P/E ratio’s: Reality check - Views on News from Equitymaster

Helping You Build Wealth With Honest Research
Since 1996. Try Now

  • MyStocks

MEMBER'S LOGINX

     
Login Failure
   
     
   
     
 
 
 
(Please do not use this option on a public machine)
 
     
 
 
 
  Sign Up | Forgot Password?  

P/E ratio’s: Reality check

Jan 19, 2002

One of the most commonly used tools for making an investment decision is the P/E ratio. This is due to the fact that that it is very easy to compute and more so, due to its easy availability. However, using the ratio without understanding its interpretation can be very dangerous especially for the retail investors, who have limited access to information. For sectors that have a long history, use of P/E ratios is less risky. However, for sectors that do not have much of a past, like software, the P/E ratio should be used with extreme caution. Infosys, in February 2000, touched a peak of Rs 16,932. This would translate to a P/E multiple of 382x its FY00 earnings. Yet many investors bought the stock as if there was no tomorrow, only to repent later. In times of irrational exuberance, the P/E ratio can give a clue about the insanity in valuations. In this article we look at how the P/E ratio can in help you avoid making such hazardous investment decisions.

Let us start with what is the P/E ratio. P/E ratio is calculated by dividing the market price of the stock by the EPS (earnings per share).

Earnings Per Share, EPS (Rs) = Profit After Tax ------------------ No of shares outstandingPrice to earnings ratio, P/E (x) = Market Price ---------------- Earnings Per Share (Rs)

The P/E ratio can be looked at as a price tag – how many times the earnings is the market willing to pay to be part of the company’s fortunes. The reciprocal of the P/E ratio (dividing 1 by the P/E) would give the earnings yield on the stock. For example the P/E of a stock is 12, then reciprocal works out to be an 8.3% yield. Another way of looking at the P/E ratio is that if the company’s earnings did not grow at all in the future, it would take company P/E number of years to get back the money invested into the company. When Infosys was trading at a P/E multiple of 382 times, assuming no growth in earnings it would have taken 382 years for the company to earn the investment back for the investor. We are looking at some really long-term investors here.

And of course no one is willing to wait perpetually to get a return on his or her investments. Thus, the higher the P/E multiple investors are willing to pay, greater will be the hopes of getting the investment amount back in a shorter time horizon. Therefore, generally a high P/E would be based on expectations of higher growth in earnings.

More often than not, P/E ratio is used as relative valuation tool. Different companies from the same sector are compared on the basis of this ratio. Also, many times sector averages are used as a benchmark to compare valuations of different companies.

However, creating sector averages are prone to errors. We have an average P/E of 27x (for FY04) by taking six companies in a sample for the software sector. For example, if Hughes Software were to replace Wipro, the P/E could come down from 27x to 24x.

CompanyMarket Cap
(Rs bn)*
PAT
(Rs bn)
P/E
(x)
CompanyMarket Cap
(Rs bn)*
PAT
(Rs bn)
P/E
(x)
Wipro 341 10 33.0 Hughes 17 1 22.0
Infosys 347 12 27.9 Infosys 347 12 27.9
Satyam 97 6 17.5 Satyam 97 6 17.5
i-flex 40 2 22.2 i-flex 40 2 22.2
Geometric 3 0 11.8 Geometric 3 0 11.8
MphasiS 17 1 16.9 MphasiS 17 1 16.9
Sector 844 31 27.0   521 22 23.9
*All numbers for FY04.

However, the greater risk that is embedded in a relative valuation exercise that uses P/E multiple is, that there is an intrinsic assumption that the markets are valuing the firms in question correctly. This is a very brave assumption to make. This might not be the case always. While the investor has to take in to account the fact that the markets do generally tend to be correct, the same markets do end up with average P/E ratios of 27x for a sector. Therefore, to get a bearing on realistic P/E ratios investors can use two methods and thus, cross check to find a rational price for the stock.

