Who will default first?

Jul 19, 2011

Paris, France

Who can honestly say that he is not enjoying the show?

Clowns to the left of us, jokers to the right... it's fun, isn't it?

Yesterday, the Dow fell and gold rose above $1,600 to a new record high. The euro fell, but against the dollar it is still more than 50% higher than it was when it was introduced 10 years ago.

In Europe, the world's leading bankers and financial policy-makers try to figure out how to avoid doing what comes naturally - going broke.

And in America, politicians scramble to raise the debt ceiling level before it is too late.

The big question is: who will default first? The Europeans? Or the Americans?

Larry Summers, former US Treasury Secretary, warned on TV that failing to raise the debt limit would be worse than after the Lehman bankruptcy in 2008. Ben Bernanke told Congress the same thing.

In Europe, the IMF and the rest of the financial elite have the same message. Don't let Greece default, or there is a serious risk of "contagion," and financial catastrophe. Larry Summers even crossed the ocean to give bad advice to the Europeans:

"No big financial institution in any country [should] be allowed to fail."

On both sides of the Atlantic, the situation is about the same. The geniuses and scam-artists who run the big banks want to keep the honey pots open as long as possible. But there are pressures...mostly from the middle classes, who feel they have been ripped off - to put on the lid.

In Europe, the Germans resist giving more money to the spendthrift Greeks and Portuguese. In America, Tea Party activists want to bring an end to Big Government by cutting off its source of funds. They want to hold the line on the debt limit. Many would be happy to see the nation default.

And here at the Daily Reckoning, we stand with the Tea Party and the Germans. We'd like to see the US government default. Why?

Because the feds have already done enough damage with their borrowing; it's time they lived within their means...

Because we already have enough zombies, supported by borrowed funds...

Because it will be less painful to stop the debt build up now than later...

And because we just want to see what happens when the zombies run out of fresh meat.

Finally, at least some people in Congress are getting serious about cutting spending.
WASHINGTON (AP) - One of the Senate's staunchest budget-cutters unveiled Monday a massive plan to cut the nation's deficit by $9 trillion over the coming decade, including $1 trillion in tax increases opposed by most of his fellow Republicans.

The plan by Sen. Tom Coburn, R-Okla., is laced with politically perilous proposals like raising to 70 the age at which people can claim their full Social Security benefits. It would cut farm subsidies, Medicare, student aid, housing subsidies for the poor, and funding for community development grants. Coburn even takes on the powerful veterans' lobby by proposing that some veterans pay more for medical care and prescription drugs.

Coburn would also eliminate $1 trillion in tax breaks over the coming decade, earning him an immediate rebuke from Americans for Tax Reform, an anti-tax organization with which Coburn has had a running feud. He would block taxpayers from claiming the mortgage interest deduction on second homes and limit it to homes worth $500,000. He would also ease taxpayers into higher tax brackets more quickly by using a smaller measure of inflation to adjust the brackets.

Coburn would cut $1 trillion from the Pentagon budget over a decade. He would block military retirees from the Tricare Prime health care plan, the option with the lowest out-of-pocket cost, saving $115 billion, and he would raise the prescription drug co-payment under the program, as well as require higher out-of-pocket fees. He also would reduce the fleet of aircraft carriers from 11 to 10 and Navy air wings from 10 to nine.

"I have no doubt that both parties will criticize portions of this plan, and I welcome that debate," Coburn told reporters. "But it's not a legitimate criticism until you have a plan of your own."

This fellow, Coburn, has the right idea. Throw away the scalpel. Get a chain saw. He'd raise the Medicare eligibility age to 69...and cut $1 trillion out of the Pentagon budget. He needs a much bigger chainsaw...but at least he's on the job. ----------------------------------------------- Your Vote Matters! -----------------------------------------------

Was Infosys more trustworthy under Narayan Murthy when it came to financial reporting?

Do you see it any differently under K V Kamath?

Do share your views with us. Click here...


*** Germans must have a race memory that makes them fear debt and inflation. They've suffered from both - especially during the war period, from 1914 until 1946. Even then, their problems were far from over. A third of the country was occupied by the Soviets and then run by communists for another 40 years. They don't want anything to do with the kind of policies that led to that debacle.

War reparations, imposed on them by the French, British and Americans after WWI, bankrupted the nation and turned the population into bitter enemies of their Western neighbors. Then, the reparations were the proximate cause of hyperinflation of the early '20s, which destroyed the middle class. Destitute and sour, the riff raff of Germany was easily drawn to extremists. The Nazis promised that their central planning would make Germany healthy and proud. The Bolsheviks promised their central planning would make Germany as successful as Soviet Russia. Scarcely 2 decades after the Armistice, German troops were on the move again, leading to another 5 years of war.

