Is S&P threat a jackpot for value investors?

Apr 26, 2012

In this issue:
» British economy witnesses another recession
» Bernanke should ease more, feels Krugman
» Dangerous times ahead for the US
» Huge jump in loans referred for restructuring
» ...and more!

------------------ Most Profitable Investment Lesson we could learn from our Past.... ------------------

Investments have certainly come a long way... Today we invest in commodities, stocks, real estate and so on.

Yet, we have discovered an extremely profitable investment strategy that has been used for over centuries now.

It's how our forefathers used to invest.... and their forefathers... It has been tested over time and even today, it could be extremely profitable for all of us.

But you need to act fast as the opportunity is available Only till 11:59 PM today!

Just click here to know all about it and why it could be the Best Inheritance we have received.


The most popular opinion, it is said, is not always the correct opinion. Nowhere else is this truer than in finance we believe. In fact, you will do a lot better in investing if you develop a constant suspicion about the most popular opinions in the field. Take S&P's recent opinion on India for example. The ratings agency believes that India is off to hell in a hand basket. It has thus cut its outlook on India's long term debt and has also warned the emerging Asian giant of a possible downgrade.

We have reasons to believe why long term equity investors have very little to worry about the announcement. The biggest amongst these is the success of the simple strategy of betting against the S&P ratings. Studies have shown that over the long term, a portfolio of stocks rated lower by S&P tends to beat the higher rated portfolio. In other words, stocks with an A+ rating have tended to underperform those with B+ or even C rated stocks over a long term horizon. The outperformance of poorly rated stocks has to do with expectations perhaps. On account of their poor financials and profitability, they happen to be valued so low that even a small improvement tends to lead to a big jump in their prices.

There is no reason why the same analogy cannot be applied to India's ratings. Agreed that India's near term outlook is poor. But with certain degree of reforms, India could easily solve deficit problems and also take its growth significantly higher. Stocks in India though do not seem to be factoring this into their valuations currently. This thus puts the risk reward ratio firmly in favour of a patient long term investor. Any more correction from the current levels and that would be the added icing on the cake we believe.

Thus, a possible downgrade of India by S&P and the resultant reaction of short term investors could actually turn out to be a bonanza in the long term for patient investors.

Do you think events like S&P downgrade should be seen as an opportunity for value investors? Share your comments with us or post your views on our Facebook page / Google+ page.

 Chart of the day
India may lag most countries in internet penetration but it has still managed to earn the dubious distinction of being the spam capital of the world. A report from SophosLabs, a software security firm states that more than 9% of all spam messages transmitted in the first quarter of 2012 were relayed through India before coming into people's inboxes. The US was close on India's heels, accounting for more than 8% of all spam mails. Countries like South Korea, Indonesia and Russia helped round off the top five.


Which is one of the deadliest things that the world economy has piled up in the last 3 decades? In case you haven't guessed yet, we're referring to the massive amount of debt that the world is sitting on. What scares the daylights out of us is the way politicians across the world are dealing with the problem. Can you stop a fire by dumping fuel into it? Even a 5 year old would laugh at such a foolish suggestion. But believe it or not, politicians are doing something quite similar. They're injecting more debt in a pretentious effort to deal with it. They tweak economics to grind their own political axes. But you cannot postpone doom by trying to hide the symptoms.

Take the US economy for instance. It is suffering from a severe debt burden, an ailing economy and widening gaps between the haves and the have-nots. When the crisis reaches its zenith, it is likely to trigger massive policy changes. The economy has to prepare itself for more taxes and spending cuts. The future of the US and several unscrupulous developed economies is going to be marked with a lot of rude shocks.

Telecom operators have been fretting and fuming over the price set for 2G license auctions. They have termed the prices are sky high and unreasonable. But the Chairman of TRAI (Telecom Regulatory Authority of India) stands firmly behind the math in his pricing. In his opinion, spectrum is a scarce commodity. Therefore the pricing that the TRAI has proposed is justified. He has also stated that the operators can look at increasing the lucrative data revenues rather than promoting voice over the new spectrum. This would help them recover the high spectrum prices.

The truth is that the government is in dire need of funds. It was able to make up a large part of its fiscal targets in FY11 mainly from the funds it received from the 3G auction. So why should it lose an opportunity to repeat history with the 2G auction as well. In reality, the price being asked for the 2G spectrum is ridiculously high. One should not forget that the 3G spectrum is premium to the 2G spectrum. Therefore the price of the latter should ideally be below that of 3G and not higher. But our dear regulator or government fails to understand basic common sense.

Is the Fed Chairman, Mr Ben Bernanke actually doing the right thing for America? Is criticism of his actions unjustified? Well, this is exactly what economist Paul Krugman thinks. Critics of the Fed's policy action want the central bank to choke off the recovery, while it should actually be doing more to accelerate the same. Bernanke should actually focus less on inflation and more on curbing unemployment. After all the basic duties of the central bank is to focus both on full employment and price stability. Not one versus the other.

If the Fed actually stops worrying about inflation, it could do the country a world of good. For three years economists have been worrying about runaway inflation. But, even now inflation remains below the Fed's 2% target. The USA is under a huge mountain of debt which was accumulated during the bubble years. Higher inflation levels will help erode the real value of debt and help speed up the recovery. Inflation would also render idle cash unattractive, spurring on more productive investments. So is QE3 in the offing? Well, if things take a turn for the worse it is definitely on the cards.

