Does 2011 remind you of 2008?

Sep 23, 2011

In this issue:
» US economy is doing a Japan
» Is the RBI independent enough?
» Crisis could lead to protectionist policies
» Bidding wars intensify in infrastructure
» ...and more!

Investors the world over are certainly not likely to forget September 2008. In that month Lehman Brothers collapsed and so massive was the scale of sell-off in the global markets, that emerging countries including India were badly impacted. In India too, despite the fact that its economy was better off than the US and Europe, foreign investors pulled money out of the stock markets in droves, causing a meltdown in Indian indices.

And after the drubbing that Indian markets received yesterday, there are fears that we may see a repeat of what happened in late 2008. Between the Lehman collapse and today, emerging countries especially Brazil, Russia, India, China (BRIC), staged a remarkable recovery that saw GDP growing at a much faster pace than its developed peers. This once again brought a flock of foreign investors to their shores as conditions in the West continued to deteriorate. Because of this over exuberance, the kind of liquidity that was unleashed in China and India especially was so strong, that both these countries had to step in and tighten rates in a bid to curb inflationary pressures. And now, prolonged crisis in the developed world and the massive sell-off yesterday has once again exposed the vulnerability of emerging nations to capital flight.

Indeed, even though growth in the emerging countries is expected to slowdown, the latter are still way ahead of the US and Europe who are riddled with excess debt and recessionary conditions. It is not that developing countries are immune to the crisis enveloping the West, but it can be said that over a longer term perspective, the strong growth prospects in the former still remain intact. This means that serious long term investors can find value if they remain invested in these countries with a longer investment horizon. The problem is that because global markets are so interlinked, panic in the Western stock markets is bound to have an impact on emerging markets including India. But any such pessimism should be looked upon as an opportunity by investors to buy good quality stocks are bargain prices.

Do you think emerging countries will be able to entirely do away with the risk of capital flight? Share with us or post your comments on our Facebook page.---------------------------------------------------------- Free Video ----------------------------------------------------------

Earlier today we recorded a short video with Asad Dossani discussing derivative trading ideas that you could profit from. This video, which was released just a few minutes back, is absolutely Free for you.

Quick! Be among the first to view this video! Click Here!


 Chart of the day
IMF's (International Monetary Fund) GDP forecasts for 2011 and 2012 do not really paint a rosy picture. As today's chart of the day shows, although China and India lead the pack, growth rates would still not match what they were in the last couple of years. This is not surprising given that both economies are battling inflation as a result of which their central banks have been tightening interest rates. Despite this, both these countries are way ahead of the rest of the pack in terms of growth.

Data Source: The Economist

With the US economy failing to show any signs of recovery despite huge stimuli, comparisons with the late 20th century Japan are inevitable. Thus, it has come as no surprise when Stephen Roach, the famous economist and currently, Morgan Stanley Asia non-executive Chairman, has done exactly the same. Roach has opined that America is in a Japan like situation but the likes of Bernanke and Obama are not willing to acknowledge or even consider this harsh reality. However, he has not chosen to put the entire blame on the current US Fed Chairman and has said that those who ran the Fed before Bernanke deserve blame as well. It should be noted that Japan faced nearly a decade in economic doldrums, a period which is now famously called as the 'The Lost Decade'. It isn't that Japan didn't do anything to escape from this misery. It adopted the exact same policies as the US is adopting currently but they had no effect whatsoever. All it ended up doing was keeping alive banks and corporations that otherwise were nothing but dead. Needless to say, the US is hurtling dangerously towards the very same outcome. A lost decade redux anyone?

If Dr Y. V Reddy would have been an American central banker, the US would have not been in the kind of economic muddle that it is in today! That is the briefest explanation of what an independent central banker can do to an economy. We came across an article in Mint that discusses whether the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) is independent enough. Well, if you ask us, all we can say is that we are lucky Mr Alan Greenspan did not work for the RBI. For an organization is only as efficient as its leaders are. RBI is not constitutionally independent. In fact the Finance Ministry can overrule the central bank's decisions if it deems fit. Over the years Finance Ministers in India have had clashes with regard to monetary policy decisions of the RBI. But it took somebody like Dr Reddy to oppose the then Finance Minister Mr Chidambaram's views and hold a cautious stance on interest rates. He was amongst the very few central bankers in 2007 who refused to lower rates citing inflationary risks from high oil prices. More recently Dr Subbarao too has shown some signs of independence despite being an ex Finance Ministry official. We believe that as long as the selection of the RBI governor remains independent of political pressure, the Indian central bank will continue to do its job well!

