The Outside View: Still on the road to moksha... - The Daily Reckoning
The Daily Reckoning by Bill Bonner
On This Day - 20 March 2010
The Outside View: Still on the road to moksha... A  A  A

Mr. Bill Bonner is visiting India to discover his next trade of the decade. We present his observations and comments on his first hand experience of living in India. We have received the approval of Mr. Bill Bonner to carry this article.

Mumbai, India

Friday, 19 March 2010

Still on the road to moksha...

Prices are rising in India - pushed up by the high cost of food. Thanks partly to a disastrous government policy of encouraging the over-use of chemical fertilizer, food prices are shooting up. In a poor country, food is a bigger part of the family budget than in a rich country. India's CPI is rising at about 11%.

Flash from the Times of India:

A man brought his wife to Mumbai from Aurangabad. He then took her to the house of someone she didn't know and told her to wait there for him to come back. But he didn't return. The wife asked the owner of the house what was going on. She was informed that she had been sold to the man for 40,000 rupees (a bit less than $1,000). Her family back in Aurangabad came to her rescue. They bought her back.

A thousand dollars seems like a lot of money to pay for a wife. Especially when you consider all the expenses that come later. Food, shelter, transportation, Gucci, BMW, and so forth...

But it's just another proof that the feds are winning! They're reflating the least to some extent.

Stocks rose again yesterday - largely on the good feelings inspired by Ben Bernanke. The US Fed chief let it be known that if the economy slips back into a slump it won't be his fault.

The Dow rose again - 45 points. Gold went up $3. Oil gushed up over $82.

That's the 22nd time in the last 27 sessions that the Dow has gone up. And it's now above its high for this its highest point in 17 months. This brings US stocks back to their levels of....

...1999! Is that progress, or what?

Emerging markets, meanwhile - at least the BRICs - are back too. They're back at 1995 levels.

Emerging economies are using this new appetite for risk to sell a record amount of debt. When the crisis came in '07, the spread in rates - between emerging market debts and US debts - widened. People knew they could count on Uncle Sam to pay up. They weren't so sure about India, Argentina and Zanzibar. So, the yields on emerging market debt rose.

But now that the feds' program of reflation seems to be working, they're going to take a flyer on emerging market bonds. They're still a little riskier than US bonds (or so buyers believe) but they have higher yields.

Here in India, for example, a portfolio of municipal and corporate bonds is paying more than 9% interest.

Hey, wait a minute...isn't the inflation rate 11%?

"Well, that's an aberration," explains an analyst. "It's caused by rising prices for food. The long-term inflation rate is only about 5% or 6%. But the real play on Indian debt is in the currency. The rupee is a relatively strong currency. India just doesn't have the debt problems that you have in America. Our bet is that you can earn 9% on the bonds and maybe another 50% as the rupee strengthens..."

The investor in Indian bonds has Ben Bernanke on his side. So does the investor in gold.

Bernanke told the world that he'll keep rates at zero for as long as it takes...

...but that's not all...

The Fed also announced that it was changing its policy. It said so in such a subtle way that most people probably missed it - including us. We only realized what it had done when we read an analysis this morning in the Financial Times.

In the past, the Fed has been "evaluating" the impact of buying up mortgages in order to support the housing (and presumably even the commercial property) market. Now, it says it "will employ its policy tools as necessary to promote economic recovery and price stability."

Monetizing private sector debt certainly promotes the hell out of something...but we doubt it really promotes either economic recovery or price stability. What it promotes is the eventual destruction of the dollar...and the US bond market. Behind the bonds stands the dollar. And behind the dollar stands the Fed. The Fed is telling us that it is ready to stab the dollar in the back in order to keep up the illusion of 'recovery.'

The Fed's $1.7 trillion bond buying program - quantitative easing - is supposed to come to an end at the end of this month. We were looking forward to seeing what happened when the biggest player in the market - a buyer - dropped out. Now it looks as though the Fed might not drop out after all.

Yes, dear reader, the US is still on the road to financial moksha (the final liberation from the cares of this world...achieved by a Hindu sect - the Jains - by starvation.)

More news...

And more thoughts...

*** We've been staying at the Taj Mahal Hotel for almost two weeks. What a great hotel. Calm. Civilized. Air conditioned! Every day, we come back from a hard day at work and settle into a comfortable wicker chair by the pool.

Last night, to deepen our research into the real India we went to a concert hall for a jazz performance by Mike Stern and then over to the Oberoi for dinner.

"Middle-class Americans are screwed," said a dinner companion. We were dining with an NRI - a non-resident Indian, who is a professor at an American university in California.

"I drove through Santa Clara yesterday. There were 'for sale' and 'vacancy' signs all over the place. And this is in a city that has some of the fastest-growing and most profitable businesses in the country. This is Silicon Valley...

"The numbers are a little misleading. They show the average American doing more or less okay. But the numbers are skewed by the top 1%. At the top of the pyramid, Americans are doing very well. They have savings. They have investments. They have businesses that are profitable...sometimes very profitable. And they've done well in this rally that we've had for the last year...

