Helping You Build Wealth With Honest Research
Since 1996. Read On...

The Best Asset Allocation for Your Equity Portfolio

Investment in securities market are subject to market risks. Read all the related documents carefully before investing

India's Bull Market
Has The Pause Finally Ended?

Global developments could be setting the stage for a new rally


See What's Ahead

**Important: We hate spam as much as you do. Check out our Privacy Policy and Terms Of Use.

AD

Why Paytm Plunged 40% in the First 6 Months of the Year

Jul 24, 2024

Why Paytm Share Price is RisingPaytm Logo source: https://paytm.com

Warren Buffett's US$ 300 million (m) investment in Paytm made people confident about Paytm's impending success.

Little did anyone know that Buffett's first and only investment in India would turn sour.

The struggle for Paytm, once an up-and-coming fintech startup, is far from over. Instead of bringing fortunes to its investors, the Paytm stock has turned into a nightmare.

Almost every investor who was anticipating huge gains from Paytm has incurred heavy losses from the very first day of Paytm's listing on the stock market.

The year 2024 has exacerbated the situation, with the stock plummeting over 40% in the first six months alone.

Here's what is dragging this stock down.

#1 RBI Restriction on Paytm Payments Bank

The downfall of Paytm's share started in January with the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) on 31 January 2024 imposing major business restrictions on Paytm Payments Bank.

These restrictions include a ban on accepting fresh deposits and making credit transactions.

So effective 29 February 2024, Paytm Payments Bank will not be allowed to accept fresh deposits, undertake credit transactions, or top-ups in any customer accounts. This also includes prepaid instruments, wallets, FASTags, and NCMC cards, among others.

Note that RBI's action comes after the bank came under non-compliance and supervisory concerns.

In March 2022, the central bank had barred Paytm Payments Bank from onboarding new customers.

Following the latest restrictions, top brokerage houses have voiced serious concerns and suggest that this will significantly impact operations.

Just to put things into context, RBI had put a ban on HDFC Bank too some two years ago and it took over 15 months for the central bank to lift the ban.

So imagine how long it will take here. The RBI has conducted a comprehensive IT audit and continued to identify non-compliance against Paytm Payments Bank.

#2 FII Selling

With this problem coming to the fore, March 2024 saw the problem further exacerbated by foreign institutional investors (FIIs) reducing their stakes in the company.

In the March 2024 quarter, FIIs decreased their holdings to 60.4%, down 3.3% from the previous quarter's 63.7%.

Continuing this selling spree, FIIs further reduced their holdings to 58.3%, down an additional 2%.

This dragged the stock lower.

#3 Senior Level Resignation

In April 2024, Paytm faced a new set of challenges with several high-level exits. Surinder Chawla, the managing director (MD) and chief executive officer (CEO) of Paytm Payments Bank, stepped down that month.

Additionally, Sumit Mathur, the company's chief marketing officer, left after a year-long tenure to join Glanbia Performance Nutrition.

The situation worsened in May 2024 with the resignation of Bhavesh Gupta, president and chief operating officer (COO). Gupta's departure marked the third senior resignation in recent months.

His resignation came just as the company was preparing to announce its annual and fourth-quarter results, with Gupta citing personal reasons. This spate of high-level departures raised concerns that more exits might follow.

In addition, Varun Sridhar, the chief executive of Paytm Money, also stepped down to take on the role of CEO at Paytm Services, a subsidiary responsible for distributing mutual funds and other wealth management products.

These successive resignations have further pressured the company's stock, contributing to its downward trend.

#4 Weak Q1 Results

Lastly, for the June 2024 quarter, Paytm reported a 36% year-on-year decline in revenue, dropping to Rs 15 billion (bn) from Rs 23.4 bn in the same period a year earlier.

Of the Rs 15 bn in revenue, the payments business contributed Rs 9 bn, financial services accounted for Rs 2.8 bn, and the remaining revenue came from marketing services.

Earnings Before Interest, Tax, Depreciation, and Amortisation (EBITDA) for the June quarter, before accounting for Employee Stock Ownership Plans (ESOPs), showed a loss of Rs 5.4 bn.

