Who is a babu?

Nov 24, 2015

28

This is a slightly different piece from the ones that I usually write for The Daily Reckoning newsletter. In this piece I will try and define a babu.

So who is a babu? More than coming up with an exact definition, it is easier to just visualise him, in a cynical sort of way. He is the quintessential government employee, not reaching office before 11AM, sitting on a chair all day and not working, taking regular breaks for having cups of tea under the banyan tree outside his office, with a constant eye on the watch, so that he can leave office the moment it strikes 5PM (or may be even 4PM in some cases). Oh and of course, to do any work the babu needs to be paid a bribe (how could have I missed out on that).

The Bangla singer Nachiketa has a fantastic song defining a babu, it's called aami sorkari karamchari (I am a government employee). Those who do not understand Bangla can listen to the Hindi version of the song by the same singer here. I guess a better song has not been written stereotyping the government in India, since this song came out sometime in the 1990s.

Now to get back to the topic at hand. So we have some sort of a definition of who is a babu, in place. But why am I talking about babus today? The Seventh Pay Commission has recommended a 23.6% overall increase in the salaries of central government employees and the pensions of retired central government employees, who are typically referred to as babus.


Advertisement
  Equitymaster Conference 2016  
23rd January. Mumbai, India
   
  It gives us great pleasure in extending you an invitation to join us at the Equitymaster Conference 2016. This is going to be one of our most important Conferences ever! And I strongly recommend you attend it.

At the Equitymaster Conference, our best ever line up of speakers, starting with Ajit Dayal (Founder, Equitymaster) and Bill Bonner (Founder, Agora Inc.) will aim to address all your questions about the current investment environment, thereby help you in planning your next steps. Including...

»  Where are the stock markets headed?
»  What should be your investment strategy for Indian stocks?
»  Is it finally time to get bullish on real estate?
»  Is the Gold story over?
»  What's next for India's economy, and the Indian Rupee?

Plus, at the Conference you will get an opportunity to rub shoulders with not just our speakers, but also like-minded investors from across India (Last year we welcomed guests from 33 cities, and 3 countries).

So if you are serious about your investments, The Equitymaster Conference 2016 is something you cannot afford to miss. More details about the Conference and our speaker line up are available here.

We suggest you move very fast on this invitation.

Reserve your seat under our 'Early Bird' opportunity!
 

This has led to a lot of outrage on the social media in particular and the media in general. People have raised a lot of rhetoric around whether lazy government employees need to be paid so much when they cannot seem to get any work done. Some people have asked why do salaries of corrupt babus need to be increased. Still others have asked, why can't the government decrease its size and not need to pay so much to so many babus.

In fact, the Seventh Pay Commission report has some data which will surprise you on this front. At least, it did surprise me. As on January 1, 2014, the central government employed a total of 33.02 lakh people against a sanctioned strength of 40.49 lakh.

Of the 33.02 lakh employees, 9.80 lakh were employed by the ministry of home affairs. These primarily include individuals working for the central paramilitary forces like central reserve police force (CRPF), Border Security Force (BSF) etc. The Railways employed another 13.16 lakh. The Defence employed another 3.98 lakh in civilian positions. And the Postal department employed 1.98 lakh. Though there is some controversy here.

The data obtained by the Seventh Pay Commission puts the number of employees working for India Post at 1.98 lakh. The expenditure budget of 2014 puts the number at 4.6 lakh. And data from Directorate General of Employment and Training suggests that the number of postal employees is at 2.09 lakh.

In fact, the same variation is seen when it comes to the number of people employed in defence in the civilian position. The expenditure budget of 2014 suggests 34,813, the DGET 3.75 lakh and the data obtained by the Seventh Pay Commission puts it at 3.98 lakh. I wonder how can there be such a huge difference between different estimates. Regular readers of The Daily Reckoning readers will also appreciate here, how difficult it is to write anything that is data oriented in India). Anyway, getting back to the matter at hand, for the sake of this analysis we will stick to the numbers that the Seventh Pay Commission has obtained.

If we were to leave out those employed by railways, post and ministry of home affairs, and those working in defence in civilian positions, the central government employs just 4.18 lakh people and that is clearly not huge in a country of more than 120 crore people.

Also, people working for the central paramilitary forces and even defence in civilian positions, clearly cannot be considered to be as babus, in the strictest sense of the term.

The India Post employees can possibly be considered as babus. If we add their numbers, then we get a 6.08 lakh central government employees who can be labelled as babus. While, the railway employees are not exactly known for their efficient way of working, but railways is an essential service and you need people to run it.

As the Seventh Pay Commission report points out: "In fact the number of personnel working in the Secretariat of ministries/departments, after excluding independent/statutory entities, attached and subordinate offices will add up to less than thirty thousands. The 'core' of the government, so to say, is actually very small for the Government of India, taken as a whole."