Britain is in a tough situation. The Cameron government is serious about sticking to its austerity plan with the aim of eliminating most of the budget deficit by 2017. But this has led to the economy tripping. The British economy shrank 0.2% in the first quarter after contracting 0.3% in the fourth quarter of last year. As a result, Britain has slid back into recession. This has also put the Bank of England in a spot. Expecting the economy to post some growth, the bank had almost decided to halt more stimulus measures and focus more on inflation. But with the economy contracting, it may be compelled to rethink its position.

Obviously, there are voices from various quarters questioning the extent of austerity measures that the British government has imposed. One thing is certain. Taking on more debt to solve the problem of debt is not going to do the British economy any favours in the long term. Thus, it will be interesting to see what the Cameron government chooses to do. Will it stick to its stance? Or will it succumb to public pressure given that it has been sliding in recent polls? Only time will tell.

The recent cut down in the key lending rate by Reserve Bank of India (RBI) hardly brought any relief to the banking sector. Coerced into reducing lending rates, many PSU banks are already set to face pressure on margins. To top that, every now and then there are reports of jump in the loan restructuring. The latest numbers published in a financial daily peg the loans referred for recast at Rs 2.05 trillion. This is 48% higher than last year! What is more worrying is that the number is three times the total profit of the listed banks in the country in FY11 i.e Rs 669 bn. Agreed that all the restructured loans are not to be written off. However even if a third of them are to become delinquent, it would wipe off an entire year's profits for the sector. Needless to say that the statistics are worrying indeed. Moreover, the reporting for such restructured assets is still very opaque. Hence it is time the RBI should come out with some guidelines to better reflect the same. Until then, investors in the sector will have to tread very cautiously in terms of valuations.

Meanwhile, indices in the Indian stock markets have been hovering around the dotted line since the beginning. The Sensex was trading higher by around 20 points at the time of writing. Heavyweights like ITC and Infosys were the main drivers. Most Asian indices closed strong today with Europe too opening on a positive note.

 Today's Investing mantra
"If you spend more than 13 minutes analyzing economic and market forecasts, you've wasted 10 minutes." - Peter Lynch

Today's Premium Edition.

Recent Articles

All Good Things Come to an End... April 8, 2020
Why your favourite e-letter won't reach you every week day.
A Safe Stock to Lockdown Now April 2, 2020
The market crashc has made strong, established brands attractive. Here's a stock to make the most of this opportunity...
One Stock that is All Charged Up for the Post Coronavirus Rebound April 1, 2020
A stock with strong moat is currently trading near 5-year lows.
Sorry Warren Buffett, I'm Following This Man Instead of You in 2020 March 30, 2020
This man warned of an impending market correction while everyone else was celebrating the renewed optimism in early 2020...

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Is S&P threat a jackpot for value investors?". Click here!

5 Responses to "Is S&P threat a jackpot for value investors?"

Harleen Kaur Sethi

Apr 26, 2012

For US, it might be better to focus on reducing slowdown rather than inflation. But if we talk about India, ignoring inflation and concentrating only on reducing the slowdown might not serve the purpose. How will the initial damages caused by rise in prices be counteracted?



Apr 26, 2012

Yes, this downgrade would have been an oppurtunity to buy quality stocks at a lower rates, but for the counter rating given by Moodys'. The mrkts were poised for a fall, and by coincidence(?????) after the S&Ps' warning, immediately within an hour the stable rating of Moodys'was flashed. If it is coincidence, it is really perfectly timed. Anyhow, we do not expect the mrkts to move much at least till the next elections, which are almost 2 yrs away, till than mkrts will be ranged bound, and give ample oppurtunity to buy stock for the year 2017-18. If selected with very good care, we can get many multi-baggers.
Secondly, regarding the Chairman of TRAI, sometimes one feels, since the call rates in India are extremely low, it is only natural that the Govt. gets full value for the scarce spectrum. Remember 1980, prior to Mobile days, local call use to be Re.1 for 3 min. Urgent calls, and Lighting calls, just recollect those days. Technology does bring down the prices, but for a cash strapped Govt., if it sells the national spectrum at reasonable price (rather than at throw away rates) what is wrong. Seven lakh crores could be really handy for the Congress. And for that if public has to pay say 50ps. per minute or a rupee per minute, it should be tolerable. Think positive.



Apr 26, 2012

"But the Chairman of TRAI (Telecom Regulatory Authority of India) stands firmly behind the math in his pricing."

Eventually the higher 2G spectrum prices will be passed on by the telecom operators to the consumers. This is an indirect form of taxation because the govt is filling its kitty and then wasting it on some silly scheme or the other to garner votes in the next election.


Sundar Rangan

Apr 26, 2012

You may be right. Fact is, S&P itself has very little credibility, considering the role it played in accelerating the sub-prime crisis in US during 2007. I wonder who would rate S&P itself and if someone were to rate it, it would most certainly get the most further-undowngradably low rating that one would ever get.



Apr 26, 2012

S&P ratings are comments on debt and not equity markets. Moreover, they consider the fundamental aspects, rather than valuation aspects. Therefore, to draw conclusions on share price movements of S&P rated entities (positively or negatively) is naive.

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Is S&P threat a jackpot for value investors?". Click here!