Will this help India overtake China's growth?

Jun 1, 2010

In this issue:
» The effect dividends can have on stock returns
» Why the strong GDP growth failed to cheer markets
» Do financial forecasts have any value?
» SEBI's clampdown extends to derivatives
» ...and more!!

--------------------- Don't Miss! FREE Webinar with Ajit Dayal - Register Now! ---------------------
If you are worried about the global crisis reaching India and impacting your investments, then tune in to the Equitymaster FREE Webinar, titled, 'Global Fears, India Cheers?' Listen to Ajit speak on the opportunity he can foresee for India...and for a long-term investor like yourself. Scheduled for Monday, 7th June, 5.30 pm (IST).
Hurry! Register now!

Perhaps the question that we ask most often to company managements here in India is how they are dealing with competition from companies in China. For Indian companies that sell within India, there is the fear of cheaper imports from China. For companies that export their wares, there is again competition from China that constantly hounds their share in the international markets. Indeed, China has flooded the world with its goods, becoming the big daddy of the global manufacturing sector. Thus giving sleepless nights to many an Indian promoter.

All this has been made possible by this one big competitive advantage that the dragon nation possesses - ultra-cheap labour. No wonder then that Chinese goods are some of the cheapest in the world. And this is one of the biggest reasons for their extensive popularity. But this may all be about to change soon.

Foxconn is the world's largest contract manufacturer of electronics that supplies to companies like Apple, Sony, Dell, Nokia and HP. It has recently been finding itself struggling to manage the rising expectations of younger workers at its 300,000 worker factory in China. Worker protests demanding wage hike have marred the operations of many units including that of Honda's in the past week.

China has traditionally looked down on worker protests. But instance like these have been getting more frequent of late. Reports suggest that manufacturers are struggling to attract and keep young workers. Brought up in an era of relative affluence, they are proving less willing to put up with poor wages.

India's manufacturing sector too has seen challenges in recent times. Particularly in the form of land acquisition delay and infrastructural bottlenecks. Also the least expected - terrorist attacks. However, China's 'low cost' advantage may not remain that challenging going forward. Thus, a more level playing field for Indian companies may be on their way. Could this be case for India taking over China's GDP growth rate? Time will tell.

 Chart of the day
Investors seldom take into consideration dividends. For most, they are simply cheques of measly amounts that they receive in the mail that do not really matter much. It is rise in share prices that matter to them. But as today's chart of the day shows, dividends are definitely not something to be ignored. It pegs the Sensex 'Total Returns Index' against the BSE-Sensex. The Total Returns Index, not known to many, also takes into consideration dividends announced by companies, and assumes them to be reinvested. While the BSE Sensex may be far from that magic 21,000 number, the Total Returns Index is well above that. Infact, it stood at a good 22,474 as per yesterday's closing.

Data source: CMIE Prowess

India's GDP growth has come in at a strong 8.6% during the quarter ended March 2010. This has however failed to cheer the markets. The concern probably lies in the consumption growth number. As per reports, India's private consumption growth stood at just around 2.6% during the quarter. This was almost half the growth achieved in the previous quarter (ended December 2009). The number was also not very encouraging for FY10 - at 4.3% as against 6.8% during the crisis year of FY09.

So, are the markets right in not giving much heed to these numbers? We believe yes. This is given the Indian economy is domestic consumption driven. It remains to be seen how the consumption numbers come in the current year. But if the growth remains lacklustre, it will be a matter of serious concern. This is especially with respect to sustaining a high GDP growth rate in the future.

It is a very important debate for investors. Do financial forecasts have any value? After all, the entire industry of traditional equity research is built on forecasts. An interesting article we read today says the problem is not with forecasting itself, but how it is done. You see, future is inherently uncertain or probabilistic. Hence, forecast cannot be single point estimates. They must be in terms of a probability distribution - with measures of central tendency (such as an average or median) and measures of dispersion or variation. The problem with most forecasts, no matter how detailed, is that they are only point estimates of central tendencies. So the underlying assumption is that the future is certain. It is not!

Much of the blame for the financial meltdown lies at the door of complicated models that did not sufficiently recognise the dangers of unexpected events. It is high time financial modeling embraced uncertainty and considered a wide range of events. In our view, the inherent strength of a discipline like value investing is that it specifically tries to counter uncertainty through a margin of safety. A practice the broader industry could benefit from.

Mis-selling of financial products has been the cause of global financial meltdown. But the pain is felt more acutely when ignorant retail investors lose their shirt gambling on complex products. With this in mind, mutual fund regulator SEBI has clamped out on this practice. SEBI has proposed a set of guidelines for vending financial products. Currently banks sell nearly a third of all financial products including mutual funds and insurance. Broking firms and portfolio managers also enjoy a considerable clout. However, their sales are guided by the sales executives' 'targets'. And not by the risk profile of the potential investor. This most often leads to mis-selling. SEBI's guidelines seek to penalize such act and ensure that investors buy only what suits them. It also seeks to limit the use of derivatives to portfolio hedging rather than as a speculative instrument. We believe that these guidelines could go a long way in regulating the maturity of Indian financial markets.

If you do not know the kind of impact good governance can have on business, just ask cement companies present in the eastern state of Bihar. On second thoughts, forget it. They may not even have the time to pay any heed to your question, thanks to the tremendous surge they are witnessing in the off take of cement. A leading business daily has put the growth number at 35%. Yes, that's right. Cement demand in Bihar has grown by 35% in the financial year FY10, coming as it does, on the back of a 13% rise in FY09. For close followers of the economic activity in the state, the numbers may not have come as a surprise.

