Should you invest in IPOs in a volatile market?

Dec 10, 2011

In this issue:
» India's GDP per person to double fast
» Nilekani's UID project in trouble?
» German banks are facing capital shortfall
» MF Global's Corzine has no clue where the money is
» and more!
----------------------------- Now get free daily updates on Global Economy! -----------------------------

Will Italy be able to get back on its feet again?

Will Euro die faster than the Dollar?

Will China now replace US as the new superpower?

Know all that's going on in the global markets through the free daily financial e-column The Daily Reckoning.

Authored by Bill Bonner, a three-time New York Times best-selling author, the Daily Reckoning is published in 3 languages and is read by millions of people across the globe.

Sign up now for free updates on global markets!


The heady years of 2006 and 2007 saw a slew of initial public offers (IPOs) hit the Indian stock markets. Because of the heavy bullishness then, many of these IPOs quoted astronomical valuations but still enjoyed heavy subscriptions on account of very positive sentiments. But all that changed when the global financial crisis hit the world in 2008-09.

Since then the IPO market has been going through choppy waters and while the going was good last year, the trend seems to have reversed this year. According to Ernst & Young, Indian companies mopped up barely US$ 1.14 bn through IPOs till November this year. This is around an 89% plunge over last year. The number of IPOs was less than half of that last year, and stood at 34 in the first 11 months of 2011 as compared to 71 in 2010. The deepening debt crisis in Europe and the lack of solution thereof, rising inflation and slowdown in growth in India and policy paralysis in the government have spooked stock markets and contributed to the increasing volatility. This has then made companies wary of raising capital through the IPO route. PSU share sales as part of the government's divestment programme have also petered out. Not surprisingly, this phenomenon is not unique to India and has been seen in Asian as well as the global stock markets with the number of deals and new issues drastically reducing.

The problem for Indian companies is that debt is not cheap either. With inflation remaining perisistently high, interest rates have risen and this has made cost of debt dearer. Further, foreign currency loans have their own set of problems with the rupee depreciating at such a steep pace.

Having said that, businesses need to grow and growing businesses need capital. The crux here is that those wanting to access capital through IPOs need to price them reasonably. Readers would do well to recall that last year saw the government divest their stake in a number of PSU companies. Many of these companies had strong growth prospects but the icing on the cake was that quite a few were attractively valued and held the potential of strong returns for investors. We believe that this holds true even in a volatile market. As long as companies have sound business models with a strong management and reasonable valuations, there is no reason why investors should not invest in these companies whether they are raising capital for the first time or are already listed on the stock exchanges.

Will you invest in the IPO of a company with strong growth prospects and reasonable valuations in a volatile stock market? Share with us or post your comments on our Facebook page / Google+ page.

 Chart of the day
As the economies of the developing countries grow at a faster pace than their developed peers, so will their GDP per person. As today's chart of the day shows, the GDP per person for India and China will double in less than 10 years from 2011. Developed economies have been in a state of turmoil ever since the global financial crisis unraveled and it will be some time before they are able to show any meaningful sign of recovery. Little wonder then that the growth in GDP per person in their respective economies will not be able to keep pace than that of their developing peers.

Data Source: The Economist

"I simply don't know where the money is." You could be excused from assuming that this comment was passed by some low level employee of a financial institution. But if the CEO utters the very same words, something is hugely amiss. Indeed, these remarks passed by Jon Corzine, the ex-CEO of now defunct MF Global has not gone down well with the close followers of the saga. They would have hurt the company's clients the most as chances of recovering more than US$ 1 bn of their own money have weakened considerably. It should be noted that MF Global recently filed for bankruptcy as it found itself caught in the downward spiral of ratings downgrade and liquidity shortfall followed by more downgrade and more liquidity shortfall.

What made matters worse was the sudden vanishing act performed by nearly US$ 1 bn worth of funds from clients' accounts that is supposed to be kept segregated from the firm's money used for making risky bets. And what the clients are getting from the CEO of the firm when asked about the whereabouts of their hard earned money? Well, nothing more than a shrug of the shoulder and a terse 'I don't know the location of the funds'. If you are thinking that Mr Corzine may land himself in prison after all this, banish the thought. He may still be able to go scot free. No wonder, the US society is in a state of turmoil right now.

2011 has been a bad year for the ruling government. Already haunted by the ghosts of the infamous scams, the government came under further criticism thanks to their policy inactions. Things became worse when they decided to backtrack on the issue of Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) in retail just days after approving it. Now it is likely that the government will do another U-turn on another popular project. This time the project under the spotlight is the UIDAI or the unique ID project that was started under the supervision of Nandan Nilekani. The parliamentary standing committee on finance is of the opinion that the Rs 178 bn UIDAI project is costly, unnecessary and will lead to communal disharmony in the country. They also feel that the project is just a duplication of data already collected under the National Population Register. The biometric data collected for UIDAI is also under the scanner with the committee stating that the data is a privacy breach and could be misused.

