Are Your Bank Deposits Riskier than Your Bank Stocks?

Aug 17, 2018

Editor's Note: Dear reader, we would like to say a big thank you to all those who have claimed their copies of Equitymaster's Secrets: 2018 Limited Edition. We published only 1,000 copies and stocks are running out fast! This book is virtually free and we want you to get your hands on a copy before stocks run out. Just click here to get your copy now.

In today's edition of The 5 Minute WrapUp, Tanushree revisits an issue that is very close to her heart. The safety of India's banking system. Read on...

Tanushree Banerjee, Editor, The 5 Minute Wrapup

The value of your fixed deposit in ABC Bank crashed by 95% at today's closing prices.

Has your bank ever sent you such messages?

Do you find the idea ridiculous?

Well, not if you expect your bank to be completely honest with you. And believe that it should worry about its own bankruptcy.

Today, more than half the public sector banks do not have the capital to pay back depositors.

Believe it or not, the losses of these banks are several times the value of the deposits they owe you. And if they must shut down, they could simply not repay depositors. Unless the government makes good their losses and capitalises them.

So, left on their own, they might have to mark down the value of deposits by 90% to 100%.

In that case, your banker would have to tell you about a crash in your fixed deposit value, like your broker tells you about your stocks.

--- Advertisement ---
Your Hardbound Book Will Be Dispatched Shortly

Hundreds of readers have claimed their virtually free copies of Equitymaster's Secrets: 2018 Limited Edition. If you haven't already, please share your Indian postal address with us as soon as possible, so that we can dispatch your book. We are running out of stock faster than we'd anticipated…

Click here to claim your book.

Reminds you of the crash in smallcaps, doesn't it?

The problem is that we think about stocks and fixed deposits very differently.

We take it for granted that stocks are perpetually at high risk, for their returns are not guaranteed.

And the guaranteed return from fixed deposits makes us complacent about their risk, especially if the deposit is in a public sector bank!

If you remember, I asked this question in an issue of the Wrapup earlier this year.

Are the Stock and Deposits of State Bank of India Equally Risky Today?

The deposits of State Bank of India (SBI) enjoy a sort of sovereign guarantee. So, they are considered the gold standard for a low risk asset in India.

But is that true for every public sector bank? And should you blindly assume that your deposits in them carry no risk?

Well, you won't, if you take a look at this...

Banks on the Verge of Bankruptcy

Public Sector Banks Net NPA to Networth
Allahabad Bank 159%
Indian Overseas Bank 154%
IDBI Bank 135%
Oriental Bank of Commerce 121%
United Bank of India 119%
Andhra Bank 117%
Punjab National Bank 115%
Union Bank 96%
Central Bank 95%
UCO Bank 94%
Corporation Bank 92%
Data source: Companies

11 out of the 21 public sector banks in India have net non performing assets (NPA) higher than or almost equal to their networth. In an ideal case, their depositors would be warned and the entities would be wound up. Offering deposits in the garb of safe assets, in near bankrupt entities, is mis-selling.

If this was the case with a private sector non banking entity, you would have voluntarily given up the idea of getting your deposits back. Or at least tried to redeem them as soon as possible. But these banks - with blessing of the government - manage to keep depositors in the dark.

So when you think of risk, make sure you don't rule out asset classes.

Even the seemingly safest ones could carry a high degree of risk. And even the much-feared ones, like stocks, could, in fact, be a safe haven.

Black Swan author, Nassim Nicholas Taleb says that anyone who survived in the risk-taking business lives by a version of Warren Buffett's sermon 'in order to succeed, you must first survive'.

Taleb's version is...never cross a river if it is, on average, four feet deep.

Mine finish first you must first finish.

Which is why I look for a big margin of safety even in risky asset classes like stocks. And having recommended safe stocks for over a decade, can confidently tell you, that the risk of losing money in them is less than that of deposits of some banks.

So, dispel the myth that bank deposits do not carry risks. Check if your bank is telling you the truth.

If you still aren't convinced, ask yourself if the best stocks (bought at their best valuations) are really as risky as bank deposits, over the long-term. Just look at that NPA data again.

To finish first and to finish your investing journey well, embracing Safe Stocks for the long term, is the way to go.

Chart of the Day

Ask an average Indian investor about the next best thing after safe bank deposits. I can bet they would tell you about LIC policies. For generations Indians have treasured LIC policies in their safe deposit lockers like their gold and fixed deposit receipts.

Life Insurance Corp. of India (LIC) meanwhile, has been acting like the government's ATM for years. It has bailed out public issues of scores of PSUs. And helped the government milk it by buying a majority stake in several state-owned lenders. The latest attempt to bail out the troubled IDBI Bank is a classic case of the state insurer buying toxic assets.

In fact, given the high stakes that LIC owns in the most troubled banks, the government needn't even consider the proposal of setting up a 'Bad Bank'. It could just turn LIC into one. At least then the investors owning investments in LIC policies, would know the real risk they carry.

LIC - The Default Bad Bank?

Warm regards,

Tanushree Banerjee
Tanushree Banerjee (Research Analyst)
Editor, The 5 Minute WrapUp

PS: Dear reader, click here to claim your virtually free copy of Equitymaster's Secrets: 2018 Limited Edition This book, which includes a special message from Tanushree Banerjee, editor of The 5 Minute WrapUp, will be available only till stocks last! Claim your copy now!

Recent Articles

All Good Things Come to an End... April 8, 2020
Why your favourite e-letter won't reach you every week day.
A Safe Stock to Lockdown Now April 2, 2020
The market crashc has made strong, established brands attractive. Here's a stock to make the most of this opportunity...
One Stock that is All Charged Up for the Post Coronavirus Rebound April 1, 2020
A stock with strong moat is currently trading near 5-year lows.
Sorry Warren Buffett, I'm Following This Man Instead of You in 2020 March 30, 2020
This man warned of an impending market correction while everyone else was celebrating the renewed optimism in early 2020...

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Are Your Bank Deposits Riskier than Your Bank Stocks?". Click here!