Well, let's look at where we are. In 2007, the private sector hit a wall. It couldn't go any further. It had too much debt. Lenders and investors were beginning to realize that the debt wouldn't be repaid.
Billions...maybe trillions...of dollars had been lent to people who were not really creditworthy...on the basis of collateral that wasn't worth what they thought it was worth. Housing was in a bubble. It had doubled in the previous 10 years...after only tracking inflation over the 100 years before that. Houses had become so over-priced that the average house was far out of range for the average buyer. And the housing industry was turning out millions more of them!
The leveraging up process had run for 60 years. It began at the close of WWII. It would have come to an end long before, but the feds and their pet economists had a theory. When an economy began to 'correct'...that is, to lay off the BS debt and BS businesses and the BS speculations - the feds thought they should step in to stop it. They thought that a healthy economy always grows. Recessions - or corrections - were things that needed to be eliminated, like lice.
And their theory told them how to do it. When businessmen and investors started to come to their senses and correct their mistakes, the feds would give them more of the elixir that got them so giddy in the first place - cash and credit.
This approach 'worked" for many years - in the sense that the feds were able to stymie corrections and keep the economy in growth mode. More jobs. More spending. More output. More debt.
Is the theory sound? No. If you don't correct a child for saying nasty things to his grandmother sooner or later he'll rob a bank. That's our counter-theory. An economy needs a correction from time to time. Mistakes are always made, even by the smartest entrepreneur and the most mathematically-gifted speculator. If these mistakes are not corrected...they compound. The mistakes don't go away. And people don't learn from them. Instead, they continue making the same mistake until the thing blows up.
Take forests. Nature has a way of clearing out the dead underbrush. Forest fires. Stop the little forest fires and you get a much bigger conflagration later.
Nassim Taleb uses the example of restaurants. Imagine a world in which bad restaurants never went out of business. The food would be horrible in all restaurants...because it's easier and cheaper to prepare bad food than good food...and there would be no penalty for bad cooking.
Or, what about airline pilots? Suppose they get drunk in the cockpit. Do you fire them? Or put them at the controls of a new Dreamliner?
Without corrections, the dead wood...the bad food...the incompetent, lazy, stupid, and disastrous things people do... would not be systematically eliminated. We'd have a zombie world....waiting for the Zombie Apocalypse.
Little corrections prevent big ones.
But the feds are trying to put a stop to the debt correction. They want to do it in the worst possible way...by adding more debt!
Will this stop the private sector from correcting?
Here's Gary Shilling:
The current domestic and global investing environment is dominated by deleveraging, according to Gary Shilling.
In other words, households and institutions are slashing the debt on their balance sheets.
And according to Shilling, we still have some way to go:
"The deleveraging process for both these sectors has commenced, but it has a long way to go to return to the long run flat trends and we are strong believers in reversions to well-established trend. If we simply extend the downward slopes, it will take the Financial sector 9.5 more years to return to trend as bank assets continue to be dumped and capital raised, and 8.3 more years for the Household sector as debts are repaid or written off and assets are rebuilt through a rising saving rate
...We continue to suggest about five more years of deleveraging, however, since adding that to the 2008-2012 initial span would bring the total to about 10 years. That's the normal length of deleveraging after major financial bubbles, according to Carmen Reinhardt and Kenneth Rogoff's book, This Time Is Different: Eight Centuries of Financial Folly."
And the power of deleveraging according to Shilling is "gigantic", because it is offsetting tremendous amounts of stimulus:
"Witness the fact that despite all the fiscal and monetary stimuli here and abroad since 2008, economic growth remains slow at best.
No one...not Gary Shilling...not no one...knows what will happen exactly. But we do know something: debt is dangerous. It makes the debtor vulnerable to shocks. And the way it is distributed by the feds - to industries, a financial sector, and households - makes them vulnerable too. All depend on a fantasy: that you can continue borrowing and spending...practically forever.
The feds are printing money -- $84 billion a month. Fed asset holdings - the nation's monetary foundation - are going up 5 times in 5 years. And the real GAAP accounting US deficit is growing 20 times as fast as US GDP.
Warning: The feds are making a big mistake. Just wait until it is corrected!
Bill Bonner is the President & Founder of Agora Inc, an international publisher of financial and special interest books and newsletters.