It should be noted that in FY09, Bihar had the fastest pace of GDP growth among all states at 11.4% and this in turn seems to have boosted demand for all commodities, including cement. Also important to add that the cement demand is not coming from big infrastructure projects but is actually being driven by rural demand and demand from home builders and small businesses. As to how long this buoyancy will last? Well, if governance continues to be good, given the low per capita consumption of cement in state, demand should remain robust for quite some time to come. And this could well be music to the ears of cement companies present in the state.

Developed economies worldwide are facing sluggish growth while emerging economies are quickly breaking past records. While this growth may look good on paper, BRIC economies may be overheating and developing asset bubbles, according to renowned economist Nouriel Roubini.

High inflation, foreign capital inflows, and unfavorable currency appreciation are standard accompaniments for a quick-paced recovery, and the BRIC nations are not immune to these evils. Roubini, however feels that Brazil and India are still in 'better shape' than China due to the strength of their domestic demand.

All in all, positive GDP numbers may not look good for too long; unless inflation shows some respite, spending in developed economies improve, and structural reforms in the emerging nations are implemented.

Meanwhile, the Indian markets witnessed a negative trading session today after a weak start. At the time of writing, the BSE Sensex was down by about 290 points. The metal and energy indices led the pack of losers. However, pharma stocks have managed to hold their own. Asian markets across the board had a weak outing today. Europe has also opened lower.

 Today's investing mantra
"Volatility is a symptom that people have no idea of the underlying value - that they have stopped playing the asset game. They're not buying because it's a company with certain attributes. They're buying because the price is rising." - Jeremy Grantham

Today's Premium Edition.

Recent Articles

All Good Things Come to an End... April 8, 2020
Why your favourite e-letter won't reach you every week day.
A Safe Stock to Lockdown Now April 2, 2020
The market crashc has made strong, established brands attractive. Here's a stock to make the most of this opportunity...
One Stock that is All Charged Up for the Post Coronavirus Rebound April 1, 2020
A stock with strong moat is currently trading near 5-year lows.
Sorry Warren Buffett, I'm Following This Man Instead of You in 2020 March 30, 2020
This man warned of an impending market correction while everyone else was celebrating the renewed optimism in early 2020...

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Will this help India overtake China's growth?". Click here!

9 Responses to "Will this help India overtake China's growth?"

shrinath sahai

Mar 10, 2012

shrinath sahai, investment&realestate consultant,is optimistic about INDIA SURPASSING CHINA due to young,energiticworkforce.



Jun 2, 2010

A nice presentation about the prevailing market.Keep me update please.



Jun 1, 2010

Living in China, I have come to understand a few more things about the people. It is not just the cheap labour which helps, but the disciplined work force. Factories are able to build huge labor driven plants without the fear of lock outs and strikes, which is still a problem in India. Plus, the workforce here is very ambitious and driven, with the desire to achieve a lot more, than quite a few of India's workforce happy with their 'dal-roti'. Maybe the current workforce in India is evolving to a more ambitious frame of mind, but as it stands, China does have an advantage here as well. Not to forget the infrastructure, in which it is far ahead of India.


manish patel

Jun 1, 2010

"While the BSE Sensex may be far from that magic 21,000 number, the Total Returns Index is well above that. Infact, it stood at a good 22,474 as per yesterday's closing." This is one of the sentence in which i can not relate or understand total return index which also used as a benchmark for quantum long term equity fund. can you explain me in details.
thanking you,



Jun 1, 2010

India will still find it very difficult to overtake China`s growth.India has its own different problems.



Jun 1, 2010

from the first gight its looks that CHINA is going to take over the world market in the fild of elictronics,garments,toyes,automobiles,and many other filds.First thing is that labourer are chiper then india, another hand they have devolope smallscale industries infrastructures,even you may say it just as cotteg infra.But over all you see that the quality their product is inferrior USE&THROUGHOUT,china can not PERSISNANT STABLE MARKET,lET THE CONSUMIER HAVR experience,and same thing is being heppening.



Jun 1, 2010

Bihar fully understands the importance of agriculture due to other limited opportunities available here. Every house is having an agricultural land & the state seems to be self-sufficient in terms of agricultural products which is not the scenario in other states. Due to the gap between production and demand, this brings in revenue into the hands of rural people thus helping them progress or live a better life style thus impacting demand for other commodities. This is a real good thing and this is how India should be functioning since India is mainly an agricultural driven country. Urban development is not as big as the rural sector. Many of the states like Kerala have indeed forgot the importance of agriculture and are fully dependant on other states for their daily bread. This is a bad thing indeed.



Jun 1, 2010

Equitymaster's forecasts with 'margin of safety' for all the pressing questions today:

Will India surpass Chaina in GDP Growth?
Will BSE SENSEX cross 21000 by July 2010?
Will SEBI triumph over IRDA?
Will Gold be the Asset of the Decade?
Will the Sun rise in the West?

Answer to all the above --- 'Time Will Tell'


surajit som

Jun 1, 2010

bihar's story is heartening.if india is to progress,BIMARU states must perform. gujarat/keralas alone cannot eradicate india's backwardness.long live nitish kumar.now we need CM like him in other BIMARU states.

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Will this help India overtake China's growth?". Click here!