  • First method is to calculate a P/E ratio for a stock and compare it with the P/E ratios the markets are using.

  • Second method is to look at the PEG ratio. That looks at the P/E ratio in light of the future growth in earnings.

In the past we have seen that stock price is a function of the expected dividends in the future. Therefore, we have

DP0 = ---- r-gPO= stock priceD= Dividend expected at the end of the yearr= required rate of returng=perpetual growth rate expected

For calculation of rate of return please follow this link Expected rate of returns


Dividend can be also expressed as = EPS x Payout ratioModifying we have
PO = EPS0 x Payout ratio *(1+g) ------------------------------- (r-g)Where EPS0 is the current EPS for the companyTherefore,P0 = Payout ratio*(1+g)---- --------------------------EPS0 (r-g)P0 = P/E ----EPS0Therefore, P/E = Payout ratio*(1+g) ------------------------- (r-g)

HLL that has a pay out ratio of about 90%, has seen earnings grow at a CAGR of 25% for between 1986 and 2004. Assuming a perpetual growth rate of 10% for the company and a required rate of return of 14% the P/E ratio works out to be 14x times. The stock is currently trading at a P/E multiple of about 17x. Obviously, the markets are factoring in a slightly higher growth rates.

Thus, based on the same assumptions for calculating the stock price, the P/E ratio can be estimated. However, the problem with this method is that retail investors need to make assumptions about the discount rate, payout ratio and perpetual growth rates. These being not so widely available would be very difficult to approximate. And if any one was to make the effort, why not calculate the stock price? There is merit in the argument. We want to point out here is that many times P/E ratio is used because there is a misconception that while using P/E ratios the need to make assumptions about the above mentioned variables are eliminated. However, one must appreciate that this is not a number pulled out of a hat, but the ratio is determined by the same assumptions that go into determining the stock price.

However for those who do not want to get involved in the complex process of valuing a stock the PEG ratio, is a tool that can help.

The PEG ratio is the ratio of the P/E ratio to future growth in earnings. This is based on the thumb rule that the P/E ratio should be equal to future earnings growth for the stock. Therefore, if the stock has a P/E ratio of 35, this should be supported by earnings growth of 35% in the future. It is preferable to use a CAGR for next two to three years. The future growth rates can be determined from company’s earnings guidance or research reports on the companies that give projections about future earnings. Equitymaster’s research reports give three-year forward projections for companies under our coverage.

Thus, this helps to justify whether the EPS has future growth potential to support the P/E. In that sense this becomes an indispensable tool for the investor.

PEG = P/E ratio (x) -------------------------- Growth in earnings (%)

The number is calculated by dividing the P/E ratio by the expected growth in earnings. For example, Infosys has a P/E of 28x (based on FY04 earnings) and the CAGR growth in earnings is expected to be 22%. Therefore, the company’s PEG ratio will be 1.3 (28/22). The use of the PEG ratio is however based on a thumb rule and is not a valid financial law. The two sides of the formula have different units: you're comparing a fraction with a percent, meaning that a factor of 100 has magically appeared on one side only.

Taking on from here investors should be very cautious about stocks that are trading at PEG ratio’s of more than 0.8.

Company*Current Market
Price
EPS
(FY07E, Rs)
P/E
(x)
CAGR
(FY02E-FY04E)
PEG
Infosys 5,235 337 15.5 21.9% 0.7
Wipro 1,447 77 18.9 19.9% 0.9
Satyam 310 31 10.0 20.4% 0.5
* As on 3rd June 2004 close

Wipro and Infosys look highly valued based on the PEG ratio. However, this ratio does not reflect the huge amount of cash these companies are carrying on their balance sheet. Infosys has around Rs 6,000 m (US$ 125 m) balance sheet if its buys a business at a market cap to sales ratio of 1.5x spending Rs 3,000 m (US$ 62.5 m), the company can add about 8% to its topline.