"But you go down the socio-economic ladder and you find pain and suffering all over the place. Businesses are learning to be more profitable...largely by not hiring Americans...

"Here in India, the per capita income is only about $1,000 a year. And that means that half the population, more than 500 million people, have less than $1,000 per year...or less than, say, $3 per day to live on.

"In the US, it's 30 to 40 times higher. But both groups speak English. Both groups can do simple tasks that don't require much training...

"So, if you're a smart US-based business, what are you going to do? You're going to outsource, if you can. You know, there are now personal assistants in India working for ordinary people in the US and Europe. They figured out that many executives -- and other people, for that matter - communicate with their personal assistants via email. And most of what personal assistants do - making reservations...following up on customer service issues...tracking this and that - is also done via email. In the US you'd pay a good personal assistant maybe $50,000 a year. Instead, you pay an Indian personal assistant $3,000 per year. Maybe you don't get 100% of the service you got. But maybe you just get 50%. It's still a great deal...

"And suppose you're going to make something. And suppose you need a lot of labor to do it. Where do you go? To Detroit? Or to Delhi? In Detroit you have expensive labor that is theoretically better trained but used to not working very hard...

"The problem for India is that people are very poorly educated. They're supposed to be able to speak English, for example. But they can't. And even when they do speak English, you won't be able to understand them.

"And the infrastructure in India is notoriously bad. So, even if you can make something very inexpensively, there's no guarantee that you'll be able to deliver it.

"We're seeing American companies that are getting things made in China - because everything works better there - and then selling them in India cheaper than we can make them ourselves. This is great for the owners of the American company. But it doesn't do the working class any good."

*** We've been studying other people at the hotel. We watch them come and go as we eat breakfast or have a drink after work. There are few rich couples enjoying a holiday... Some Arabs. Some Americans. Large groups of Japanese tourists...a group of middle-aged Germans... The occasional back-packer, often Australian... An older man, big...overfed and over-pleased with himself...from Milwaukee or Dusseldorf... with an elegant woman from Thailand. Eager and earnest businessmen from Europe and Japan, huddling in small groups. Teams of consultants from the US, casually dressed...confident...often a few pretty girls among them, ready to give bad advice at a high price.

There was even a large assembly of mid-level bureaucrats from the USA. They sat near us at breakfast...talking endlessly about 'dialoguing' with their Indian peers. God help anyone who takes them seriously or pays their salaries...


Bombay Dreams

By Bill Bonner

We have come to Bombay to get a good look at India - at least the part of it you can see from a 10th floor room at the Taj Mahal Hotel. Which isn't much. The air is too dense. Still, we can make out the figures of whole families eating and sleeping on the pavement near the dock.

We have never seen families sleeping on the pavement on Regent Street...nor on 5th Avenue. New York and London are great success stories. Turning the pages here, on the other hand, we read a failure story. It is the story of a people who haven't got much. The world turned against them, relatively, at the beginning of the Industrial Revolution. But if world turns long enough, it comes back to where it began. To make a long story short, we're betting on rotation.

The secret of material success is simple enough. In the beginning there is nothing. In the end, there is much. In between is all the dust and noise of a real economy. Everything and everyone moves -- the dirt and raw materials...the bussers and schleppers who carry them, heat them up and hammer them into finished products...the merchants who sell them...and the consumers who use them. The money moves too.

But over time...and must all balance out. For every item produced there must be a consumer. For every surplus, there must be a deficit somewhere else. And for every boom there must be a bust.

Taking a train from Washington DC to New York City, you can look out your window and see the equation fastened to a rusty bridge, over a rusty river in a city of rust. It says "Trenton Makes, the World Takes." It is a sign that might have been hung on any one of hundreds of bridges in hundreds of different factory towns throughout America and Britain. As a bit of civic promotion, the sign is not completely fraudulent; it is only incomplete. It should have been turned around...probably in the 1970s. That was when Trenton became a taker.

For more than half a century, Trenton pumped out exports...then, it spent almost another half a century getting swamped by them. First, it enjoyed a capital investment boom...and then a capital investment bust, followed by a consumer spending boom...and then a consumer spending bust. Now the rest of the world awaits neither its output nor its orders. It is neither maker nor taker, but a dead-end slum.

Where will Trenton's next boom come from...or when? No one knows. In the meantime, it must pay for what it already got. America's post-WWII consumer boom came to an end in 2007. For the first time since 1946, consumer credit is falling. Americans are paying down debt.

Which leaves us looking out our hotel window, wondering...

The best form of government, said Voltaire, is democracy tempered by an occasional assassination. India's government must be as hard as steel by now. In 1984, the Prime Minister, Indira Gandhi, was assassinated by her Sikh bodyguards. Then, in 1991, her son Rajiv Gandhi was also killed, this time by Tamil Tigers. If we were named Gandhi, we'd go into a less dangerous line of work, like being a test pilot. But Sonia Gandhi, widow of Rajiv and the daughter of an unreconstructed Italian fascist, must like excitement. She was elected president of the Congress party in 1998. Her son is also a politician.

