Mumbai real estate is like a super-expensive Maybach-what we need are Tata Nanos - The Daily Reckoning

Mumbai real estate is like a super-expensive Maybach-what we need are Tata Nanos

Jun 18, 2015

- By Vivek Kaul

Vivek Kaul
The Financial Express had a very interesting newsreport on the super-luxury real estate market in Mumbai, a couple of days back. As per this report around 5,000 upmarket flats in Mumbai that are built and ready to occupy, have not been able to find any buyers.

And how much do these flats cost on an average? The Financial Express estimates that each of these flats costs at least Rs 10 crore. Hence, the total market value of these unsold flats is at least Rs 50,000 crore. That clearly is a lot of money.

As the newspaper points out: "Sales are tepid in central Mumbai - Lower Parel, Mahalaxmi, Prabhadevi and Parel. In these areas, the apartment sizes are typically between 4,000 sq ft and 7,000 sq ft accommodating three, four and five bedrooms. At the very least, they cost Rs 10 crore or approximately Rs 25,000 to Rs 30,000 per sq ft." Interestingly, anyone who has moved around in this area would know that there are many other properties still under-construction and will hit the market over the next few years. So, this oversupply is unlikely to go any time soon.

In fact, super-luxury is not the only segment where sales are slow. Liases Foras, a real estate rating and research firm, estimates that the Mumbai Metropolitan Region has 46 months of unsold inventory of flats currently. "Months inventory denotes the months required to clear the stock at the existing absorption pace. A healthy market maintains 8 to 12 months of inventory," Liases Foras points out.

Further, the sales velocity or the ratio of monthly sales to total supply currently stands at 1.05% in Mumbai. Liases Foras considers a sales velocity of 2.75% optimum as it translates into a gestation period of 36 months. And despite the slow sales, launches of new home projects have remained on a firm footing in Mumbai.

During the period January and March 2015, the Mumbai Metropolitan Region witnessed new launches of 18.16 million square feet. This amounted to the second highest new launches ever-the highest having been in April to June 2010. What is interesting is that the new launches form around 9.5% of the total unsold space of 192.27 million square feet.

Within this total unsold space, the maximum is for flats which are priced at Rs 2 crore or more. 62.06 million square feet of home space remains unsold in this category. This is around 32.3% of the total unsold inventory of flats in Mumbai.

The weighted average price of a flat in the Mumbai Metropolitan Region is around Rs 1.3 crore. Banks and home loan companies give a loan of 80% of the price of property. Hence, on a flat which is available for a price of Rs 1.3 crore, the bank would give a home loan of Rs 1.04 crore. The remaining Rs 26 lakh would have to be paid by the buyer.

Further, the EMI on this loan at 10% interest and repayable over a period of 20 years, would amount to over Rs 1 lakh per month. Hence, in order to get this loan the buyer would need to have a monthly income of Rs 2.5-3 lakh per month. How many people have that kind of income?

Hariprakash Pandey, senior vice-president, finance and investor relations, at Mumbai-based developer HDIL, recently told Business Standard that flat prices in Mumbai had gone beyond Rs 1.5-2 crore and this meant that homes were beyond the reach of the middle class. As he said: "If you take a loan of Rs 1.5 crore, you have to pay an EMI of Rs 1.5 lakh. For that you should have a monthly income of Rs 4-5 lakh."

This was a rare occasion of an individual who makes his money in the real estate industry admitting that there is a problem. The usual tendency till date has been to blame the slowdown in the real estate industry on high interest rates and the fact that the Reserve Bank of India was not doing enough to bring them down.

This as I have often pointed out in the past is a very stupid argument.

All these numbers have some lessons to offer. First and foremost is the fact that the Indian real estate is now way beyond the affordability levels of the rich as well and not just the salaried middle class, as Pandey of HDIL pointed out.

The Indian real estate companies have stopped catering to demand. As Dhirendra Kumar rightly points out in a recent column: "It's as if the car industry would try to sell nothing but large BMWs, Mercedes and Jaguars while most of the country yearned for cheaper cars."

I think I would go a step ahead and say that "it's as if the car industry would try to sell nothing but Maybachs." (Maybach is incidentally also made by Mercedes).

The second learning here is that the real estate industry has been for long been catering to the real estate investor rather than the real estate buyer. But now this business model seems to be breaking down as well. Take the case of Mumbai-as pointed earlier, the city has 5,000 upscale flats with a price tag of greater than Rs 10 crore, which are lying unsold. And more such flats are still being made.

Even in a city like Mumbai it would be difficult to find so many genuine buyers who would have the ability to cough up Rs 10 crore or more for a home to live in. And those who have that kind of ability, already have a home or two to live in.

It now seems that the price is beyond what investors would like as well. Even with all the black money going around in the country, there is only so much of real estate that can be bought. Also, at a price of Rs 10 crore or more, what kind of returns can the investor really expect is a question worth asking?

To conclude, it is worth pointing out a couple of numbers from the latest Maharashtra State Economic Survey. The per capita income in Mumbai in 2013-2014 was at around Rs 1.88 lakh. In Thane, it was Rs 1.73 lakh. And we are selling homes priced at greater than Rs 10 crore. Who is the joke on? And when will we get around to build and sell flats at prices at which there is real demand?

Mumbai real estate is like a super-expensive Maybach-what we need are Tata Nanos. Or maybe even bicycles.

Microcap Millionaires - Reopened! (You Won't Believe This...)