The current crisis appears to be spreading across the world. This is the warning signal sounded off by the World Bank's Chief, Mr Robert Zoellick. He has stated that the way things are going the developing world would start sounding off negative signals very soon. As per him, more than 40% of the developing countries have budget deficits of over 4% of GDP. As a result, if things get worse, they would see major drop in asset prices as well as an increase in nonperforming loans. This in turn would lead to protectionist and populist measures being adopted by these countries. Combine this with the troubles in the advanced economies and we have the perfect recipe for a global turmoil. Things could turn out to be different if the emerging markets decide to adopt long term approach to growth rather than adopting a narrow approach. Look to the long term rather than trying to find a quick fix for short term problems. A quick fix does not really help anyone. Just ask the developed countries if you don't believe us.

It's dragon versus elephant again. And this time the standoff is over South Chinese Sea. It is worthwhile to note that South Chinese Sea is one of the world's key shipping routes and is believed to store rich oil and gas reserves. Recently, China has made a diplomatic protest over ONGC's joint exploration plans with Vietnam blaming it for violation of its sovereignty. The area no doubt is strategic. Its ownership will be crucial in bargaining power in future negotiations. It is important to note that Vietnam is one among the many nations that China is involved in territorial disputes with while India has US's support to freely navigate the region.

Maintaining friendly relations with China are of a strategic importance to India. However, knowing how crucial energy resources will be on way to be a global super power, such tussles will be unavoidable. And we believe that in the quest for energy security, it is a reason worth the diplomatic fight.

It is a well known fact that India's infrastructure is in dire straits. And in order to resolve this issue, government has targeted huge infrastructure investments over the next five years. But considering the fiscal position of the government private sector participation seems to be imminent. This presents huge business opportunities for infrastructure developers which has completely changed the competitive scenario in the industry. Fierce bidding and offering negative grants for road projects have been a common phenomenon. The bids, nowadays, have become so competitive that even minor time and cost over-runs could put the margin profile at risk. And considering that the industry already operates on wafer thin margins unanticipated price inflation or bureaucratic delays could make these competitive bids unviable. While buffering order pipeline through fierce bidding secures future revenue visibility it would seriously test the execution skills of these companies. Nonetheless, such an aggressive bidding climate is good for the nation where quality infrastructure is a luxury as against deemed public good.

In the meanwhile, the Indian stock markets continued their southward journey today. At the time of writing, the benchmark BSE-Sensex was down by 150 points (0.9%). Barring IT and FMCG stocks, all sectoral indices were trading weak. Red marks were seen across Asia too with Indonesia (up by 0.8%) being the only exception. South Korea was the biggest loser down by a huge 5.8% and Taiwan was next in line (down 3.6% from yesterday's closing).

 Today's investing mantra
"There are two times in a man's life when he should not speculate - when he can't afford it and when he can." - Mark Twain

Today's Premium Edition.

Recent Articles

All Good Things Come to an End... April 8, 2020
Why your favourite e-letter won't reach you every week day.
A Safe Stock to Lockdown Now April 2, 2020
The market crashc has made strong, established brands attractive. Here's a stock to make the most of this opportunity...
One Stock that is All Charged Up for the Post Coronavirus Rebound April 1, 2020
A stock with strong moat is currently trading near 5-year lows.
Sorry Warren Buffett, I'm Following This Man Instead of You in 2020 March 30, 2020
This man warned of an impending market correction while everyone else was celebrating the renewed optimism in early 2020...

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Does 2011 remind you of 2008?". Click here!

10 Responses to "Does 2011 remind you of 2008?"

Divyesh Parikh

Sep 24, 2011

In this world of overload of run of the mill analysis, it is refreshing to come across small pieces of articles/analysis which is though centered on economics yet diversified, crisp, informative, intelligent and well written.

Keep up the good work.



