Sovereign Gold Bonds are a great idea that won't work in India

Nov 10, 2015

- By Vivek Kaul

Vivek Kaul
On November 5, 2015, the Prime Minister Narendra Modi launched the sovereign gold bonds. On the occasion Modi said: "India has no reason to be described as a poor country, as it has 20,000 tonnes of gold. He said the gold available with the country should be put to productive use, and these schemes show us the way to achieve this goal."

Our fascination for gold has led to a situation where we have managed to accumulate 20,000 tonnes of gold over the years. To understand how big this number is, consider the following point made by the World Gold Council. As it points out: "At the end of 2014, there were 183,600 tonnes of stocks in existence above ground. If every single ounce of this gold were placed next to each other, the resulting cube of pure gold would only measure 21 metres in any direction."

What does this mean? India has 20,000 tonnes or around 10.9% of the 1,83,000 tonnes of gold in existence. The tragedy is that India doesn't produce almost any gold. In fact, in 2013-2014, we produced 1.4 tonnes of gold.

And how much did we import? The minister of state for commerce Nirmala Sitharaman(independent charge) in a written reply in the Lok Sabha had pointed out that Indian import of gold in 2013-2014 had stood at 638 tonnes.

Advertisement
  Real Estate: The (In)Complete Guide  
(Claim You Free Copy Instantly)
   
  Vivek Kaul's Special Guide Are you thinking about buying a house?

Do you have a property you are looking to sell?

Is it a good time to buy Real Estate as an investment?

Is it the right time for the "Tata Nanos" of Real Estate to emerge?

What can Modi do to revive the sector?

If any of these questions are on your mind, we have some great news for you!

Introducing our Latest Special Guide... The (In)Complete Guide To Real Estate.

Authored by Vivek Kaul, (A noted columnist and writer whose writings on the economy and money have appeared in several big publications like The Times of India, The Hindu, and Forbes India), this Special guide promises to give you rare insights into this relatively under-researched sector.

A sector that almost every Indian wants to invest in... or is at least affected by.

Right Now... You can Instantly Claim an Absolutely Free Copy of this guide!

 

So India produced 1.4 tonnes of gold and imported 638 tonnes of gold. Interestingly, the import of gold in 2013-2014 fell by around 25% from 845 tonnes in 2011-2012. In 2011-2012, India had produced 1.59 tonnes of gold. Hence, we practically import all the gold that we consume.

And this creates major macroeconomic imbalances. Gold is sold internationally in dollars. When India imports gold it needs dollars, which need to be earned through exports. When India imports gold, it pushes up the demand for dollars in comparison to the rupee and the value of the rupee starts to fall. A depreciating rupee is good for the exporters because they earn more. But given that our imports are more than our exports it hurts.

Other than practically importing all the gold that it consumes, India also imports 80% of the oil that it consumes. A depreciating rupee means that the oil marketing companies which import oil have to pay more for oil in rupee terms. In the past, the government did not allow the oil marketing companies to pass on this increase in cost to the consumers totally.

Only recently diesel prices have been freed and are determined by the price at which oil marketing companies are able to buy oil internationally. Oil marketing companies still suffer under-recoveries every time they sell kerosene and domestic cooking gas.

The government has to compensate the oil marketing companies for these under-recoveries. Up until last year, the oil prices were very high. And when gold demand went up, the rupee depreciated and this pushed up the total amount of money oil marketing companies had to pay for oil. Since they were not allowed to totally pass on this increase in price to the end consumer on the oil products they sold, the government had to compensate them.

When the government compensated them, the expenditure of the government went up and so did its fiscal deficit. Fiscal deficit is the difference between what a government earns and what it spends. This meant higher borrowing by the government.  A higher borrowing led to crowding out, where the increased government borrowing did not leave enough on the table for the other borrowers. This, in turn, pushed up interest rates. And so the cycle worked.

Let's look at this in another way. In 2013-2014, the gold and silver India imported, formed around 7.1% of the total commodity imports. In 2012-2013 and 2011-2012, the number was higher at 11.3% and 12.5%. For a commodity which is pretty much useless from an industrial point of view that is a huge proportion.