The thing is that the project is a brilliant idea to ensure that people have a single identification card that takes care of their social security, their voting rights and everything in between. Thus, the question that one needs to ask is whether the concerns raised by politicians genuine? Or are the so called 'intelligent' politicians threatened by Mr Nilekani's presence. He is after all not a politician but an ex-bureaucrat. Nevertheless, by the looks of it, another good proposal of the government is headed down the drain.

The troubles for Eurozone seem to be getting worse. The latest series of stress tests done on banks in Europe have revealed that the German banks are facing much severe capital shortfall than what was previously estimated. The amount of Euro 13.1 bn payable by next June is almost three times larger than the earlier estimates and has worsened the Euro deficit to Euro 115 bn, up 8%. The recent disclosure is another set back to the Eurozone and could be a pre cursor to further misuse of taxpayers' funds to bail out the sinking ships or nationalization of banks, something that time will tell. However, one thing is for sure. It is a huge blow to the credibility of European banking authority and overshadows the recent announcements regarding rate cuts and measures to support ailing regional banks. It could mean a long period of slow lending, something that triggered the worst recession in American economy three years back.

Unfortunately, the damage does not stop here. Given that European economy is one of the biggest, the ripple effect will spread far and wide. It could send US economy in the reverse gear that has recently managed to improve in the last few months.

With the ongoing European debt crisis and slowing down in world economy, the stock markets around the world have seen a sharp correction. So in the midst of such uncertainty, what is the outlook for equities, Euro and China? According to Marc Faber, publisher of the Gloom, Boom & Doom report, US equities are not terribly expensive relatively to other assets and if some good news comes out of Europe, it could lead to a rally in equities. On the outlook for Euro, he expects the Euro to survive. It may survive without the weaker countries or it could survive theoretically just as a currency aside from local currencies. So one could travel anywhere in Europe and still pay Euros. He also preferred holding gold rather than the US Dollar or Euro. As far as China was concerned he was not bullish on investing in that country. However he warned that any slowdown in China could have adverse impact on the world economy because the Chinese economy today has a much larger impact on the rest of the world than is generally perceived. We certainly advocate Faber's view on gold given that the importance of paper currencies has been rendered quite meaningless on the back of rampant money printing.

After witnessing a sharp bounce back in the last week, the world markets were not able to hold on to the gains and corrected in this week's trade. The US stock markets were up 1.4% during the week. Hopes that better fiscal integration measures by the European countries will help resolve the debt crisis fuelled market sentiments. Trade deficit numbers reported by the US were also encouraging while the consumer confidence index surprised positively propelling further buying interest.

However, the Indian stock markets were down 3.8% during the week after the government lowered the full year Gross Domestic Product (GDP) growth target and disclosed that meeting the fiscal target would also prove to be a challenge. Apart from this, decision to put Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) in multi-brand retail on a hold also made investors jittery.

Amongst the other markets, Brazil was up 0.6% while France was flat with gains of 0.2%. However, Singapore and China lost considerable ground and ended the week on a negative note.

Data Source: Yahoo Finance

 Weekend Investing Mantra
"An investment operation is one which, upon thorough analysis, promises safety of principal and an adequate return. Operations not meeting these requirements are speculative." - Benjamin Graham

Today's Premium Edition.

Recent Articles

All Good Things Come to an End... April 8, 2020
Why your favourite e-letter won't reach you every week day.
A Safe Stock to Lockdown Now April 2, 2020
The market crashc has made strong, established brands attractive. Here's a stock to make the most of this opportunity...
One Stock that is All Charged Up for the Post Coronavirus Rebound April 1, 2020
A stock with strong moat is currently trading near 5-year lows.
Sorry Warren Buffett, I'm Following This Man Instead of You in 2020 March 30, 2020
This man warned of an impending market correction while everyone else was celebrating the renewed optimism in early 2020...

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Should you invest in IPOs in a volatile market?". Click here!

10 Responses to "Should you invest in IPOs in a volatile market?"


Dec 11, 2011

Promoters of IPOs are always very reasonable, but only to themselves. That is why it is, 'I Piyo, I Jiyo', rest go to hell.



