled with the freedom of money's repatriation acceptabilities. Hence, unless USA is able to stem the tide of money flowing back to Asia to fetch much higher returns, Mr. Warren Buffet may be betting on the wrong economy.

It is evidently clear that the US government along with all the sinking economies of Europe, injected huge amounts of Public Funds to Bolster the totteing companies as well as the Banking Institutions.

(It is well known that the World Bank, IMF, UNESCO, and all major world bodies are governed by the West and as such have a biased views.)

Individual companies in the USA had to prevent erosion of their massive capital base and have had to literally dive into their Shareholders Reserves and Buy Back their own Shares in the Capital Market to show the their Company Stocks had rebounded in March 2009.

Only time will tell whether this rescue mission could convince the public to bring back their money into the US economy.

History always repeats itself and if all goes well India may see a flow of money never seen in the history of the world. If on the other hand USA is successful in thwarting this flow from the USA, then Mr. Warren Buffet shall once again prove a winner and laugh all the way to eternity.

This is what the game is!



Jan 21, 2010

Also it would be interesting to see comments and opinions of Equitymaster when US (Ben) took the radical steps to stem the global economic slide.



Jan 21, 2010

Buffet want to make profits from govt. policy so he wants them to keep happy. This money injection into system will buy some time for buffet to switch over from stuck investments, and now he is switching over.



Jan 21, 2010

Everyone in any kind of business (excepting perhaps non-profit social org) or politics are opportunist and have self-interest in mind, especially when money matters are concerned. Ben had a self-interest too in i.e. doing his job for his salary - and ofcourse to achieve success so that he gains in his life. So no point in blaming anyone. Ben did what he thought was best for America, and G20 leaders did what they felt was right for their respective nations at that point of time. Each one had a choice of doing differently, but everyone agreed to print and supply money! I am sure Ben and other leaders will have best of economic advisors at their disposal...
By the way Equitymaster is also opportunist! When market falls, they show their cautious warnings to investors, and when market goes up, they show how their Stock Select Recommendations to gain more subscription money!


shine abraham

Jan 21, 2010

it is opportunist approach only, his correct decisions were also opportunist approach also, this time he wants to drive up stock prices with excess liquidity and feel good factor and then he will exit from us stocks and dollar because he knows that both are on verge of collapase. so he will be a winner yet again you see.



Jan 21, 2010

Yes, equitymaster is right in pointing out that it is in his self-interest. He cannot continue to rule as the world's wisest investor if the US ecomony go to dogs. So he had to do something to instil confidence in investors and he has been at this for some time now.



Jan 21, 2010

Why don't you share the views of readers about rising inflation which at present is a burning issue in every peoples mind instead of bringing views on Bernanke vs Buffet which in no way going to feed the poor and unaffordable indians.

<<Prev    Next>>
Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Has Warren Buffett got it completely wrong?". Click here!