**Important: We hate spam as much as you do. Check out our Privacy Policy and Terms Of Use.
Discover the hidden reasons why Mr. Market values some public sector enterprises far beyond their current financials. It's not what you think!
Recently, I was going through the financials of a decorated PSU company, and I couldn't help but notice how Mr Market has been very generous in its valuation of the company.
Let us learn about this company through an interesting case study.
Here's the financial of two PSU companies. Now, you have to tell me which one deserves to be treated better by the investors.
Here's the P&L statement of the first one.
This PSU has more than doubled its topline in the last 10 years and same for the bottomline. Although the performance is stable, the growth is not very impressive. Over 10 years, the topline and bottomline should have atleast quadrupled. But instead, they have only doubled.
Here's the balance sheet of the same PSU. The company has a bit of a debt problem. It's debt to equity has consistently been higher than an acceptable level of 1x. Otherwise, the growth in balance sheet has been steady. It appears that the company makes its capital allocation quite judiciously and is not in a hurry to grow. So, the balance sheet is certainly leveraged but there is stability about it as well.
Now, let us move to the second PSU.
Well, if the performance of the first PSU, which doubled its topline and bottomline in 10 years was disappointing, this even is even more so. This PSU has grown its topline by only 50% over 10 years while its bottomline has grown by a little over 20%. However, like the first PSU, the performance has been largely stable.
When it comes to the winner, the first PSU seems to have a definite edge in this round.
Let us move on to the balance sheet of the second PSU.
Here, the balance sheet has not grown as fast as the first PSU with total size increasing by 50% from Rs 10,000 crores to Rs 15,000 crores. The good thing about this PSU is that it is a zero-debt company. Unlike the first company that was leveraged, this second PSU's debt has consistently been almost zero, which is certainly a good sign.
Hence, when it comes to the balance sheet, it is this PSU that has the edge in my view.
Let us talk about how their ROE's or return on equity has moved over the last 10 years. Here, both the PSUs have shown remarkable consistency in their ROEs. It is the first PSU however that has a slight edge over the second. All its ROEs i.e. 10-year, 5-year, 3-year and even latest, higher than the second PSU.
Here's the summary. While both the PSU's have shown stable performance over the years, based on numbers alone, it is the first PSU that has a slight edge over the second one in my opinion. Its growth was better and its return on equity was better. The only area where it lagged was the balance sheet. It had significantly higher debt relative to its equity as compared to the second PSU, which is virtually a debt free company.
So, maybe PSU 1 has an edge or may be it does not. However, here's the interesting bit.
Investors in the stock market have always valued the second PSU significantly higher than the first PSU. Yes, that's right. A PSU that has grown slower than the first one and which had lower ROEs, has enjoyed a much superior rating by the investors.
Over the last 10 years, investors have given the second PSU a PE multiple of more than 30x whereas the PE multiple given to the first one has been a little over 10x.
It is the same situation when it comes to the price to book value multiple. The second PSU has commanded a PBV multiple that's almost three times the PBV multiple of PSU 1.
The story is quite similar from a 5-year perspective as well. In short, investors have always put PSU2 on a much higher pedestal than PSU1.
But why is this the case? Why PSU1 hasn't earned the same respect as PSU2 despite having better growth and better return on equity historically.
Well, to be honest, I don't have a clear answer to this but I will make an attempt anyway.
But before I do that, let me reveal the names of the two stocks for you. PSU1 is none other than National Thermal Power Corporation or NTPC as it is popularly known as.
PSU2 on the other hand is Container Corporation of India or CONCOR as it is popularly known as.
Yes, Container Corporation has enjoyed a significantly higher PE multiples as well as PBV multiples over NTPC historically.
When you think about the business models of these companies and about the industries to which they belong, it does appear sensible that Container Corporation should be valued significantly higher than NTPC.
After all, power is a regulated sector with high capital intensity and limited growth prospects.
But despite Container Corporation's superior business model, it is not reflected in the numbers as yet. Its growth has lagged that of NTPC, and its return ratios are also at par or slightly below NTPCs. Then why is it that investors have been willing to pay a significant premium to buy shares of Container Corporation as compared to NTPC.
I am sure you would have heard of the famous book by Jim Collins titled Good to Great.
Good to Great had achieved a cult status back when I was doing my MBA and management students were often seen walking around with a copy of the book in their hands.
The book had a byline which went something like this. Good to Great...Why Some Companies Make the Leap.......and Others Don't.
Well, investors are hoping the exact same thing with Container Corporation of India or Concor Ltd. The reason it is getting significantly higher valuations as compared to NTPC is that the company is expected to make a leap from Good to Great.
There's no doubt that NTPC is a good company. But can it become a great company? Looks unlikely given the sector it belongs to and the regulatory oversight it finds itself under.
However, investors believe that Concor is certainly capable of taking that leap from Good to Great.
India dreams of becoming a developed nation by 2047. And if this dream has to turn into a reality, both our manufacturing as well as our exports have to step up. Without a robust manufacturing as well as exports set up, it will be very difficult for us to achieve a developed status.
And if manufacturing picks up, more goods will have to be transported through Concor's containers, its wagons and its rakes. More freight stations as well as container depots will have to be built, thus giving a big boost to both the topline as well as the bottomline growth of Concor.
It is this the possibility of this growth that is pulling investors towards Concor and making them pay a significant premium over its peers like NTPC.
Do you believe this dream of our will turn into a reality, making Concor one of the leading beneficiaries? If yes, then Concor certainly makes for a good long-term bet.
However, if you think that the competition in the sector is going to intensify and Concor would wallow in mediocrity like it has done in the past, then a caution is certainly warranted.
You will have to make up your mind fast as the opportunity of riding the manufacturing growth story through a stable and a strong business like Concor may not last long.
Let me know what you think. This brings me to the end of today's video. I will see you again next time. Good bye and happy investing.
Rahul Shah co-head of research at Equitymaster is the editor of (Research Analyst), Editor, Microcap Millionaires, Exponential Profits, Double Income, Midcap Value Alert and Momentum Profits. Rahul has over 20 years of experience in financial markets as an analyst and editor. Rahul first joined Equitymaster as a Research Analyst, fresh out of university in 2003 but left shortly after to pursue his dream job with a Swiss investment bank. However, he quickly became disillusioned working for the 'financial establishment'. He learned first-hand the greedy stereotype of an investment banker is true and became uncomfortable working for a company that put profit above everything else. In 2006, Rahul re-joined Equitymas ter to serve honest, hardworking Indians like his father, who want to take control of their financial future - and not leave it in the hands of greedy money managers. Following the investment principles of Benjamin Graham (the bestselling author of The Intelligent Investor) and Warren Buffet (considered the world's greatest living investor), Rahul has recommended some of the biggest winners in Equitymaster's history.
Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Is this PSU Getting an Unfair Premium? You Decide!". Click here!
1 Responses to "Is this PSU Getting an Unfair Premium? You Decide!"
Krishna Gopal
Jul 10, 2025It is evident from chart structure of both stocks they both are about give significant upside over period of 3-9 months. However FII+DII hold significant stake in Boths stocks. Stock 1 still is available at discount PEG ratio & Stock2 not able realise its full potential due to tariff war & wars & change in USA president election hits the businesses insignificant way, its sales ratio may about to be turn around in near future.