While it is not easy to compare one government with another, the Seventh Pay Commission does make an attempt to do that. As the report points out: "Available literature indicates that the size of the non-postal civilian workforce for the US Federal Government in the year 2012 was 21.30 lakh. This includes civilians working in US defence establishments. The corresponding persons in position in India for the Central Government in 2014 was 17.96 lakh8. The total number of federal/Central Government personnel per lakh of population in India and the US works out to 139 and 668 respectively."

What these data points clearly tell us is that the Indian government is not big at the central government level, at least. There is a "concentration of personnel in a handful of departments" like home ministry and railways ministry. The department of revenue is other big employer, the report points out.

So what can we learn from this? First and foremost that the central government may have babus who are not efficient at work, but it doesn't have too many of them. A major part of the increase in salaries recommended by the Seventh Pay Commission will go to the paramilitary forces, railways and defence personnel.

So a smaller government in terms of number of people at least at the central government may not be possible. Now this realisation has important repercussions.

The Seventh Pay Commission's recommendations will cost the government Rs 1,02,100 crore. Hence, even though the number of people is not huge, the salary plus pensions bill is huge, given the earning capacity of the government. And if the government continues to work in the way it currently is, there is a very good chance that this increased expenditure will end up screwing up the finances of the government like it had after the recommendations of the Sixth Pay Commission had been accepted in August 2008.

Given this, the government needs to work in a very efficient way. It needs to get rid of loss making public sector enterprises like MTNL and Air India. It also needs to raise more money by strategically selling its stake in other profit making public sector enterprises. It needs to make an inventory of all the land held by public sector enterprises and look at various ways of monetising it.

Further, steps need to be taken to increase the tax base, instead of taxing the same set of people over and over again. Domestic black money needs to be concentrated on. Right now the government clearly does not earn enough to finance the increase in salaries and pensions recommended by the Central Pay Commission.

Further, with people living longer and other developments like one rank one pension (which the seventh pay commission has recommended for all central government employees), the pension bill of the government is set to shoot up. In this scenario it is important that the government move the sections of the government still on the defined-benefit pension to defined-contribution pension.

The Seventh Pay Commission has also recommended a minimum pay of Rs 18,000 with effect from January 1, 2016. The allowances and other facilities will be over and above this pay. At lower levels the government pays much more than the private sector. And this explains to a large extent why you hear engineers, PhDs and doctors applying for jobs at lower levels of the government. This is an anomaly that needs to be set right. But I am not sure how determined this government (or for that matter any other government would have been) is to challenge the existing way of doing things.

Vivek Kaul is the Editor of the Diary and The Vivek Kaul Letter. Vivek is a writer who has worked at senior positions with the Daily News and Analysis (DNA) and The Economic Times, in the past. He is the author of the Easy Money trilogy. The latest book in the trilogy Easy Money: The Greatest Ponzi Scheme Ever and How It Is Set to Destroy the Global Financial System was published in March 2015. The books were bestsellers on Amazon. His writing has also appeared in The Times of India, The Hindu, The Hindu Business Line, Business World, Business Today, India Today, Business Standard, Forbes India, Deccan Chronicle, The Asian Age, Mutual Fund Insight, Wealth Insight, Swarajya, Bangalore Mirror among others.

Disclaimer: The views mentioned above are of the author only. Data and charts, if used, in the article have been sourced from available information and have not been authenticated by any statutory authority. The author and Equitymaster do not claim it to be accurate nor accept any responsibility for the same. The views constitute only the opinions and do not constitute any guidelines or recommendation on any course of action to be followed by the reader. Please read the detailed Terms of Use of the web site.

Recent Articles

Why It Feels like the Brexit Vote Never Happened December 13, 2017
The war is over, but the battle has only just begun. That's the summary of Prime Minister Theresa May's agreement with the EU on Brexit. Read on for more.
Bitcoin: Just a Game December 13, 2017
People say bitcoin is money. But whether it is real money or not is only something you can only know later...
Oil at Two-Year Highs as Saudi Arabia Engages in Its Own "Game of Thrones" December 12, 2017
Recently I identified five agents of change that I believe investors should know about right now. I'd like to add one more to the list: Mohammad bin Salman.
The GOP Tax Bill Is a Deep State Scam December 12, 2017
The mainstream press seems obsessed by the harm being done to Americans... by foreigners.

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Who is a babu?". Click here!

14 Responses to "Who is a babu?"

Subhash Kak

Nov 26, 2015

The word "babu" is the distortion of the Sanskrit "prabhu", lord. The English with their wicked sense of humour absorbed the highest local titles into the lowest ones in the new hierarchy. Thus "subedar", the chief of the province, became a lowly soldier, just above the conscript.

Like 

abhay dixit

Nov 25, 2015

There are two Daily Reckonings coming every day. Can we have two different names for posts by Bonner and Kaul?