Western investors needed courage to put their money in India. Six out of nine governments since 1980 have been coalitions, several including communists. In 1999, Pakistan invaded the country. In 2007 Maoist rebels attacked police and killed 50 of them. Last year, terrorists set fire to our hotel.

When activists, foreign and domestic, failed to destroy India, nature took a whack at it. A cyclone in 1999 killed 10,000 people. An earthquake in 2001 carried off 30,000. A Tsunami struck in 2004. The next year, monsoons flooded much of the country.

Indian stocks paid off anyway. US stock prices went nowhere over the last 10 years; Bombay stock prices more than tripled. Over the 30 years, from the opening of the stock market to the end of 2009, the investor had a return of 17,000%.

All over the developed world, governments are getting a death grip on their economies, taking control of vital industries and increasing the state's share of GDP. One of India's advantages is that its feds have been choking the economy for years; now it is becoming a model of negligence. As a percentage of GDP, India offered only perfunctory stimulus to fight the downturn of 2007-2009.

Now, China overheats. America cools down. And India grows at 7% per year without breaking a sweat.

Wage growth is flat or negative in Trenton; in India hourly earnings double every 10 years. India depends less on exports than any other major developing nation except Brazil. And only the Philippines and Indonesia have less credit as a percentage of GDP.

While much of the rest of the world did it...and then over-did it...India hasn't done it yet. There are more autos in the US than there are licensed drivers, and two chickens in every pot; India barely has one vehicle per 100 people and barely any pot at all. This is a country where the getting has just begun

Editor's Note: Bill Bonner is the founder and editor of The Daily Reckoning. He is also the author, with Addison Wiggin, of the national best sellers Financial Reckoning Day: Surviving the Soft Depression of the 21st Century and Empire of Debt: The Rise of an Epic Financial Crisis. He is also the author, along with Lila Rajiva, of Mobs, Messiahs and Markets: Surviving the Public Spectacle in Finance and Politics.

Bill Bonner is the President & Founder of Agora Inc, an international publisher of financial and special interest books and newsletters.

The views mentioned above are of the author only. Data and charts, if used, in the article have been sourced from available information and have not been authenticated by any statutory authority. The author and Equitymaster do not claim it to be accurate nor accept any responsibility for the same. The views constitute only the opinions and do not constitute any guidelines or recommendation on any course of action to be followed by the reader. Please read the detailed Terms of Use of the web site.

Get The Daily Reckoning directly
in your mail box.
Just enter your e-mail address » 

Read our Privacy Policy and Terms Of Use.

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "The Outside View: Still on the road to moksha...". Click here!

5 Responses to "The Outside View: Still on the road to moksha..."


Jul 18, 2010

An article to induce faith in the positive outlook for india the persons funding his trip and excite the investors for personla gains



Mar 31, 2010

Dont take the detail, take the final takeaway : " The getting has just begun "



Mar 26, 2010

God save EQM. From where do you get such people to write in your columns. Mr Bonner seems to be writing pre-concieved / cliche ridden story of very poor taste. Has Mr Dayal lost interest in his company or what? This is no way to treat paid customers


Vinod Furtado

Mar 21, 2010

Just curious, but how did you reach the conclusion that "India barely has one vehicle per 100 people"? As per my calculations it comes to about 6 vehicles per 100. I am considering all registered vehicles in India.


Ramana Kumar

Mar 20, 2010

Sounds like a typical western tourist whos come to India for a 'fast food' kind of experience. Makes some superficial observations abt the country and tries to evolve doctorate theses out of them. His definition of 'Moksha' is rubbish - offensive to both Hindus and Jains! And bringing in the story abt a woman being sold for $1,000 - surely irrelevant and shows poor taste. The comments abt US per capita income are highly misleading. Talking abt how 'average per capita' income does not disclose the real 'suffering' of Americans. Does he expect sympathy and support from a much poorer country ? US per capita GDP is close to $45,000. Median income is closer to $33,000 - which adequately reflects income concentration at the top. Most critical data point : US Govt considers 'Poverty Line' to be $22,000 ! Whichever way you look at it, US citizens are 22 to 45 times richer than India and shud not try to squeeze concessions out of the rest of the world.

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "The Outside View: Still on the road to moksha...". Click here!

Recent Articles:
Trump Takes a Beating
August 18, 2017
Donald J Trump, a wrasslin' fan, took a 'Holy Sh*t!' blow on Tuesday.
Which Gods Will Bring Down the US Empire?
August 17, 2017
Mr Trump is in the White House and the gods are in their heavens; what's not to like?
Will They Haul Off Trump's Statue, Too?
August 16, 2017
All across the country, the old gods become devils. New, gluten-free gods take their places...
Farm Loan Waivers: Why Bad Economics Makes for Good Politics
August 14, 2017
It is because the negative effects of the waivers aren't clearly visible.