The Western growth model is broken and it ain't getting fixed any time soon

May 22, 2015

- By Vivek Kaul

Vivek Kaul
There is nothing more deceptive than an obvious fact.
-Arthur Conan Doyle, "The Boscombe Valley Mystery"

It's around 1.30 pm on Thursday afternoon and I have just finished reading a wonderful speech titled 'Going bust for growth', made by the Reserve Bank of India governor Raghuram Rajan, to the Economic Club of New York on May 19, 2015. The speech which runs into 14 pages like all Rajan speeches is a very good read and gets to the heart of the issue and explains things very well.

No wonder the prime minister Narendra Modi is so impressed with Rajan. As Modi said about Rajan in April earlier this year: "I happen to meet Raghuram (Rajan) once every two months and he comes prepared with three or four slides. He makes me understand them so perfectly that I don't need to question anything, I understand what he says."

--- Advertisement ---
Is It Time To Be Greedy Or Fearful?

The stock markets have crashed and a number of stocks have taken a beating.

And now, many common investors feel it's better to stay away from stocks right now.

But what if we told you this could be an ideal time to get Greedy about stocks?

And not only that, what if we told you this is actually a wonderful opportunity to grab some very good stocks at bargain prices?

Yes, we've revealed details of 3 such stocks you could consider buying right away in our new special report... which you could obtain for absolutely FREE!

Click here for full details...


In his latest speech Rajan talks about the steps taken by developed countries in the aftermath of the financial crisis that broke out in September 2008, why they are not working and how they are creating problems for what the developed world likes to call emerging markets.

Consumer demand collapsed in the aftermath of the financial crisis. One of the things that governments of the developed world did was to borrow and increase spending. This money was supposed to be spent towards creating physical infrastructure.

Returns on investing in infrastructure are supposed to be high given that currently both interest rates as well as constructions costs are low. Nevertheless, it is not easy to spend on building infrastructure in a developed country. As Rajan points out: "However, high-return infrastructure investment is harder to identify and implement in developed countries where most obvious investments have already been made - political influence is as likely to create bridges to nowhere or unviable high speed train networks as needed infrastructure."

Nevertheless, money can be spent on improving existing infrastructure. The trouble here is that decision making in this case needs to be a lot more decentralized in comparison to spending on mega projects. Given this, it "may be harder to initiate and finance from the centre". Hence, spending money on infrastructure may not always be the best way going around in order to create economic growth in developed countries.

Also, money being spent always does not go to projects which are likely to generate the most returns. It may go to projects backed by politicians who have the most influence. It's worth remembering here that even in well-functioning democracies some groups wield more influence than others. As Raghuram Rajan and Luigi Zingales write in Saving Capitalism from the Capitalists "Policy making is often captured by powerful special interests that thrive because of the peculiarities of democratic governance... Governments may work in the interest of a privileged few rather than the larger public and dig the wrong channels."

Other than increased spending, central banks of developed countries also printed and pumped money into the financial system. They did this by printing money to buy government and private bonds. By buying these bonds, the idea was to pump a lot of money into the financial system, keep interest rates low, with the hope of people borrowing and spending more at low interest rates.

But low interest rates make things difficult for investors. They need to invest in riskier assets and go searching for yield (return). Since the start of the financial crisis, there has been a huge flow of money from the developed markets into emerging markets, in search of a higher return.

As Rajan put it in his speech: "Indeed, the post-global crisis capital flows into emerging markets have been huge, despite the best efforts of emerging markets to push them back by accumulating reserves (net capital flows to emerging economies reached US$ 550 bn in 2013 compared to US$120 bn in 2006)."

So the money flowing into the emerging markets has increased many times over since the start of the financial crisis. And these flows create problems in emerging markets. When the money is coming in it leads to the appreciation of the local currency against the dollar (unless the central bank intervenes), creating problems for exporters. And when this money leaves in a hurry it leaves financial markets in a mess (Stock markets fall, yields on government bonds go up as foreign investors leave in a hurry) and the value of the local currency depreciates against the dollar., creating problems for importers. This makes things much more difficult for central banks in emerging markets.

Further, despite many years of increased government spending, money printing and low interest rates, economic growth is yet to recover in developed countries. What this tells us is that policies followed in the aftermath of the financial crisis haven't really worked. And the reason for this the slow growth of consumer demand.

A major reason for the same is that Western economies have lost the ability to make things. As Rajan and Zingales point out: "For decades before the financial crisis in 2008, advanced economies were losing their ability to grow by making useful things. But they needed to somehow replace the jobs that had been lost to technology and foreign competition... So in an effort to pump up growth, governments spent more than they could afford and promoted easy credit to get households to do the same. The growth that these countries engineered, with its dependence on borrowing, proved unsustainable."