Additionally, Paytm's net loss widened significantly, increasing two and a half times to Rs 8.4 bn from Rs 3.6 bn a year ago.

This increase in losses is attributed to the ongoing impact of the Reserve Bank of India's (RBI) curbs, which have shut down the payments bank business.

#5 Related Party Dealings Warning

Coming to July 2024, Paytm's parent company, One 97 Communications, recently received an administrative warning letter from the market regulator, SEBI.

The regulator stated that certain transactions in FY22 between Paytm and the now-defunct Paytm Payments Bank were conducted without approval from the company's audit committee or its shareholders.

In response to the administrative warning, Paytm asserted that it has consistently adhered to all listing regulations and will address the market regulator's concerns with a detailed response.

The administrative warning, detailed in a letter dated 15 July 2024, and uploaded by One 97 Communications to the exchanges on Monday, focuses on related party transactions valued at Rs 3.2 bn and Rs 360 m, respectively.

These transactions, conducted during FY22, did not receive the requisite approval from either the audit committee or the shareholders, according to the market regulator.

The company claimed it had provided a cumulative numerical value of the transactions with Paytm Payments Bank for reference by the shareholders. It argued that transactions between subsidiaries of One 97 Communications and Paytm Payments Bank did not qualify as related party transactions during FY22.

However, the board and audit committee considered transactions between One 97 Communications and/or its subsidiaries with Paytm Payments Bank as material-related party transactions and passed resolutions to keep such transactions within specified limits.

The market regulator pointed out discrepancies between the company's assertions of compliance and the transactions categorised as material-related party transactions by the board and audit committee.

These violations have been viewed very seriously. The market regulator instructed Paytm to present the letter to its board for corrective actions and to provide a report on the measures taken within 10 days thereafter.

Following this update, the company's stock has been on a downward trend.

What Next?

Following setbacks from the shutdown of its payments banking unit earlier this year, Paytm is optimistic about improvements in key operating metrics, including gross merchandise value and the addition of merchant devices.

In response to mounting losses, the company has implemented a cost-saving strategy aimed at reducing employee expenses by Rs 4-5 bn annually. Employee costs are expected to decrease from July to September.

Looking ahead to FY25, Paytm aims to achieve at least one profitable quarter. The company plans to enhance its financial services by cross-selling products such as lending, insurance, and wealth management through an expanded distribution model and deeper partnerships with lenders and insurers.

In the lending sector, Paytm will focus on a distribution-only model for personal and merchant loans, avoiding collection responsibilities. They also plan to pilot secured lending products, including micro loan against property (LAP) loans.

Additionally, Paytm intends to streamline operations by reducing non-core assets and businesses, thereby improving profitability and focus.

How Shares of Paytm have Performed Recently

Over five days, Paytm shares are down by 2%, while it is down 30 % in 2024 so far.

Over the past year, the stock has declined 44%.

The company touched its 52-week high of Rs 998.3 on 20 October 2023 and its 52-week low of Rs 310 on 9 May 2024.

Paytm Share Price Performance in 2024

About Paytm

Paytm is India's leading financial services company that offers payments and financial solutions to consumers.

It's an Indian-based mobile internet company and a subsidiary of One97 Communications Limited.

For more details about the company, you can have a look at Paytm's factsheet and quarterly result.

You can also compare Paytm with its peers.

Paytm vs Policy Bazaar

Paytm vs Zomato

Paytm vs Nykaa

To know what's moving the Indian stock markets today, check out the most recent share market updates here.

--- Advertisement ---
Investment in securities market are subject to market risks. Read all the related documents carefully before investing

Which businesses are most likely to emerge stronger over the next 3 to 5 years?

After screening thousands of listed companies, comparing industries, and examining balance sheets...

Our research team discovered some of the strongest opportunities in what we call... Essential Stocks.

Opportunities like this do not remain hidden forever.

Disclaimer: This article is for information purposes only. It is not a stock recommendation and should not be treated as such. Learn more about our recommendation services here...

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Why Paytm Plunged 40% in the First 6 Months of the Year". Click here!