Buyback: What should a retail investor do? - Views on News from Equitymaster

Helping You Build Wealth With Honest Research
Since 1996. Try Now

  • MyStocks

MEMBER'S LOGINX

     
Login Failure
   
     
   
     
 
 
 
(Please do not use this option on a public machine)
 
     
 
 
 
  Sign Up | Forgot Password?  

Buyback: What should a retail investor do?

Mar 3, 2011

An investor buys a stock with the intention to earn returns. These returns accrue over a period of time. So why would a company buy its own stock? To earn returns on itself? Sounds confusing? Well read on to understand more.

Time and again you must have come across this word "Buyback". In a buyback, the company purchases its own shares from the market. Then it often cancels them or keeps them as treasury shares. (Treasury shares are the shares that may have come from a buyback or may have never been issued to the public in the first place. These stocks don't have any voting rights and they don't pay dividends as well. Hence they are not included in shares outstanding.) The result of the whole buyback process is that the number of shares outstanding for the company is brought down.

But many wonder as to what should be their course of action when a company announces a buyback? Should one tender their shares or hold on to it for further returns. To understand a course of action, one needs to understand another important thing. That is, what are the objectives of the buyback?

The company may be buying back its own shares due to any reasons. The reason may be to increase promoters' holding or to delist the company. It may also be to pay back the shareholders the surplus cash that is not required by the business. This helps the company in improving performance ratios like earnings per share and return on equity. This simply happens because after buyback the number of shares outstanding and invested equity capital go down. The reason for the buyback could also be to support share value or to thwart takeover bids.

Suppose the company is cash rich and cannot find any suitable avenue to generate additional returns on the same. Then it is best to return the excess cash to the shareholders. So the company may use the excess cash to buy back its own shares.

Now let's us discuss what should we do if we find a buyback offer in the stock markets. As suggested in the past, we suggest that one should refrain from trading. It would be better not to buy shares just to participate in the open offer. One may well lose money instead as is discussed later. But if one is already holding the shares, one may very well decide as per the merit of the case.

Case 1: After the buyback, the company will be delisted

This is a no brainer. Please tender the shares. After delisting one may face difficulties in selling one's shares in the future.

Case 2: Buyback is to support share prices and improve future performance ratios

Here we need to go back to fundamental research of the company. If improvement in the performance is sustainable then it would make more sense to hold on to the stock for a longer period. Else one might think of tendering in part and holding the rest for the future returns.

Case 3: Buying the shares just to participate in the buyback offer

There are people who do buy the shares just to participate in the buyback offer. This is something that we suggest our readers to avoid. Why? Let us try and understand it better through an example of Goodyear India.

On 9th Feb 2010, Goodyear India made an announcement to start the delisting process and announced a share buyback. The offer failed due to an inadequate number of shares tendered for the process. The company made the announcement for the same on 17th June 2010. In the whole process share price of Goodyear India zoomed from Rs 186 on 8th Feb 2010 to Rs 360 on 19th May 2010. Finally it came down to Rs 250 on 17th June 2010. After that it never crossed Rs 300 and 18th June 2010 onwards the average price for this share is Rs 256.

Source: CMIE Database

From the above chart it is very clear that the most of the people, who were looking to make a quick buck bought shares at higher levels. However, as the buyback failed, these shares crashed down. As a result, these people were stuck with the losses, which could not be recovered subsequently as the share price did not go back to the peak levels.

Even risk-reward analysis shows that doing trade here was not a good idea at all. No one can predict the very outcome of the whole process. It is also interesting to note that the buyback offer document had suggested a price indication of Rs 245 only. So even in the case of successful buyback, the upside was very limited. It was just the market's greed that sent the share prices north of the buyback price. But it lured several innocent people in the process.

In this case, it would be better for the people to stay away from the company. It is important to remember that buybacks are for existing shareholders only. It should not be used as a means for making a quick buck because if the buyback offer fails then the short term gain may turn out to be a long term pain. At the end of the day, it is all about the fundamentals and intentions of the company announcing the buyback. It is important to understand the underlying reason before deciding on a course of action.


Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Buyback: What should a retail investor do?". Click here!

10 Responses to "Buyback: What should a retail investor do?"

BHARAT JAMDAR

May 3, 2019

WHO IS PARTICIPATE IN BUY BACK OFFE. ALL SHARE HOLDER APPLAY OR NOT
CORPORATE A/C,INDIVIDUAL A/C,HUF A/C,TRUSTEE A/C.

