Something went wrong after 30 years of growth

Oct 31, 2011

Paris, France

Last week, the bull market continued. Investors were sure that the bailout of Europe's wobbly debtors was a done deal. The details of the deal have yet to be worked out. Just details, of course...such as who's going to pay for it and where they're going to get the money.

That, and whether Europe's 17 nations will go along with it...when they finally figure out what "it" is.

For now, nobody knows.

Here's how we look at it. After WWII, Europe rose from its ashes while America went from strength to strength. The entire developed, non-communist world - including Japan - enjoyed its "30 glorious years" of growth.

Then, something went wrong. The zombies gained power...and gradually shifted more and more resources to unproductive sectors. At the same time, the pay off from increased use of fossil fuels (the real cause of above-trend growth since the advent of the Industrial Revolution) reached the point of declining marginal utility. Energy prices rose and it was more and more difficult to find applications that would pay off.

Together, these phenomena caused real growth rates to decline. Neither in France nor in America have real wages shown significant improvement since. That is, for the last 40 years, the earnings of the typical working stiff have barely improved.

How to react to this challenge?

In the US, households ran down their balance sheets. They made up for the lack of income growth with debt growth. This allowed them to continue improving their standards of living until the 21st century.

In Europe, it was governments who ran down their balance sheets. They made up for the lack of income growth with increased public services, financed by debt. This allowed people to improve their standards of living even though they weren't earning more money.

In terms of total debt, there is not much difference between the countries of Europe of the US. All have total debt to GDP ratios in the 250% - 300% range. Some a bit more. Some a bit less. In Europe and Japan, the debt is concentrated in the public sector. In America, it is mostly in the private sector...with the public sector gaining ground fast.

Of course, the people who sell debt - namely, Wall Street, the City in London, and the rest of the financial industry - did wonderfully well. In America, for example, the percentage of total corporate profits coming from the financial industry rose 300% during the last three decades.

That is why people think the banks were the cause of the problem. Mostly, they were just in the right time at the right place to benefit from a trend that they didn't cause and couldn't possibly control.

Then, in 2007, the reckoning began. All of a sudden, the private sector in the US buckled under the weight of so much debt. People couldn't pay their mortgages...and then the geniuses at the finance companies realized that they were broke. Their sliced and diced mortgage debt was not nearly as solid as they had thought.

Governments rushed to bail out the banks, who just happened to be large campaign contributors. The feds swamped themselves in the process. Iceland and Ireland were the first to sink. Then, all the periphery of Europe was shipping water.

Back in America, whole towns were soon underwater...such as Las Vegas and Orlando. In Europe, whole countries were submerged, such as Greece.

And what did the authorities do? What was their solution?

Alas, they are all one-trick ponies. And the only trick they know - adding more debt - doesn't work. But they keep at it...lowering interest rates, offering more credit on EZ terms to everyone. Students are encouraged to shackle themselves to a lifetime of ball-and-chain education debt. Homeowners, who should swim away from their underwater houses, are encouraged to refinance. Everyone is encouraged to spend money he doesn't have on products he doesn't need so that the economy will go where it shouldn't go - furthering into debt!

But even if the feds can get households to repeat their errors...they won't be able to keep it up; they're running out of money. A Wall Street Journal blog explains:
By Kathleen Madigan

Like the Cardinals' David Freese, the U.S. consumer stepped up to the plate and hit one out of the park in the third quarter. Unless job and income gains pick up, though, the household sector may not get past first base this quarter.

Consumer spending powered the 2.5% annualized gain in real gross domestic product last quarter. The monthly numbers show spending ended the quarter on a very strong note in September, despite surveys showing the household sector very downbeat about the economy.

Can consumers keep buying in the fourth quarter?

There are, however, a few reasons for caution. Incomes gains are trailing spending increases. Personal income edged up just 0.1% in September. After taking price changes and taxes into account, real disposable income has fallen for three consecutive months.

As a result, last quarter's spending gain came at the expense of savings. The September saving rate dipped to 3.6%, the lowest rate since the recession began in December 2007.

Consumers cannot ignore their nest eggs indefinitely. Households need to pay down existing debts (a form of saving) and to replenish retirement funds eroded during the financial crisis. A saving rate closer to 5% is needed to repair household finances.

Looking beyond the fourth quarter, much faster hiring and wage growth are needed to solidify the consumer outlook.
Good luck on that!

