The importance of value creation - Views on News from Equitymaster

Helping You Build Wealth With Honest Research
Since 1996. Try Now

  • MyStocks


Login Failure
(Please do not use this option on a public machine)
  Sign Up | Forgot Password?  

The importance of value creation

Jul 17, 2001

In the last few years the capital markets have witnessed major changes like the permission granted to Foreign institutional investors (FII) to invest in India, introduction of derivatives, ban on badla trading, trading in demat format (electronic form), e-broking, the setting up of a market regulator etc….It saw the decline of UTI (Unit Trust of India) from its predominant position and the emergence of private sector players in the Indian mutual fund industry. In the last decade the Indian markets also witnessed many mini and mega scams and also participated in the global technology boom. With millions being made and lost in minutes, questions were abound in the minds of theoreticians and investors whether equity analysis is relevant and whether corporates take steps to create shareholder value and finally does the market punish companies that destroy shareholder value? I think equity analysis is important in at least identifying trends if not in timing of entry and exit prices. While there are some companies, which give importance to shareholder value, there is equal number of good corporates who took minority shareholders for granted and got punished in the process.

There are many methods of creating shareholder value but chief among them are created by:

  • Managements who have the vision to identify trends and invest in projects that generate positive net present value or

  • By managements who realize that they do not have adequate projects on hand to generate returns higher than they currently earn and therefore return the money in the form of higher dividend payout e.g. Hindustan Lever.

Alternatively shareholder value is destroyed by management who become obstinate and refuse to acknowledge change in trends or who react slowly to change in trends and by management who invest shareholders money in projects for which they are not adequately geared to handle.

Some of the listed automobile companies in India clearly bring out these issues. The following table shows the return generated by these companies and also the operating margins. You can also see how the market cap of the company declined in these years.

Avg ROE 28 24 22 21 18 -
OPM 16 15 15 13 5 -
Avg Market cap (Rs bn) 61 63 69 53 31 24
Avg ROE 25 8 3 2 (14) -
OPM 17 11 8 6 5 -
Avg Market cap (Rs bn) 116 82 52 60 26 18
Hero Honda
Avg ROE 44 46 49 52 47 -
OPM 9 11 12 13 14 -
Avg Market cap (Rs bn) 6 12 25 42 40 30
TVS Suzuki
Avg ROE 51 44 38 31 20 -
OPM 12 12 11 11 7 -
Avg Market cap (Rs bn) 4 8 10 11 7 2
* Based on current market price

Bajaj not only failed in identifying the trend against scooters, but also refused to take a decision on the huge amount of cash and investments it was holding in its balance sheet. The cash and investments that formed nearly 60% to 70% of balance sheet value was earning sub optimal returns. Belying the trust placed on the management, large part of the cash was also used to speculate in the stock markets. Result: Decline in shareholder value and decline in market cap.

Telco followed a different path that was quite opposite to what Bajaj did. It used the surplus and had to raise more money to invest in a project (the car project) whose returns were lower than what it was already earning. Hence for every incremental rupee it invested in the new project it was actually earning less than it was earning in its main commercial vehicle business. Agreed that the company might not have invested in these projects with any malafide intentions, but it clearly did not do its homework thoroughly and paid little respect to the advice of its well wishers. Result: Decline in shareholder value and decline in market cap.

TVS Suzuki probably got carried away with its own success and consequently suffered from blurred vision. The management failed to introduce 4 stroke vehicles in time to meet the requirement of changing environmental norms. Result it lost market share and also market cap.

Hero Honda is the only company that appears to have taken shareholders value seriously. It has improved its returns as well as margins. It however suffers from a peculiar problem currently, as Honda, its JV partner and global leader, has set up a 100% subsidiary. Consequently, markets are worried that the future cream lies in that subsidiary and not in Hero Honda. Result: A cap on market cap.

Will they change their ways?
Having seen the decline in market cap one only hopes that these companies learn from their mistakes and take value creation more seriously. The hope arises, as these are not some fly by night promoters, but promoters who have painstakingly established their name over many years of diligence.

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "The importance of value creation". Click here!


More Views on News

BSE Sensex Surges 600 Points; BAJAJ AUTO Among Top Gainers (Market Updates)

Oct 1, 2020 | Updated on Oct 1, 2020

The BSE Sensex Surged 600 Points; BAJAJ AUTO Among Top Gainers. Find the latest update, special reports and news on all time high gainers of BSE Sensex at

Nippon India Nifty Smallcap 250 Index Fund: High Risk in Passive Mode (Outside View)

Oct 1, 2020

PFN explains about the Nippon India Nifty Smallcap 250 Index Fund.

You Should Be looking for Small-cap Stocks that Will Rebound Strongly (Profit Hunter)

Oct 1, 2020

This single trait in excellent small cap businesses differentiates them from the rest.

This Number Will Give You an Edge Over Other Traders in the Market (Fast Profits Daily)

Sep 30, 2020

In this video, I'll share with you, a crucial number that I track everyday which gives me trading edge.

Is Mirae Asset Ultra Short Duration Fund a Right Solution for Your Short Term Needs? (Outside View)

Sep 30, 2020

PFN explains about the Mirae Asset Ultra Short Duration Fund.

More Views on News

Most Popular

My Top Stock to Buy in this Market Selloff (Profit Hunter)

Sep 22, 2020

The recent correction offers a great opportunity to buy this high conviction smallcap stock.

Can the Nifty Fall to 10,200? (Fast Profits Daily)

Sep 24, 2020

The Nifty has reached an important support level today. If it breaks then we could see further downside.

I Believe These Stocks Will Deliver the Most Outsized Returns in 2021 and Beyond (Profit Hunter)

Sep 23, 2020

Rules of the racetrack can help you bag the biggest gainers of the coming decade.

What Do the Charts Say About Buying Smallcaps Now? (Fast Profits Daily)

Sep 18, 2020

Everyone seems to be excited about buying smallcaps now...but is it the right thing to do? What do the charts tell us? Find out in this video...


Covid-19 Proof
Multibagger Stocks

Covid19 Proof Multibaggers
Get this special report, authored by Equitymaster's top analysts now!
We will never sell or rent your email id.
Please read our Terms


Oct 1, 2020 02:41 PM