How vote bank politics will drown India?

Sep 21, 2012

In this issue:
» Why is Brazil opposing QE3?
» Fed to remain dovish for years to come
» How can kirana stores compete with the likes of Wal-Mart?
» Signs of prolonged Chinese slowdown
» ...and more!


Video: Our Top 5 Picks For 2015
(Watch It Before The News Spreads)

This video goes off air at 11:59 PM on 23rd September... Don't miss it! Click here to view now...

Reforms. It is the word that has eluded India for quite some time. But finally when it arrived, stiff resistance came along. And it was Mamata Banerjee who pulled the shots this time around. Recently, United Progressive Alliance (UPA), in a bid to curb fiscal deficit, increased diesel prices. It also opened the doors for Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) in retail. Both these moves were widely criticized by Mamata Banerjee, a key ally. In fact, she has also decided to withdraw her support from the government deeming the moves as anti-people.

But we believe that her step to oppose the price hike will particularly make oil costlier than before! And this will hurt the people even more. Let us explain how. We know that oil is bought and sold in dollars. Before the reforms Indian rupee was lingering at 55 odd levels to the US dollar. However, once they were announced Foreign Institutional Investors (FIIs) started pouring money into India. As a result, rupee appreciated. And appreciating rupee effectively reduces the import bill of India. That's because the oil marketing companies would now have to shell less in rupee terms to buy the oil.

But the rally in the rupee was short lived as stiff resistance came in from the key ally. Thus, market lost faith in the reform process. And rupee settled at earlier levels. In fact, it might depreciate even more from here amidst capital flight. Thus, Mamata's steps will not only bloat the oil bill but will also impact the rupee. This will widen the trade deficit. Not to mention that the fiscal deficit will expand further. Opposing FDI in retail will also deprive India, of much needed foreign capital. This will hurt the investment climate in India.

We believe that opposing reforms under the garb that they are anti-people will do no good to the nation. Tough steps have to be taken to bring economy back on track. But India's coalition politics is making things difficult for the government.

Do you think reforms will attract capital and improve growth prospects of India? Share your views you can also comment on Facebook page / Google+ page

 Chart of the day
Labor is expensive in the western countries compared to the Asia. But wage payments are also linked to location and skill sets. For instance, hourly wages in Mumbai are higher than in Patna. Also, a skilled labor gets paid more than an unskilled labor. Thus, higher wage paying cities indicate the abundance of skilled labor that is being employed there. The chart of the day reflects the prominence of cities in Switzerland, known to have one of the highest standards of living, that offer higher wages compared to their European counterparts. In building the index, effective hourly wages of 15 professions are used to derive the aggregate wage level across cities. And New York City is used as the base with index level of 100. Thus, the figures 131 and 124 for Zurich and Geneva respectively indicate that the wage levels here are 1.3 times and 1.2 times that of New York.

Data source: Rediff

He may not see eye to eye with the Indian Finance Minister. However, our RBI governor Dr Subbarao has finally found a like-minded contemporary in Brazil's Finance Minister. Guido Mantega, The Brazilian Minister has expressed his disapproval of the US Fed's money printing policy. He believes that the QE3 method will reignite currency wars. Ones that could potentially have drastic consequences for the rest of the world. This is not the first time Mr Mantega has opposed the Fed's loose monetary policies. He even cited Japan's attempt to print cheap money, calling it a currency war. However, there are obviously few takers for Mr Mantega's conservative views. Brazil itself has cut interest rates by 5% over the past year to foster economic recovery. Trying to catch up with the US' methods of reckless money printing is a tough task for any sane central bank. Nevertheless, as our founder Ajit Dayal had written in The Honest Truth "The man with the addiction to alcohol is as addicted as the man who serves up the alcohol." Thus it remains to be seen to what extent the conservative central banks can ward off such peer pressure.

If you thought that we've had enough of the Fed largesse, you may well be wrong. Some of the Fed officials have now gone public with their views on when exactly should the Fed reverse its policy of low interest rates. And for some of them, the timeline extends well beyond FY15. Infact, they are now arguing that low interest rates should continue till the time unemployment levels in US do not come down to a specific level. An announcement of this kind will also give financial markets an idea of what policies lie ahead. Well, targeting a specific unemployment rate is fine, but what if inflation rears its head much before the target is reached? Not a chance believes one of the Fed officials. Given the past history of inflation, it is unlikely to kick in before unemployment drops significantly as per him.