Like 

Dr. Anilkumar G Garag

Nov 24, 2015

An article worth reading. But some of the things are overlooked in this article, there are 46 central universities, 19 IIMS, 31 NITs and other National Institues in India and they too have employees to the tune of a lakh or so.

I have been interacting with the civil service during the last 5 years and I find that these civil servants are the most overworked lot. They do not have the time to spend their salaries, usually their perks keep them going.

Let's be fair to these employees, I would put about 30% of the employees under the BABU head. other 70% seems to be overworked and has a general sense of despondency. These civil servants will usually get 10 times more salaries and perks if they quit and join the corporate world.

So its ok that you find all babus are lethargic and they just sip tea under the banyan tree, but they are still paid less than the corporate sector. where large scale daytime robbery is happening in the boardrooms and in the middle management.

Like 

chandra sekhar

Nov 24, 2015

I probably had unique experience of working both in government and in private sector. Few clarifications may be in order:

1.Not all babus are corrupt (because many do not get an opportunity)
2.For government, donkey and horse are the same (I bet, show me the difference).
3.Government neither know how much to pay nor how much to extract (govt. is a strange animal).
4.Babus act like sand in the bearing (they love it that way).
5.Anybody who criticize a babu, I would say, be in their 'kursi' and act differently (you get transformed in no time, believe me).
6.To be fair,Babus were paid pittance before fifth pay commission (should we give credit to that brainy chettiar).

Only way forward is down sizing government (it requires lot of ingenuity to down size and function efficiently)

I better stop here.

chandra sekhar

Like 

sethu

Nov 24, 2015

Vivek has very nicely defined BABU.

Viveks suggestion of privatising PSUs,Monetising the lands owned by railways etc are all very good;But these should be used for Public welfare and development projects;
Certainly not for paying the unwarranted increase in salaries of Govt. employees.

Like 

Girish Patkar

Nov 24, 2015

Governments world wide have a way of working which is described differently in each country ( inefficient in some, slow in some other country etc. But governments do work !

Time and again we have seen the private sector which engages the best of talent failing miserably on all parameters ( compliance, governance, profitability, ethics etc) and has to be rescued by the inefficient Government.

The only efficient section of society, non corrupt, is the media which is extremely alert, the critics who are prompt in their work, and the intelligentsia who are always right.

Unfortunately, criticism is easy, governance is difficult and therefore those who govern should get paid. Having said that,learning and efficiency improvement is a constant and applicable in every activity.


Girish





Like 

Penugonda Prabhakar

Nov 24, 2015

Iam P.Prabhakar others cheating to babu who is babu i dont know cheating tray babu is not believing you . All ready to my image photo will there in Agora.

yours lovely
Penugonda Prabhakar

Like 

Prakash Basrur

Nov 24, 2015

Isn't it strange after NDA coming to power just about 18 months ago that people , the illiterates to intellectuals , are suddenly demanding resolution of the myriad problems left by the previous governments in last 65 years ? Resolving the "Babu" issue seems to be one such problem that the writer has brought to the front ! Dismantling of Public Sector organisation is another ! I feel poor Modi made two unnecessary statements during his 2014 general election campaign , i.e. "Acche Din Ayenge" and "More governance and less Government" ! He is being cornered , within the first 18 months of taking over , on these two slogans he made forgettin hundreds of similar slogans like "Garibi Hatao" , "Democratic Socialism" made by his predecessors !
Do we expect NDA ( and Modi) to commit harakiri by taking the "Babudom" headon and write off their , once-in-a-while , win in the general election ? How could they reduce the number of paramilitary personnel when both Pakistan ( on the western front) and China (on the Eastern front) posing constant threat ? How to and how much to reduce Railway employment as Railways are the biggest employer in India ? I wish Modi had a magic wand with which all such 65 years old problems could be solved in "100 days" !

Like 

Nishith Tiwari

Nov 24, 2015

Dear Sir

When you have calculated only the Govt Employees in the Central govt.Once the 7th Pay commission is implemented for the Central govt there will be pressure on the State Govt's to implement the same.And as per the past history all the state govt will be forced to bring the salaries of their employees on par with the Central Govt employees.

And the no of employees employed by the state government is manifolds compared to the Central Govt employees.

Also the calibre of most of the State Govt employees is no match to the Central Govt employees. The inefficiency as well as corruption among the state govt employees is also higher.

Question : Do such employees deserve higher wages at the cost of tax payers money??? That too without any rating system to judge their efficiency

Yours truly

Like 

Girdhar Gopal Arora

Nov 24, 2015

well analyzed report. I would like to read a detailed report like this on: "How the big carporate like Vijay Malya, became successful to screw up the different banks in India and yet living a royal life without the fear of being adjudicated."

Like 
Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Who is a babu?". Click here!