In 2013-2014, gold worth $28.7 billion had been imported. Now compare this to India's IT and IT enabled services exports which during the same period stood at $86.4 billion. So, one way of looking at it is that one-third of dollars earned through IT and IT enabled services exports were used up to buy gold.

In fact, the situation was even worse in 2012-2013, when the gold imports were at $53.7 billion. The IT and IT enabled services exports were at $76.5 billion dollars. Hence, more than 70% of dollars earned through IT and IT enabled services exports were used up in buying gold. For 2011-2012, the proportion was even higher at 81%.

Once all these factors are taken into account the sovereign gold bonds sound like a fantastic idea. As a RBI notification dated October 30, 2015, points out: "The Bonds shall be denominated in units of one gram of gold and multiples thereof. Minimum investment in the Bonds shall be 2 grams with a maximum subscription of 500 grams per person per fiscal year (April - March)." The bonds shall also pay an interest of 2.75% per annum.

So anyone looking to buy gold instead of buying actual physical gold can buy these bonds. The value of these bonds will be linked to the price of gold. As the RBI notification points out: "The redemption price shall be fixed in Indian Rupees on the basis of the previous week's (Monday - Friday) simple average closing price for gold of 999 purity, published by IBJA [Indian Bullion and Jewellers Association]." The bonds can be held on paper as well as demat form.

When an investor invests in these bonds he will not buy physical gold. This will help in reducing gold imports and the entire cycle, which I have explained above, will not play out or play out to a lesser extent. The RBI and the government will not get a macroeconomic headache because of our fascination for buying gold. At least, that's the idea.

Of course I am assuming here that investors will move from buying physical gold to investing in sovereign gold bonds. Nevertheless, will that happen? Paper and demat gold has already around in the form of gold mutual funds and gold exchange traded funds(gold ETFs). Gold mutual funds invest the money that they collect into Gold ETFs.

These funds haven't really taken off. This tells us that the Indian investor has an aversion to paper and demat gold and likes to hold real gold.

The advantage in case of sovereign gold bonds is that the investor along with getting gold returns also gets 2.75% as interest on the initial amount he invests. Is that lucrative enough to get him to move from physical gold to paper/demat gold? I don't think so.

And that's basically because there are other factors at play. Investing in gold is a lot about touch and feel. Indians are emotionally and culturally attached to the gold that they buy. Further, as I mentioned in the Friday edition of The Daily Reckoning, many Indians buy gold to store their black money. A lot of money can be held by buying a small amount of gold. These individuals are likely to continue to buy gold in physical form. The reason is straightforward. They are not going to buy paper/demat gold because it would be establish an audit trail and lead to problems for these individuals.

Also, those interested in getting gold jewellery made will get gold jewellery made and not buy sovereign gold bonds instead.

Due to all these reasons, I think the sovereign gold bonds are unlikely to take off. Indians will continue to buy gold in physical form. But that shouldn't stop the government from trying.

Vivek Kaul is the Editor of the Diary and The Vivek Kaul Letter. Vivek is a writer who has worked at senior positions with the Daily News and Analysis (DNA) and The Economic Times, in the past. He is the author of the Easy Money trilogy. The latest book in the trilogy Easy Money: The Greatest Ponzi Scheme Ever and How It Is Set to Destroy the Global Financial System was published in March 2015. The books were bestsellers on Amazon. His writing has also appeared in The Times of India, The Hindu, The Hindu Business Line, Business World, Business Today, India Today, Business Standard, Forbes India, Deccan Chronicle, The Asian Age, Mutual Fund Insight, Wealth Insight, Swarajya, Bangalore Mirror among others.

Disclaimer: The views mentioned above are of the author only. Data and charts, if used, in the article have been sourced from available information and have not been authenticated by any statutory authority. The author and Equitymaster do not claim it to be accurate nor accept any responsibility for the same. The views constitute only the opinions and do not constitute any guidelines or recommendation on any course of action to be followed by the reader. Please read the detailed Terms of Use of the web site.