Well, it's amazing how the US Fed and its bunch of officials live under the belief that the economy is a well oiled machine that responds to the pulling and pushing of certain levers. Nothing could be further from the truth though. This whole monetary experiment that the Fed is conducting is fraught with risks. And thus could easily go out of hand without giving the policymakers enough time to react. Sooner they come face to face with this reality; the better it will be we believe.

Yesterday, traders across the country observed Bharat Bandh over the controversial FDI in multi-brand retail. The question is, will this new reform adversely affect traditional Indian kirana stores?

Kirana stores typically enjoy location advantage and customer loyalty. However, they cannot compete effectively with big retailers on some fronts. For one, big retailers buy goods from suppliers in such huge quantities that they are able to negotiate better pricing terms. This, in turn, can be passed on to the final consumers. Big retailers provide ease of shopping and have a wide variety of goods and brands on offer. Given the limited space, this is difficult for kirana stores to replicate.

On the positive side, FDI in retail would bring in the much needed investments in logistics. It is mandated for foreign retailers to invest at least 50% of the FDI component in back-end infrastructure. This will certainly help reduce wastage and bring in efficiency into the system. On the negative side, big foreign retailers would affect the business of kirana stores as the latter would not be able to compete on the cost front.

Stimulus packages can give a onetime booster shot to an economy. But they cannot sustain long term growth. This is a cruel realization that has hit nearly every economy which had undertaken the strategy during the 2008 crisis. And the latest entrant to this category is none other than China. China had faced a slowdown when the crisis hit the global economy. But the country had rolled out an economic stimulus which helped it to dole out a fantastic performance till recently. However, now the country is gripped with slowing growth. And unfortunately it is expected to last longer this time around. The reason behind this is worsening external demand. With the entire world witnessing a slowdown, the demand has naturally seen a decline. This is bad for a country that relies majorly on exports to stimulate its own economy.

At the same time, policy paralysis, lower lending to smaller firms, etc have hurt domestic growth. Squeezed from both the side, the red nation is facing tough times. The need of the hour for them is reforms. Hopefully their government would realize this and enact the same. Otherwise they would be looking at bad times for quite a while. Unless they decide to give another booster shot in the form of a stimulus package. That would help things in the short term but long term problems would continue to prevail.

We are all well aware that Indian growth story is cooling down since some time now. And here is another harsh reminder for the country's shadowed prospects. The rich class in India has shrunk by 18% in 2011. In comparison; last two years witnessed India as a major growth leader. No one can deny the role of a global slowdown in the fall of investible surplus. However, with India, the problem is more internal than external. Policy paralysis in the past and high debt and inflation has shook investor's confidence leading to sagging equity market and erosion of investible wealth. This is further reflected from the fact that in contrast, Asia Pacific has surpassed any other region with regards to number of high net worth individuals (with investible wealth of USD 1 bn or more) in 2011. All we hope is that with the new package of reforms, things will change for better. But for that, the Government needs to ensure that economic logic doesn't lose in favor of political interests.

In the meanwhile, the Indian equity markets rallied through the day on hopes of further reforms by the Union government. At the time of writing, BSE Sensex was up by 343 points (1.9%). Barring IT stocks, all sectoral indices traded in the green. Asian stock markets too displayed positive investor sentiments.

 Today's investment mantra
I've found that when the market's going down and you buy funds wisely, at some point in the future you will be happy. You won't get there by reading 'Now is the time to buy.' - Peter Lynch

Today's Premium Edition.

Recent Articles

All Good Things Come to an End... April 8, 2020
Why your favourite e-letter won't reach you every week day.
A Safe Stock to Lockdown Now April 2, 2020
The market crashc has made strong, established brands attractive. Here's a stock to make the most of this opportunity...
One Stock that is All Charged Up for the Post Coronavirus Rebound April 1, 2020
A stock with strong moat is currently trading near 5-year lows.
Sorry Warren Buffett, I'm Following This Man Instead of You in 2020 March 30, 2020
This man warned of an impending market correction while everyone else was celebrating the renewed optimism in early 2020...