We have some great news to share with you today!

But before that...

Let me tell beforehand that what we are going to share with you today is ONLY to highlight the money-making potential that lies in Microcaps and that there is risk involved in investing in Microcaps.

However, if you can take some risk, look at some of the Microcap Millionaires returns -

175.9% in Just 11 months, 170.1% in Just 1 year, 59.4% in Just 3 months and 51.4% in Just 3 months.

Now, we can understand that these numbers might seem unbelievable, but these are actual returns our recommendations have delivered for our valued Members.

And now, for the great news we wanted to share...

Microcap Millionaires has just been reopened for a very few select new members.

As it is one of our Most Exclusive Services it is rarely opened for new members...

So this is a great opportunity.

But it is open for a very limited period. Do not miss this for anything!

Click here to know all about Microcap Millionaires...

Vivek Kaul is the Editor of the Diary and The Vivek Kaul Letter. Vivek is a writer who has worked at senior positions with the Daily News and Analysis (DNA) and The Economic Times, in the past. He is the author of the Easy Money trilogy. The latest book in the trilogy Easy Money: The Greatest Ponzi Scheme Ever and How It Is Set to Destroy the Global Financial System was published in March 2015. The books were bestsellers on Amazon. His writing has also appeared in The Times of India, The Hindu, The Hindu Business Line, Business World, Business Today, India Today, Business Standard, Forbes India, Deccan Chronicle, The Asian Age, Mutual Fund Insight, Wealth Insight, Swarajya, Bangalore Mirror among others.

Disclaimer: The views mentioned above are of the author only. Data and charts, if used, in the article have been sourced from available information and have not been authenticated by any statutory authority. The author and Equitymaster do not claim it to be accurate nor accept any responsibility for the same. The views constitute only the opinions and do not constitute any guidelines or recommendation on any course of action to be followed by the reader. Please read the detailed Terms of Use of the web site.

Recent Articles

The Market Gods Are Laughing July 13, 2018
President Trump escalated the trade war yesterday, and the Chinese say they will retaliate. Where is this trade war heading? Bill shares his insights.
MSP Leads to Excess Procurement of Rice, Which Leads to Waste of Water and Money July 12, 2018
Wheat, MSP, Food Corporation of India, CACP
We're Living in a Deep State Paradise July 12, 2018
Bill Bonner offer insights into how Big Technology is working with the feds to use data to control every aspect of our lives.
The Multiple Problems with the Minimum Support Price (MSP) System July 11, 2018
The price signals that MSP sends out, creates its own set of problems.

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Mumbai real estate is like a super-expensive Maybach-what we need are Tata Nanos". Click here!

6 Responses to "Mumbai real estate is like a super-expensive Maybach-what we need are Tata Nanos"


Jun 19, 2015

Dear Vivek,

Its always been a pleasure to read your articles. I often wonder if it does make sense to pay this kind of price for a flat in Mumbai where once you step out of your house you only get to see filth throw all around and with the crumbling infrastructure that we have its only a matter of time that people would begin to realize they are fools to be paying such exorbitant price for a flat in Mumbai. Rather go ahead and invest such sums in delevoped countries.

I wonder how the banks are still lending to this sector.



Jun 19, 2015

Vivek Kaul's articles are very interesting to read. The real estate market across the country is quite skewed. Genuine seekers of decent accommodation find it very difficult to buy one. The income disparity among various sectors is very wide. For example, average income in IT sector is 2 to 3 times higher than that of other sectors. Cities like Pune are witnessing prices of above 1 crore. People with resources are acquiring multiple houses with the hope of making enormous profit. The market has become speculative. I think one way to stop this is to bring down the loan component to 50%.



Jun 18, 2015

this type of tendencies to serve only high profile ones is creating hindrances in providing affordable housing to
poor.Apart. of ten crore will accommodate maximum of four person where as 100 houses can be built for one hundred families.
Further builders should be allowed to build houses ready to move. This will eliminate black money involving in real estate business.



Jun 18, 2015

Very Interesting article and truthful facts which is not highlighted enough in the financial press. The fact that flats are expensive not only in Mumbai but also in Thane and Kalyan-Dombivli. Middle class people can afford flats only from Badlapur onwards. (that too only double income families). Longer loan terms will lead to higher risk of default as not everybody works in Government/blue chip corporate companies where jobs are secure and protected against inflation.



Jun 18, 2015

The poor cannot think of buying a house. It has gone beyond the purchasing power of middle class. Education and health care have also gone beyond the reach of the poor and middle class. If this trend continues there will be social unrest in couple of years. What is the point in copying Anglo-Saxon economic model and what it has achieved? True, some have reaped the benefits of this model but majority of the poor Indians have lost. Liquidity driven economic growth has failed to give equitable growth in our country but has helped the rich and powerful & their cronies only


Girish Patkar

Jun 18, 2015

Price of real estate in Mumbai will never drop for many reasons such as the geography of the city, infrastructure, cost of approvals , absence of regulatory framework, etc. However in my opinion, if the lenders do not provide a safety net to developers by not exercising their rights available to them in case of loan defaults, developers will be forced to liquidate stock which will bring down prices. Presently, developers are sitting on inventory in the hope that prices will rise in excess of inventory carrying cost without worrying about loan repayments. There exists a holy nexus between all stake holders at the cost of the buyer.

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Mumbai real estate is like a super-expensive Maybach-what we need are Tata Nanos". Click here!