Recent Articles

Get 'India's Big Government' at Just Rs 199 Now October 18, 2017
Vivek's latest book is now available at a rare discount. Grab a copy now.
Our Plan to Save the Ranch October 18, 2017
How to increase fertility in the kingdom of cows.
Nobody Honks in Bali - Lessons for Indian Tourism October 17, 2017
Things India can learn to promote tourism from this small island.
We Rode Out... Unarmed October 17, 2017
Money is the tape measure for the carpenter economy.

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Sovereign Gold Bonds are a great idea that won't work in India". Click here!

11 Responses to "Sovereign Gold Bonds are a great idea that won't work in India"

Ganesh Sastri

Jan 18, 2016

Everybody knowledgeable or otherwise, complains about the quantity of gold that we import. Why don't we compare that with the black gold and electronic items that Indians import. India produces very little of either of these. Both of these are consumed and there is nothing to show. At least in the case of gold, the country can pledge gold should the need arise. Considering the MASSIVE trade deficit ( despite record low prices for black gold) and the continuing current account trade deficit, one cannot rule out going back to lenders.

Like 

krishnan vc

Nov 12, 2015

Vivek, I think there is a small add on i will like to make here. It is not the audit trail that matters. most of these buyers are samll people who start buying in small quantities to start accumalating for their daughters wedding. very few do it as an investment for themselves. For themselves it would be Land or Building. If the Govt. was to offer a rate of 8.5% I am sure there will be a rise in the need for these bonds as at 2.5% it is next to nothing. They view this as another savings account and nothing else.

Like 

kirit saraiya

Nov 10, 2015

two factors need consideration. our temples are loaded with gold where no body looks physically for years. if that is diverted than can contribute.
the effect of black money searching moment of govt will make few people to go for this. even planned investment by black money holder will be befitted.

Like 

Sunil Doshi

Nov 10, 2015

Dear Vivek,
Indian Govt has already taken a Risk of Capital Loss in case Gold takes an Uptrend in coming 8 years.Against Govt.Long term borrowing at 8.75%,Govt. is getting Money at 2.75%.Gold is already at almost 6 years Bottom. EQM has been constatly expecting an Uptrend sooner or later. Govt. has done Best possible by promising 2.75%p.a.Investors are most likely to gain 2.75% and Price Uptrend. It's a Good Idea.

Like 

Soumyadeep Banerjee

Nov 10, 2015

Hi,
If we hold these sovereign bonds in paper format, how we will sel these bonds in case required? Do we have to sell to the bank from which we have purchased these bonds or to Govt of India?

Like 

vip

Nov 10, 2015

Majority of gold investors are investing/hoarding black money. Real investor class which is tiny in size and number is investing with view may find Gold Bonds attractive. The third category of buyer is jewelry/ornaments buyers, will never come.

Like 

Ramakant Tiwari

Nov 10, 2015

An insightful article!

Can we think of practical ways of educating the masses to lure them away from bullion (esp. Gold) & encourage them to "invest" where it truly creates wealth?

Like 

MUKUND JAEEL

Nov 10, 2015

Sir,
You have stated that black marketeers are not going to buy paper/demat gold because it would establish an audit trail and lead to problems for these individuals. True. But, how come they are not getting caught by Income Tax Department or other Government agencies when they buy actual gold in bulk ? Can you give your expert comments ?

M P Jaeel

Like 

ramux

Nov 10, 2015

All this much logic is unnecessary. There is only one thing. Gold is anti-Paper money and hence Anti-Govt. That is why Govt. and Central Banks hate it. Everybody needs some physical gold as safety from Govt. Buying paper gold is absurd. In that case it is better to sell that gold and put rupees in FDs, Bonds or stocks and you get better interest returns. The dumbest idea is to trust govt. with your gold. It's like appointing fox to guard your hen house.

Like 

PANDEY

Nov 10, 2015

The basic reason of hesitation to invest in paper gold and the physical gold is the psychology. In physical gold say one is having 10 gm it will always 10 gm. IN CASE OF ETF it fluctuates and the unfortunate part is that most Etf came during peek of cycle.

Like 
   Next>>
Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Sovereign Gold Bonds are a great idea that won't work in India". Click here!