Like 

Rita

Sep 2, 2017

How do I submit my shares in buyback if I am out of country for 3 months and meanwhile a company of which I hold shares brings out buyback which would end before my reaching back to India?

Like (15)

Girish

Aug 21, 2017

Sir,
Should I participate in Infosys buyback? My cost is Rs.992 per share.

Like (29)

subbarayuduborra

May 17, 2017

I have 10 shares of tcs iwant to buyback theshares what can i do

Like (4)

kamal

Mar 16, 2011

Anil

here in buyback u wont get long term securities holding tax benefit.....so it is less than 1 yr holding then its ok...otherwise u shud take care of tax thing in mind....

so far only 13% share of total buyback size is tendered ...so u shud wait till last to look what ppl are doing...

if others are interested and u think this company has value....u can hold on....

if ppl are giving away the shares....u too shud....as promotors holding will increase and then future will be in the hand of promoters......

so it depends on ur risk return thing....if 600 meets ur target,......book ur profit.....

so tax, risk return n ur view on company....take everything together n decide

Like (4)

praveen

Mar 16, 2011

david

u will be getting the offer....offer will be dispatched by 18th march....u can read here

u can read announcement made by company on BSE....they have revised a few things .....and announced on 16th march the same...

Like (2)

ANIL SURVE

Mar 14, 2011

I hold 50 shares of piramal health cares, co. offer the buy back at Rs.600/ at present price is Rs 465/. pl. guide me .

Like (17)

david p george

Mar 13, 2011

i hold 50 shares of Siemens , ofter the announcement of 'buy back'it's price has been stable in a volatile market .my question is , will i be getting any offer/message from the company on this subject?

Like (2)

vivek

Mar 8, 2011

Well Patni case is bit different but answer lies here only.....see after getting hold on patni , it will take time to get synergy....and growth may suffer and as we have seen in the past....MNC try to delist and in the process minority shareholder alwz get the raw deal.....if see the article.....

MphasiS : Unfair deal to minority shareholders? on the website ...

it talks abt the same and you will have ur answer.....

Like (1)

Capt Veeresh

Mar 8, 2011

What should be done for Patni buyback since this is from merger & acquisition perspective?

Like (1)
  
Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Buyback: What should a retail investor do?". Click here!

More Views on News

How to Pick Stocks for Trading podcast (Views On News)

May 26, 2020

The year 2020 has been a difficult one for everybody including traders. You deserve a pat on the back if you have stayed above water in 2020. However, if you haven't done so well then don't worry, I am here to help.

What Should I Trade Today? (Fast Profits Daily)

May 26, 2020

What to trade is the most important decision a trader has to make everyday. In this video I will show you how to make that decision.

6 Charts Showing the State of Indian Financial Markets in 2020 (Sector Info)

May 26, 2020

Six charts showing how Indian financial markets have performed in 2020 so far...

This Smallcap is on the Frontline in the Battle Against Coronavirus (Profit Hunter)

May 26, 2020

For investors who act with discretion, it could be the best year as quality stocks are available at beaten down valuations and rebound from these levels could be sharp.

The Coronavirus Impact on the Indian Economy - 8 Points to Track (Sector Info)

May 25, 2020

These 8 pointers indicate how coronavirus pandemic has painted a gloomy picture for Indian economy but there's a silver lining...

More Views on News

Most Popular

Pick the Best Multibagger Stocks in 2020

Every investor is looking for multibaggers stocks. Get free guidance for buying the best multibagger stocks online in india a...

Protect Your Wealth from Fund Managers (Fast Profits Daily)

May 14, 2020

Do you know how much you are paying in fees to your mutual fund? In this video I'll share with you my views.

Of India's 20 Trillion Stimulus Package and the Swoosh Index for a Swoosh Recovery (Profit Hunter)

May 13, 2020

For India's rapid economic recovery, hopping on to the Swoosh index is a must.

How Commodity Prices Tell You When Stocks Will Go Up (Fast Profits Daily)

May 20, 2020

Commodity prices often provide clues to big moves in stock markets. In today's video, I'll explain this link.

This 'Essential Product' Smallcap is a Must Have for a 'Covid-19' Immune Portfolio (Profit Hunter)

May 19, 2020

This smallcap company needs no stimulus measures to do well in the long term.

More

How to Trade the
Coronavirus Crash

Coronavirus Crash
Get this special report, authored by Equitymaster's top analysts, now.
We will never sell or rent your email id.
Please read our Terms

S&P BSE SENSEX


May 26, 2020 (Close)

MARKET STATS