Debt has become an impediment to growth, not a facilitator. Like energy, it reached the point of declining marginal utility years ago. The feds can still add debt - at least in America - but it won't make the economy grow. Instead, it crushes it.

And when investors finally figure this out they will sell their stocks...and the markets will be free to complete their rendezvous with the bottom.

Stay tuned...

------- FREE Newsletter -------
Straight from the Hip - A Weekly E-Letter
"This weekly stock market column written by me has run for over 19 years on various platforms. I invite you to subscribe today for a fresh and thought-provoking perspective." - J Mulraj
Available exclusively to readers of Equitymaster. Sign-up Now! It's Free!

*** "We're very glad we moved here. And both of our girls have thanked us."

We were having dinner with an English/Dutch couple who had moved to France 12 years ago. They live out in the country, where he raises cereal crops and she teaches French to foreigners.

We had just explained how our children moved back to the US. Despite growing up in France and attending French schools most of their lives, they seem to want to make their lives in America.

"It is just the opposite for our children," our friends explained. "At first, the girls weren't so sure. They thought they wanted to go back to England. And they blamed us for ruining their lives, because they thought they had lost their identities.

"But when they went back to England they didn't like it very much. I mean, we had visited many times. And my family still lives there. But when they went to university there they were a little shocked. They said that young people in Britain just want to get drunk. So, they both came back here.

"Of course, France is not an easy country. The people are very nice once you get to know them. But it's a hard place to work or do business. There is so much bureaucracy...paperwork and taxes. And there's such an us-versus-them tension in French working places. If you hire someone...they think you are the enemy. They treat you like you were a rich capitalist. Even if you're just a small farmer like me. Then, you spend your time filling out forms and trying to figure out how the labor system works. And if you come across a rotten apple employee, they take advantage of you.

"I prefer to work with English or Dutch people. It's just easier to get along with them."

*** "France is screwed," said a friend at a wedding on Saturday. "We think we're going to finance this bailout of Greece and Portugal...and the banks. But who's going to bail us out? We think we have such a strong economy, but our figures are actually worse than those of Italy or Spain. And we don't have any margin for error. We already have the highest taxes in Europe. Raising taxes to cover deficits is out of the question. And you know how much we have in our accounts to pay for our pension system? Nothing. There's nothing there. It's all a gigantic fraud that we're going to discover later. And then we're screwed."

Bill Bonner is the President & Founder of Agora Inc, an international publisher of financial and special interest books and newsletters.

Disclaimer: The views mentioned above are of the author only. Data and charts, if used, in the article have been sourced from available information and have not been authenticated by any statutory authority. The author and Equitymaster do not claim it to be accurate nor accept any responsibility for the same. The views constitute only the opinions and do not constitute any guidelines or recommendation on any course of action to be followed by the reader. Please read the detailed Terms of Use of the web site.

Recent Articles

A New Infrastructure Boom March 26, 2019
Selva Freigedo talks about the potential in 5G network and how it could transform the way we communicate.
A 40 Somethings Guide to YouTube Hits March 20, 2019
Vivek dwells into a new YouTube phenomenon.
As the Economy Slows Down, Maruti and Two-Wheeler Companies Cut Production March 19, 2019
The country's largest car maker has cut production by more than a fourth.
In Supporting Demonetisation, RBI Behaved Like an Old Uncle Not Willing to Take a Stand March 13, 2019
The minutes of the meeting of the RBI Board which happened before demonetisation have been released.

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Something went wrong after 30 years of growth". Click here!

2 Responses to "Something went wrong after 30 years of growth"


Oct 31, 2011

We Indians also leading to the same trap. We should call it Pension Economy. We are paying to govt. employees hundred times more than our GDP. They dont work but are burden on the people.They are pesioners from the date they are confrimed. Aam Aadami has become AAM (Mango) from whom every drop of juice is being extracted. Instead of providing relief to ordinary man only relief is available to govt. employees even from the back date (DA arrears).


raghvinder Joshi

Oct 31, 2011

This is the downside of democracy and socialism. Governments are elected by voters, voters have to be kept happy in the near term even when the long term effects of economic policies may lead to eventual doom of the country.

It will be interesting to see how these countries come out of the quicksand of bad economic policies. Problem in a globalised world is that every one suffers.

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Something went wrong after 30 years of growth". Click here!