Today, sovereign debt takes the place of war reparations. A generation of taxpayers in Greece, Ireland and America is supposed to bear the debts of their spendthrift elders.

And once again, clouds gather and the sky darkens. Consumers close their wallets, just as they did in the '30s. Auto sales are running 28% below their level of 10 years ago. Home appliances are selling as this 20 years ago.

Housing is down a third...and keeps dropping.

Unemployment, properly measured, is at Depression levels too.

And this just in: a drought in the South threatens to turn the region into a giant Dust Bowl - just as in the '30s.

*** "France's system of social support is too generous," said a guest last night. "It attracts the wrong kind of immigrants. They don't want to work. They just want to take advantage of our welfare system."

Today's debt problems in Europe can be traced to a cultural misunderstanding. Germany's low interest rates work for Germans, more or less. They save. They work hard. They have a cultural bias against waste and idleness.

But offer the same interest rates to Irish property developers ...or to the government of Greece...and pretty soon you have problems. The cultures are different. Germans may be reticent about borrowing...but not, apparently, the Greeks!

Different groups respond to incentives differently. By trial and error, they develop systems of government and banking that work for them. Some groups value leisure and larceny far more than others. Some place less importance on wealth. Many people disapprove of working too hard...some regard it as a sign of failure and incompetence.

It is all very well to give the Westphalian landser a comfortable safety net, in other words. His pride, his status, and sense of right and wrong will not permit him to use it - unless he really needs to. But give the same safety net to other peoples, and soon they are lolling about in it...happy with the leisure and the standard of living it affords them.

And then, naturally, the net gives way under the weight of so many shiftless malingers.

Bill Bonner is the President & Founder of Agora Inc, an international publisher of financial and special interest books and newsletters.

Disclaimer: The views mentioned above are of the author only. Data and charts, if used, in the article have been sourced from available information and have not been authenticated by any statutory authority. The author and Equitymaster do not claim it to be accurate nor accept any responsibility for the same. The views constitute only the opinions and do not constitute any guidelines or recommendation on any course of action to be followed by the reader. Please read the detailed Terms of Use of the web site.

Recent Articles

A New Infrastructure Boom March 26, 2019
Selva Freigedo talks about the potential in 5G network and how it could transform the way we communicate.
A 40 Somethings Guide to YouTube Hits March 20, 2019
Vivek dwells into a new YouTube phenomenon.
As the Economy Slows Down, Maruti and Two-Wheeler Companies Cut Production March 19, 2019
The country's largest car maker has cut production by more than a fourth.
In Supporting Demonetisation, RBI Behaved Like an Old Uncle Not Willing to Take a Stand March 13, 2019
The minutes of the meeting of the RBI Board which happened before demonetisation have been released.

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Who will default first?". Click here!

5 Responses to "Who will default first?"


Jul 21, 2011

I entirely agree with the observation that responses to incentives, subsidies etc. have a cultural bias and indiscriminately provided crutches give rise to negative consequences in many cultures. Similarly power given to persons incapble of handling it will destroy the society. Like Indian politicians and buruacrats.



Jul 19, 2011

The whole scene create by one basic cause is governments and citizens are spending lavishly and borrow and will return principle but they don't think that this cycle will complete, and create this scenario, they all are enjoining money and business comes from by petro dollars in past very easily,when sheikh are illetrate. And new generation which is well educated in Europe,UK and US. And they takeover the business and cut the monopaly by tendering and form the associations and coordination by this they creat one mechenism of compitition.
Slowly-slowly they creat our own infrastructure in his own countries and drain the bussiness of US,UK,and Europe, by this big slow down comes in these service provider companies and countries.
This will take more time they these govt think may be five year or decade.


Rajiv Phadke

Jul 19, 2011

Hi Bill,
Hv bn reading yr daily reckonings for past few wks and totally agree with yr prognosis abt the decline of US & euro zone. The culture of low/no savings & unbridled consumerism /indulgence, even on borrowed money, will surely lead to disastrous results...We in India are blessed by a strong savings culture and conservative economic policies which will attract and reward many more international investors....
Rajiv - Mumbai


Yoginder Saxena

Jul 19, 2011

Definately US will default first, then followed by Grecce, Ireland, Portugal, Spain etc.
Very well studied



Jul 19, 2011

Drastic times call for drastic measures. Still, does that make it okay for a country to break its promise to its employees and vets? A person who signed into the military was expected to have a Tricare Plan. On what basis do you now say, "Sorry sucker, no more Tricare. You may have spend your productive years serving the Military, but don't expect to be given what you were promised in return."
Maybe you can do that going forward with new recruits who sign-on full aware that they don't have this perk anymore. But how do you do it with vets? (Or am I missing something?)

Also don't see any of these proposals cutting the perks of Reps & Senators (including their own govt-funded healthcare plans)!

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Who will default first?". Click here!