The thumb rule that the P/E ratio should be equal to the future growth in earrings for a stock is actually based on the time value of money. The P/E ratio is an indication how much should investors pay for a company? A company that is growing twice as fast is worth twice as much.

But PEG is not suitable to value cyclical companies like semiconductors and chemical manufacturers, airlines, utilities, or financial companies like banks. It is also not useful in valuing large, well-established companies. Also, a low PEG ratio might not mean necessarily mean that the company is undervalued. There a lot of certain facts about a company that the P/E ratio does not reflect like the amount of debt in the company.

There are two parts to selecting a company the first one is about finding out a viable business model and second part is about finding a correct price for the stock or put a correct value to the stock. In this article we have looked at trying to put a value to the stock but more the focus has been to a clue on how realistic valuations are. All these tools can only aid. All these tools can also be used against you to justify things like the information technology revolution, which ultimately turned out to be an evolution. They are no substitute for rational thinking and patience.

For high growth stocks like Infosys a two-stage model has to be used. A growth rate and payout ratio is assumed for the super normal growth period. A lower growth rate and higher payout ratio is assumed for subsequent period of time.

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "P/E ratio’s: Reality check". Click here!

1 Responses to "P/E ratio’s: Reality check"

Dr. Rajeev Kapur

Dec 19, 2013

A lot of mambo-jumbo that is bound to confuse most of the investors. These ratios are more likely to mislead than give correct guidance. The most important factor is the quality of management in terms of their integrity, honesty and business acumen. The track record of promotors tells you more than the PE and PEG ratios. Investing in Infosys is safer any day compared to Satyam - no matter what is the PE or PEG ratio. A sinking business will have low PE and may show a low PEG ratio with a bit of window dressing by the promotors or by the brokers pushing that stock.

Like 
  
Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "P/E ratio’s: Reality check". Click here!

More Views on News

Mirae Asset Tax Saver Fund: Seizing Superior Growth Opportunities (Outside View)

Apr 9, 2021

PersonalFN's analysis on the features and performance of Mirae Asset Tax Saver Fund.

Time to Change Our Trading Blueprint? (Fast Profits Daily)

Apr 9, 2021

The Indian government recently announced cut backs on crude oil imports from Saudi Arabia. Does this change our crude oil trading blueprint. Find out...

An India Revival Stock I'm Bullish On... (Profit Hunter)

Apr 9, 2021

This could take India to the position of 3rd largest economy.

Key Reasons Why Mutual Funds Turned Net Buyers in March 2021 (Outside View)

Apr 8, 2021

Domestic mutual funds have turned net buyers worth Rs 2,476 crore in the Indian equity markets in March 2021 for the first time in the last 10 months.

The Indians Are Coming (Fast Profits Daily)

Apr 8, 2021

In this video, I'll tell you why the Indian consumer has started to take the price of gold and silver higher.

More Views on News

Most Popular

A Critical Update on the Market (Fast Profits Daily)

Mar 30, 2021

In this video, I'll tell you why I am recommending caution in the market at this time.

My Recent Recommendation Will Profit from the Global Supply Chain Crisis (Profit Hunter)

Mar 31, 2021

A tiny chemical company, started in the Licence Raj era, is a great example of a new wealth creating opportunity.

My Stock Trading Strategy (Fast Profits Daily)

Mar 31, 2021

In this video I'll show you exactly how I go about picking stocks for trading.

What You Need to Find Hundred Baggers (Profit Hunter)

Mar 30, 2021

100 baggers of the last decade share this common trait. Here's how to use it to nail future multibaggers.

More

India's #1 Trader
Reveals His Secrets

Secret To Increasing Your Trading Profits Today
Get this Special Report,
The Secret to Increasing Your Trading Profits Today, Now!
We will never sell or rent your email id.
Please read our Terms

S&P BSE SENSEX


Apr 9, 2021 (Close)

MARKET STATS