Do rating agencies deserve such lofty valuations? - Views on News from Equitymaster

Helping You Build Wealth With Honest Research
Since 1996. Try Now

  • MyStocks


Login Failure
(Please do not use this option on a public machine)
  Sign Up | Forgot Password?  

Do rating agencies deserve such lofty valuations?

Apr 18, 2012

They are not the only blue eyed babies of stock investors in India. There are plenty in their class, when one compares pedigree, fundamentals and management. But these entities, unlike their peers in the West have managed to do what even the MNC parents haven't. They look the regulators in the eye while the likes of Standard & Poor's and Moody's face the fury of the SEC.

In fact India can be called a paradise for rating agencies. There are six of them, with the biggest of them all, CRISIL, having a market value in excess of US$ 1.3 bn. Each of these entities shares the same business model as that of their global counterparts, albeit with slight differences.

The issuer of debt pays for the credit rating resulting in conflict of interest on the part of the rating agency. That the likes of CRISIL and ICRA also offer ratings on IPOs and stocks and consulting services makes their business model slightly more resilient to volatility in bond markets.

But what really intrigues us is that fact that irrespective of market cycles, the rating agencies have managed to fetch valuations that very few blue chips can boast of. That too despite the fact that the Indian regulators too have frowned upon the loopholes in their business model.

Leave aside debt, many listed companies are happy to share 'sponsored' research reports on themselves citing attractive investment prospects by the rating agencies.

However, one cannot deny that it is lure of zero debt balance sheets, high return ratios and mouth watering dividend payouts that attracts investors to the stocks of rating agencies.

However, investors cannot lose sight of the fact that the high PE ratios have diminished the dividend yields despite the handsome payouts.

Hence unless they have been early investors in the stock, they are less likely to benefit from the extra returns. Also since the dividend yields now account for only a couple of percentage points of return, investors will have to rely on at least 15% to 20% profit growth to fetch good returns.

Steep valuations diminish returns
  P/E ratio (x) Dividend yield (%)
CY08 12.7 2.8
CY09 19.9 2.3
CY10 20.5 3.4
CY11 30.1 1.2
FY08 24.2 1.5
FY09 12.6 2.5
FY10 16.5 1.9
FY11 22.5 1.6
Data source: Ace Equity

At the same time, regulatory hurdles could sooner or later deal a blow to the conflict of interest in the business model of rating agencies.

The cases of micro finance and gold loan companies are there for us to see. Hence we believe that instead of getting blinded by the high return ratios and dividend payouts, investors should get more realistic about the valuations the companies deserve for sustainable growth rate.

Tanushree Banerjee

Tanushree Banerjee (Research Analyst), is the editor of Stock Select and, ValuePro Equitymaster's oldest recommendation services. She is also the editor of Equitymaster's most popular newsletter read by over 300,000 subscribers, The 5 Minute WrapUp. Tanushree started her career at Equitymaster covering the banking and financial sector stocks and scrutinising RBI policies. Over the last decade, she developed Equitymaster's research processes that helped us pick out various multibaggers, across all sectors. A firm believer of "safety first" when it comes to investing, Tanushree closely follows the investing philosophies of Warren Buffett, Jeremy Grantham, and Joel Greenblatt.

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Do rating agencies deserve such lofty valuations?". Click here!

1 Responses to "Do rating agencies deserve such lofty valuations?"


Apr 18, 2012

Yes they do. Ask Warren Buffet.
In Indian context there may be a question on ethics with conflict of interest going unnoticed as the regulator may be asked by the Govt to look the other way or it may do so on its own. A good, ethical ratin agency will definitely command a premium in the market as there will be few who can match it in quality.

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Do rating agencies deserve such lofty valuations?". Click here!

More Views on News

BSE Sensex Surges 510 Points; ONGC Among Top Gainers (Market Updates)

Sep 28, 2020 | Updated on Sep 28, 2020

The BSE Sensex Surged 510 Points; ONGC Among Top Gainers. Find the latest update, special reports and news on all time high gainers of BSE Sensex at

Why the Market May Rally for a Few Days (Fast Profits Daily)

Sep 28, 2020

Why I think the market can rise for the next few days.

My Top Pick for 2021 is Not a Stock. It is Something Much More Powerful (Profit Hunter)

Sep 28, 2020

My top pick for 2021 is something that has helped me and my subscribers beat the stock market by a factor of 2:1.

Your Queries on the 8-Year Cycle Answered (Fast Profits Daily)

Sep 25, 2020

You've sent in your queries on my videos on the 8-year greed and fear cycle in the market. I'll answer them in this video.

It's When You Sell that Counts (Profit Hunter)

Sep 25, 2020

How I alerted readers to the impending crash last week.

More Views on News

Most Popular

High Dividend Stocks

Find all : Top Dividend Yield Stocks, Top High Dividend Stocks, Top Dividend Paying Stocks. High-dividend stocks can be a goo...

Why We Picked This Small-cap Stock for Our Hidden Treasure Subscribers (Profit Hunter)

Sep 17, 2020

This leading household brand will profit big time in a post covid world.

My Top Stock to Buy in this Market Selloff (Profit Hunter)

Sep 22, 2020

The recent correction offers a great opportunity to buy this high conviction smallcap stock.

Can the Nifty Fall to 10,200? (Fast Profits Daily)

Sep 24, 2020

The Nifty has reached an important support level today. If it breaks then we could see further downside.

What Do the Charts Say About Buying Smallcaps Now? (Fast Profits Daily)

Sep 18, 2020

Everyone seems to be excited about buying smallcaps now...but is it the right thing to do? What do the charts tell us? Find out in this video...


Covid-19 Proof
Multibagger Stocks

Covid19 Proof Multibaggers
Get this special report, authored by Equitymaster's top analysts now!
We will never sell or rent your email id.
Please read our Terms


Sep 28, 2020 (Close)