Sep 24, 2011


As usual your article is bang on the point. If Mr. Reddy would have bowed to Mr.PC, we would have been in much deeper trouble. As I have read earlier, Mr. Reddy had been to US during 2005-06 and he had discreetly studied how their economy and the financial mrkts were run. He was very wary of the hybrid derivative products sold by the Banks, and was much aware of the sub-prime problem likely to blow over. Only time could not be told, he was sure that it is going to lead to massive problems. And thus when he was asked to lower the rates, he firmly refused and stood his ground. The result is for everyone to see. Today all over the world RBI Governor is respected. May be they are not poster boys like those of the West, but yes they do command respect. Same is the case with the present Mr. Subba Rao and considering his cautious stance, one more hike of .25percent basis point is expected in October. Present conditons point to such amove. Unless Europeans come off with some magical wand to mitigate and remove their financial problems, a cautious and hawkish outlook will be beneficial for India. (Industry captains will not agree - but the common man will be saved of future problems)
Mrkts will trade down and Nifty will test 4720, and if on 29th German Chancellor Angela Morkel losses her re-election, than Europe will be in bigger problem. Why should Germans pay for the miss deeds of PIGS ?? that is the question, germans are asking.


Adi Daruwalla

Sep 24, 2011

While it is imprtant that the process to select the RBI governors is independent, in the future the sucession of the current governor should also be filled by people who are capable and will match the calibre of the likes of Dr. Y V Reddy and Dr. Subbarao. I have heard Dr. Reddy speak on financial issues and his brillance was reflected in his speech.



Sep 23, 2011

Dear sir, I appreciate your view point regarding the previous and present Governors of our central Bank. Dr Y V Reddy indeed stood his ground against the populistic policies of the Government,by not succumbing to the pressures of the then FM, Sri. Chidambaram. He acted as a deterrent to short sighted, politically motivated designs of our Government. Or we would have been reeling under triple digit inflation by now!!. Thanks to Sri. Rao who also stood his ground. Though the stated policies could not tame the inflation as desired, it stopped the galloping tendency of inflation giving some relief to the common man. As all know, as far as huge black money is in circulation, taming inflation will remain only a distant dream, and common man will have to live with increasing interest rate and high inflation as they work against each other!!


Vikash Kandhway

Sep 23, 2011

Extremely competitive bids can be two way sword. It can be: 1)They have extremely innovative solutions which will help the companies make decent profits.2)They will cut corners at all possible places. Thus such infrastructure may be built to last only the BO part of BOT. This will mean India will be back to square one. 3) These companies are pursuing a strategy to first corner the projects and then sometime in future go back to the government saying that they can't implement if the prices are not raised and pull strings to have their way. This will the same strategy adopted by the telecom companies in the 90s when the Indian Government first sold spectrum. At that time players with no background in mobile telephony or anything remotely related to it first cornered the spectrum putting in extremely high bids. Then they went back to government in late 90s saying that they can't survive if License fee is not reduced. I hope these companies are not pursuing the second and the third option.


sunilkumar tejwani

Sep 23, 2011

agreed that emerging economies will do well in the long run. But in the near future the excess liquidity injected by rotten economies has to take a flight back home. This will create some downside in the emerging economies for a short while. In such situation one should invest in emerging markets especially India due to strong base & ability to withstand external shocks.But one should invest in stocks which will really lift the economy. One should avoid sectors which are destructive in nature like real estate (corporate and governance issues) same with infra companies & auto sector.


Alexander Kurien

Sep 23, 2011

Dear Sirs,

1. Your article contents are great indeed !
2. The crisis during 2008 was a 'collapse of very large companies' of the financial world, a very serious one indeed. The crisis during 2011, seemed at onset, one of a lesser degree, and potential salvage seemed within the idealogical limits of the main salvors: Germany, and France. But now, it appears clearly to be one, where both these potential salvors are slowly losing their zeal, mainly because of the financial quantum involved in the excercise, also, it is slowly getting to be a 'catch 22' situation - to salvage is a big problem, NOT to salvage seems equally a big problem for their own futures (Germany would have to get back to their DM currency, which would be valued sky-high at re-launch itself; in comparison, the Euro currency provides them the balancing factor). It seems the 2011 crisis would be a collapse of nations - a much bigger problem, with the potential to severely impact the overall global financial system(s).

Warm regards


nikesh shah

Sep 23, 2011

1 Responses to "Does 2011 remind you of 2008?" only in currency


Kartik Dadia

Sep 23, 2011

Sometimes we IFAs are looking for ANSWERS..
After reading this edition of 5 minute wrapup.. i have some of them now atleast..

Regards for the amount of pain taken to bring out ground realities

Best wishes


shome suvra

Sep 23, 2011

India has underperformed for so many years that it has the potential of high growth provided the inflation comes down.The inter linkages of global economy can't be underestimated which is bound to impact the capital flight.

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Does 2011 remind you of 2008?". Click here!