Is Trading in Equities, Commodities, and Currencies the Same? - Views on News from Equitymaster

Helping You Build Wealth With Honest Research
Since 1996. Try Now

  • MyStocks


Login Failure
(Please do not use this option on a public machine)
  Sign Up | Forgot Password?  
  • Home
  • Outlook Arena
  • May 30, 2019 - Is Trading in Equities, Commodities, and Currencies the Same?

Is Trading in Equities, Commodities, and Currencies the Same?

May 30, 2019

Since the last few years I have noticed ladies wearing tights (lycra slacks). These are close to our traditional Indian salwars. They come in various colours and are literally a rage. The best part is, being made of lycra, which is a stretch material, you get a one size fits all. This is a win-win situation for everyone.

Can something like that exist in the financial markets?

A secret sauce or a hidden system that helps you "conquer" commodities, currencies, equities and bonds alike?

A one-size-fits-all type of solution?

In my humble opinion it is a Utopian idea. Allow me to explain....

If you want to take a dog out for a walk, you know the dog will not walk along a straight line. The younger puppies are the friskiest and the most mischievous. The older dogs are more stable and need little or no monitoring.

Since both the kinds of dogs have unique energy, mischief, and unpredictability levels, the length of the leash around the dogs' necks will also differ.

--- Advertisement ---
From Sensex 40,000 to Sensex 100,000…

After news of Modi's win came out…

The Sensex briefly hit 40,000 in a bout of euphoria – the highest it's ever been at.

And we have no doubt that the Sensex will see many new highs under Modi's leadership…

Sensex 100,000, as we've predicted in many of our writeups, could be here in the years to come.

And 4 stocks have the potential to benefit the most.

Full details here.

Read all about this opportunity before it's too late.

Similarly, the daily price movement of various asset classes is also different. If each asset class was to be equated with a puppy, each would require a different length of the leash.

So can you analyse all of them using a template approach that says 'one-size-fits-all'? I think not.

Let's dig a little deeper...

Sugar is traded on the commodity exchanges, but doesn't really fluctuate beyond 10% in price, in an average month. It is a politically sensitive commodity that causes reverberations in the seat of power.

Now any sugar cane farmer will gladly tell you that the sugar crop has a 7 to 8-year cycle. After planting sugarcane and harvesting it, the soil slowly starts to get "tired" after about four to five years of continuous cane crops. Thereafter it starts downsizing in terms of crop output and this down phase last for approximately 2 to 3-years. Then a 4 to 5-year upswing in the output follows, ad infinitum.

If you analyse the stock price movement of leading sugar mills, you see a corresponding pattern. In the upswing years of farm output of cane, markets are over stocked and share prices are under pressure. The plain vanilla Dow theory of technical analysis states that prices declining by 20% or more qualifies as a bear market. By that yardstick sugar share prices are a string of multiple bear markets during the phase when sugar shares are down, due to excessive supply of sugar in the market.

Once the downswing in the farm output of cane commences, those same sugar stocks are known to become 10 baggers. Yet sugar prices on the exchanges hardly move 10 to 15%, and this occurs every 7 to 8 years in a perpetual loop.

Now tell me... would you use the same system to trade sugar that hardly moves 10 to 15% on commodity exchanges, and sugar stocks on the stock exchanges that can become 10 baggers? I don't think so.

Here's another good example...

Currencies are traded in pairs and the most liquid is the USDINR. Currencies are traded in four decimal points just as bonds are. The international derivative traders association has indicated that forex may be traded in 6 decimals in the coming few years.

It takes months sometimes for the currency pair to pass the next round figure, say from 70 to 71.

Can you really trade commodities and currencies alike or for that matter, equities and currencies alike? Definitely not!

Then there is one more aspect: traded volumes.

Since equities can be multibaggers, people tend to buy a few hundred shares and wait for a big price move. And stocks oblige them too.

To make the same amount of money in commodities, as compared to equities, that trader takes an exposure of 10 to 12 times more.