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "How vote bank politics will drown India?". Click here!

8 Responses to "How vote bank politics will drown India?"

Sep 24, 2012

For long the mom and pop stores have exploited the general public in India with their monopoly and pathetic customer service. If the retail giants come and kick these fellas out of business, so be it. If the kirana shops pull up their socks and make their business efficient, its a win for the customer itself.

there is no need to protect the aam baniya at the cost of the aam aadmi.



Sep 21, 2012

No body has been able to explain the high inflation in india. In spite of the 3 QEs the inflation in US is still low and the economy does not seem to pick up. So where is all this money going? well the money is comming to markets like India. The americans use the extra dollars to buy shares in india. Ofcourse the money does not go to expand the economy, it just fill the pockets of individuals trading in the market. So essentially helicopter Benanke is responsible for our inflation. Now can the RBI do something about that?



Sep 21, 2012

The word Reform in the present form is flashed as a magic wand supposed to cure all ills plaguing the country- corruption, scams, creating political vote banks, dividing people both vertically and horizontally. Why FDI in retail - to dump goods like GM stuff, to bail out China and USA to dump their ware. The constraint is "supply" side, manufacturing, Infrastructure. Restrict the FDI to these areas. Let them (FDI) invest to build Roads, dams, rivers connectivity; not store chains to sell consumer goods and get the benefit of a great consumer market for the consumer starving USA and the West. If Wall markets like stores have all that potential to lift the economy why not Greece and other European countries and USA which are struggling to survive crises in spite of numerous flashy chains they have. The so called elite are only looking at the SENSEX of 30 and not at over 120 crore people most of them are aam admi. In any event Why now? when the ruling masters credibility, integrity and acceptability at the lowest- is it not just to cover up the mes-sup?



Sep 21, 2012

This is a very short-term and lop-sided view. I ask one simple question that whether this FDI is coming as charity ? These FDI are coming to milk this country,s market and its people. They will ultimately take away thousands time more than what they will bring. This will do long-term damage to this country. Why can't the government bring FDI in infrastructure where it is much needed. Multi brand retailing can be further strengthened to likes of Pantloons, a home grown business. You people all are talking from short-term sensex movement. FDI in MULTI BRAND retailing is not in the long-term interest of the country.



Sep 21, 2012

It is a well come though belatedly by UPA. As soon it came to power this should have been done by UPA and India by this time would have moved fast and we have missed the bus, now atleast and at last woke up to catch the bus. On any account govt. shouldn't yield to pressure tactics by allies and opposition. In the same vein Govt should bring all stashed BLACK MONEY abroad to boost India's investment climate, Whether this govt. has that GUTS?????????



Sep 21, 2012

Do you actually believe that what government has announced recently are reforms?.


Suresh Kumar

Sep 21, 2012

There are far too many uncertainties for the government to handle. Starting from the state elections in November, survival till budget of 2013 by keeping allies under CBI radar, controlling inflation, controlling ill-effects of scam and expanding welfare schemes, the list is long. Also, the window time available for reforms is rather limited. MMS is late by almost 2 years. If all the above could be achieved, MMS would be remembered for long. But, the picture is far from rosy as of now.


Umesh Sharma

Sep 21, 2012

It is not really clear as to how FDI investment in retail will help India.Whatever investment comes will be for trading purpose and will be in the form of goods which will be sold here at a profit.If they are so much attracted by our retail markets they can liberalize the migration of local people to their respective countries to improve the demand there. Are they interested? certainly not.They want to exploit the available market for making profits.And whatever money they pour in will be shifted at any time at their sweet will putting pressure on our currency.If they really want to take up investment they can look for development of solar energy conversion on a large scale so that their investment will be useful for everybody and whatever profits they generate will not be grudged.They can go in for infrastructure development, Sea bed excavation etc.Where they will add to our GDP and the investment will be welcome by everyone.What is the point in disrupting the business cycle which is already established.They can only add to costs and make the goods dearer that is why there is opposition to their entry in retail business.Their money power will sound the death knell of the small traders who cannot compete with them.So FDI in retail business is a great danger

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "How vote bank politics will drown India?". Click here!