With a manufacturing in developed countries being outsourced to emerging markets, a section of the population isn't exactly employable any more. As Rajan said in his speech: "Because of changes in technology and the expansion of global competition, routine repetitive jobs, whether done by the skilled or the unskilled, have diminished greatly in industrial countries. Many of these jobs, ranging from assembly line worker to legal aides or insurance clerks, have either been automated or outsourced."

And this is where the problem is. Good jobs now require skills. "The middle class recognizes that they need quality higher education and training to not slip into competing with the poor for low-skilled non-routine jobs such as security guard or gardener. But the poor quality early education they have received, as well as the prohibitive cost of quality higher education, puts many better livelihoods out of reach," said Rajan.

This is a problem that cannot go away either by spending more money on physical infrastructure or by maintaining low interest rates by printing money. It needs to be tackled over the long-term. But how politicians understand that term?

Vivek Kaul is the Editor of the Diary and The Vivek Kaul Letter. Vivek is a writer who has worked at senior positions with the Daily News and Analysis (DNA) and The Economic Times, in the past. He is the author of the Easy Money trilogy. The latest book in the trilogy Easy Money: The Greatest Ponzi Scheme Ever and How It Is Set to Destroy the Global Financial System was published in March 2015. The books were bestsellers on Amazon. His writing has also appeared in The Times of India, The Hindu, The Hindu Business Line, Business World, Business Today, India Today, Business Standard, Forbes India, Deccan Chronicle, The Asian Age, Mutual Fund Insight, Wealth Insight, Swarajya, Bangalore Mirror among others.

Disclaimer: The views mentioned above are of the author only. Data and charts, if used, in the article have been sourced from available information and have not been authenticated by any statutory authority. The author and Equitymaster do not claim it to be accurate nor accept any responsibility for the same. The views constitute only the opinions and do not constitute any guidelines or recommendation on any course of action to be followed by the reader. Please read the detailed Terms of Use of the web site.

Recent Articles

They Were Ordered to Shoot... June 22, 2018
If you want to do the right thing, should you obey the authorities or do some thinking of your own and figure it out for yourself? Bill Bonner offers his views on the same.
RBI Just Admitted That Real Estate Caters Only to Rich June 21, 2018
Priority sector home loan lending has fallen dramatically over the years whereas the non-priority sector continues to grow at a good pace. Hence, definitions have been changed.
The Great Canadian Shoe Heist June 21, 2018
Not only did America threaten China with import taxes on US$200 billion worth of goods, it also said that if the Chinese tried to retaliate, they would impose taxes on another US$200 billion. The Chinese have a lot more to lose than the US, it seems.
Demonetisation and the Johnny Joker Syndrome June 20, 2018
As more data comes out, more it looks like a bad decision.

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "The Western growth model is broken and it ain't getting fixed any time soon". Click here!

2 Responses to "The Western growth model is broken and it ain't getting fixed any time soon"

Santimoy Ghoshal

May 28, 2015

Parallel to the prevailing violence, chaos, unrest and tensions in families and society, there is an undercurrent of change to a higher consciousness in small segments of people in many countries.
Probably 99% of mankind now live out their whole lives in the three basic consciousness states viz. sleeping, dreaming and awake states focused almost totally in the external material world. These have produced not only great marvels of science, technology, literature and philosophy but also hatred, greed, and crimes against society and the environment resulting in World Wars, global warming, pollution and Weapons of Mass Destruction which can quickly annihilate the Earth.
But, probably our intelligent and benevolent Universe is not ready for this as yet and seems to have other ideas- because as of now about 20 million US citizens and 10 million Chinese are practicing Yoga and Meditation- the antidote for our current situation. The total global count is approaching 100 m even before the first International Yoga Day viz Sun 21st June 2015.
It is a fact that with increasing attention to Yoga and Meditation, the spinoff is that the Consciousness of people is shifting to a higher or Fourth State viz from Object (or People referral) to Self (or Spirit referral)- which is a field of unlimited potentialities. There is no limit to what we can do once we shift from the conditioned Ego-which makes us afraid as puny individuals always seeking approval of others. When we are established in Self, there is absence of Fear, no compulsion to control or seize external power, to grab or cling to anything. We become aware of our true nature as spiritual beings living temporarily in this body. In the journey to this fourth state we acquire Knowledge through Concentration and Meditation-other actions serve only to facilitate the way. We learn to live in this world but not be of this world.This is the way to go to a new Destiny- India has known this for thousands of years and now Western Science is showing that it is true.


Ramesh Venkataraman

May 22, 2015

The Western model has totally failed, but we are hopping on to the Western bandwagon now knowing fully well that it has failed. We need to let go of the GDP obsession and focus on new metrics that measure gross quality of life (GQL). We have a situation where GDP is rising but GQL is dropping, and we need to make sure that both grow at the same pace to say the least. Otherwise we will have major social problems. If we let go of the GDP obsession, we can focus more on GQL.

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "The Western growth model is broken and it ain't getting fixed any time soon". Click here!