But in currencies (which trade in the 4th decimal), he might windup exposing himself to maybe hundred times more exposure as compared to equities.

And that, dear reader, is the major difference in asset classes that makes trading them not as simple as buying like lycra slacks.

One size does not fit all.

Have a profitable day.

Warm regards,

Vijay L Bhambwani
Editor and Research Analyst, Weekly Cash Alerts

Vijay Bhambwani

Vijay L Bhambwani, is the editor of Weekly Cash Alerts and Fast Income Alerts. He is a professional trader, author, trading mentor, and lifelong student of the markets. He has been an active trader since 1986. Financial markets are his life and passion. Everything else in his life revolves around his main objective - trading. Vijay believes that no matter how much a trader has lost in the market, it is possible with hard work and smart work to get it all back over time. Understanding the method behind the madness of the markets interests him more than the profits. He specialises in predictive style of technical analysis, in the commodity, currency, and equity markets. That is the foundation stone of his style of trading - Neuro Behavioural Technical Analysis. Vijay trains other professional traders. He is empaneled with the BSE & NSE as a visiting faculty for various finance market courses. He created the early course content for the Diploma in Commodity Markets (DICM), certified by the Forward Markets Commission. He was a training mentor at the MCX between 2005-2009. He is the first author to have his book - A Traders Guide to Indian Commodity Markets published by CNBC Publishing 18, in 2009 - approved and sponsored by the NCDEX. Vijay has done over 8,000 TV shows in the last 17 years and has written over 4,000 columns/articles in the print and electronic media. He is one of the first columnists to write a weekly column in the English language print media after the commissioning of the MCX, via his columns in the DNA Money, Business Standard and others. Vijay lives with his family in the posh Breach Candy area in Mumbai.

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Is Trading in Equities, Commodities, and Currencies the Same?". Click here!


More Views on News

The Coronavirus Impact on the Indian Economy - 8 Points to Track (Sector Info)

May 25, 2020

These 8 pointers indicate how coronavirus pandemic has painted a gloomy picture for Indian economy but there's a silver lining...

What the RBI's Rate Cut Means for Options Traders (Fast Profits Daily)

May 25, 2020

The RBI governor has cut the repo rate to 4%. What does this mean for options traders? Find out in this video.

Who Will Be Crowned the 'Multibagger Blue Chip' of the Decade? (Profit Hunter)

May 25, 2020

Will the mutlibagger blue chips of the past decade continue to rule the bourses?

Stocks to Buy, Sell and Hold Right Now podcast (Views On News)

May 22, 2020

The markets continue to be volatile due to the covid-19 situation. Here's what retail investors should do with their stocks...

Passively Managed Funds Can Help You Earn Better Returns Amidst Market Turbulence (Outside View)

May 22, 2020

In this Daily Weekly Report, PersonalFN explains about why you shouldnt ignore Passive funds.

More Views on News

Most Popular

Commodities Trading: From Pits to Screen

Trading in commodities is perhaps as old as the human civilization. Find out how it will unfold in the future

Protect Your Wealth from Fund Managers (Fast Profits Daily)

May 14, 2020

Do you know how much you are paying in fees to your mutual fund? In this video I'll share with you my views.

Covid-19 Offers a Rare Opportunity to Own This Brand Leader (Profit Hunter)

May 12, 2020

Covid-19 has compounded uncertainties in investing but this smallcap company is strong enough to survive and even emerge stronger.

Of India's 20 Trillion Stimulus Package and the Swoosh Index for a Swoosh Recovery (Profit Hunter)

May 13, 2020

For India's rapid economic recovery, hopping on to the Swoosh index is a must.

How Commodity Prices Tell You When Stocks Will Go Up (Fast Profits Daily)

May 20, 2020

Commodity prices often provide clues to big moves in stock markets. In today's video, I'll explain this link.


How to Trade the
Coronavirus Crash

Coronavirus Crash
Get this special report, authored by Equitymaster's top analysts, now.
We will never sell or rent your email id.
Please read our Terms


May 22, 2020 (Close)