Dec 11, 2011

Today's IPOs are almost fully priced at their issue price. If there are really good companies in need of money, they'd rather go to angel investors/venture capitalists who can supply the money without putting restrictions that going public brings. Hence, in today's market, it is a virtual guarantee that if not a loss, a retail investors will have to wait several years to see even moderate appreciation of their investment. Even for good companies, in today's market, an IPO can best hope to get one 9-10% returns p.a. over a 3-5 year period.
Regarding, UID, I'm on the side of the Finance JPC. I utterly fail to understand the intention of UID after all the efforts undertaken to systematize everything using PAN. Is the intention of UID to replace PAN? If so, nobody has made it clear in the UID project that that is the eventual goal. Today, UID is issued even to illegal Bangladeshi immigrants, purely based on the fact that they are now in India and that's the sole eligibility to getting a UID! Having Nandan Nilekani at the helm doesn't give the project any more legality or authority than otherwise.
I would think that the UID project is an exercise in futility.
A final word on the GDP doubling in 10 years...A growth rate of only 7% will give us that, provided we are able to sustain it. Please keep in mind the amount of resources required to grow and maintain a GDP twice today's size. It is naive to think that India's high growth in the past have somehow been independent of lower growth of developed countries. It is virtually guaranteed that if developed countries growth slows or stalls, India will also feel the heat and its GDP growth will also be stunted. The Chart does not capture this!



Dec 11, 2011

It was very clear to me and confident that UId Project will never get implemented properly as the Politicians would never allow that under the current indian situation.It is good this project is not funded now itself instead of scrapping the project after spending lakhs of crores. Nandan is also an arrogantperson and should have handled such delicate things in a more diplomatic manner, than behaving high handedly.He made some stupid statements on Anna that was not asked for or warranted.Now he would learn i hope.


Radheshyam Sharma

Dec 11, 2011

The IPO market has been spoilt by greedy promoters and merchant bankers.
In the 80s and earlier, most of the IPo were at par or with a premium of Rs20 or 30 or even 40/-.
I had got 400 shares of Dr. Reddy in those days at Rs 40/- per share.
Now, most promoters connive with the merchant bankers to raise the issue price to such an extent that investors can seldom make any profit.
Unless merchant bankers who recommend such dud issues are banned, the IPo market will always be weak.
Further, the previous track record of all the promoters should be exposed to show how their previous issues have fared.
Investors have realized the they are being made fools.



Dec 11, 2011

Certainly YES - if the IPO is from a reputed house about Retail.We have enough senior NBAs from IIMs, enough industries to build cold storages enough roads, enough supply chain managers and enough sales outlets. Who needs FDI?


Daniel Varghese

Dec 10, 2011

No, never in a volatile market, eventhough the company is fundamentally strong.



Dec 10, 2011

Re Nilekani's project, I think that the politicians woke up just now and realised that if the subsidies are directly delivered to the bank accounts their 'cuts'( estimated at over 60%) would disappear. Further, the 'ghosts' benificiaries will disappear if bio metric They are now united beyond party lines to oppose it!


Dharam Dabas

Dec 10, 2011

Yes, this will be good opportunity givine good return when situation improves.



Dec 10, 2011

Micro investments in IPOS would atleast pep up the momentum fora a strong base.



Dec 10, 2011

Looking to the performance of the copmpanies whoissued PUBlic Offer duringthe last three years,the IPOs are to be boycotted by the investors in future. (90% of the IPOs have given negative return to the investors .The loss vary from 10% to 95% .It is cruel joke and deliberate attempt by the promoters to loot the investors through public Issues . Even teh public sector companies have issued shares at a very high price leaving no room for the investors to gain from the IPOS.
Earlier days the companies were not freeto fix premiums and they had to be approved by the ROC and controller of capital issues where they ware not allowed to loot the public by charging unreasonable premiums. Now even before acquiring the land for the factories the IPOs are with hefty premium,The merchant bankers are joining hands with cruel promotors to charge heavy premium.SEBi and the stock exchanges do not bother to verify the rationale for the chargfing the heavy premiums.Some companies manage to get the IPS listed at a premium hihger than the issue price by malpractices. But aftera few tradings sessions the prices go negative.
It is therefore neessary for the government agencies, SEBi and Stock exhanges and other government authorities to verify the credentials aof the promotors and the valuiation of their companies and No company should be allowed to issue shars with unreasonable premiums. Unless the investors get a reasonable return why should they invest. To have healthy capital market and for the success of companies it is necessary that the investors should get atleast 10 to 20% return from IPOs Then only investors get onfiodence in investing.
I hope the authorties and agencies concerned willbe vigilant in future.In the meantime investors should boycott the public issues

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Should you invest in IPOs in a volatile market?". Click here!