**Important: We hate spam as much as you do. Check out our Privacy Policy and Terms Of Use.
Companies involved in the stock exchange business primarily earn their revenue from transaction charges on market trades, (be it equities, bonds, currency derivatives, futures) treasury income (on margin deposited by members), listing fees (annuity kind), income from investments and deposits, and other income (from data dissemination, rent and training institute).
So when the Indian market regulator SEBI started playing tough cop to de-addict retail traders, it was clear that stock broking companies and other related firms would be impacted.
One of the proposals that regulator suggested was to limit the weekly options contract to only one benchmark index of the exchange.
At present, there are two exchanges in India - BSE and NSE - which cater to the equities and remaining segments.
While BSE has 2 option contracts, NSE has 4 weekly expiries.
For BSE contracts, right now there's decent volume for the Sensex expiry but the Bankex one is very illiquid.
And NSE has a lot of volume...
If and when the new rules come into force, there will be only 2 weekly contracts - one each from BSE and NSE.
According to industry experts, the smaller player here (BSE) may benefit as trading activities may spillover to BSE products from discontinued products of NSE.
But that's just one part of the story... both BSE and NSE continue to have high growth prospects. With the financialisation of the economy, potential rise in share of equities as a percentage of household savings, and a significant share of working population, exchange businesses have strong tailwinds in their favour.
Not to mention the current bullish market sentiment... when market sentiment is weak, the stock exchanges underperform as a good part of their earnings comes from the market sentiment. Whenever there's recovery in market sentiments, it boosts profit of exchanges due to high operating leverage (most of the costs are fixed).
With BSE already transitioning into a fintech giant and NSE getting ready with its upcoming IPO, the stage is set for both the companies.
Let's look at each of them in detail and what the future holds for them...
BSE is the world's oldest exchange and a perfect example of how a company made the pivot and transformed its business to stay relevant.
What is now a fintech company used to at one point be a gathering of stockbrokers under a banyan tree. This later evolved to an office in a building in Mumbai in 1928.
For decades, stockbrokers would buy and sell physical shares in an open outcry trading floor.
Then in 1995, the Bombay Stock Exchange switched to an electronic trading system as digitisation took the world by storm.
The company made this transition in only 50 days.
Today, BSE is the fastest stock exchange in world.
The company uses a technology platform called Bolt Plus, which is based on the business architecture of global giant Deutsche Borse.
It has over 4,500 securities listed on its platform and has commodity derivatives contracts in gold and silver. It also has a platform for trading in equities of small-and-medium enterprises and runs India INX, the first international exchange of India.
Coming to its financials, the company's earnings grew by 6% CAGR (FY19-FY23) as a result of valuation expansion. Back in 2019, it was trading at a PE of 15x and currently, the PE has expanded to 76x.
The latest year FY24 turned out to be strong.
The company posted record revenue of Rs 16.2 bn which resulted in its net profit shooting up by 86% to Rs 4.1 bn YoY.
BSE plans to introduce single stock derivatives space and it also plans to launch new products and services to strengthen offerings.
That apart, BSE currently holds 15% stake in CDSL. The company's investment value in CDSL is up over 5-6 times already.
The stock of BSE is currently available at a dividend yield of 0.6%. It also comes with negative working capital cycle, zero debt, and non-restricted cash, which provides margin of safety.
All being said, a substantial portion of BSE's revenues is vulnerable to macro factors such as market trading activity, investment yields, etc., which are beyond BSE's control. As such, the business is cyclical in nature. Also, since most of the costs for BSE Ltd are fixed in nature, margins in the business remain volatile.
NSE offers a vast array of products and services, from equities and derivatives to debt instruments and currency trading.
It maintains a leadership position, standing tall as the world's largest derivatives exchange by trading volume and the third-largest in cash equities by the number of trades.
In the domestic markets, NSE enjoys a monopoly in the capital market and equity derivative segments, with a market share of 93% and near 100%, respectively.
NSE's market share in the currency options segment stood at 97%, while in the currency futures segment accounted for 68% in the financial year 2023.
NSE caters to the needs of high-volume and high-frequency traders by providing co-location facilities for seamless algorithmic trading.
The platform's wide range, combined with its dominant position in several asset classes, allows it to be incredibly responsive to market demands.
High trading volumes create a virtuous cycle for everyone involved. More participants are attracted to the exchange, leading to efficient price discovery.
This active trading environment makes NSE a listing powerhouse, attracting companies and offering investors a wider choice of stocks.
This robust ecosystem explains the healthy revenue growth, 80% of which comes from transaction charges followed by a mix of co-location charges (4.8%) and the balance 15% from multiple fee sources such as listing, book-building and processing.
NSE's growth trajectory is nothing short of phenomenal. Between 2019 and 2023, the sales have tripled while the net profits have quadrupled.
The business has not only multiplied swiftly, but it has also maintained its supernormal profit margins, thanks to its dominant position.
Over the last five years, the company's operating margins have been above 80% and net profit margins have been around 60%.
Furthermore, being an asset-light company, NSE has fuelled its growth without relying on debt.
The company doesn't spend a lot on capital expenditure. Capex, if any, usually goes towards technological advancements, a strategic investment that positions it for long-term success.
NSE is a formidable competitor to BSE in the equity segment (main contributing asset class to income from transaction charges).
BSE has been losing market share in this segment. In other segments such as currency derivatives, NSE has been able to wrestle market share back from BSE.
The Indian economy is one of the fastest-growing major economies in the world, driven by a healthy banking system and a government pushing hard on infrastructure spending.
The private investment cycle has been doing well, led by increased capacity utilisation and healthier corporate balance sheets.
India's digital revolution is in full swing. The renewed focus on digitisation, formalising the economy, and making financial services accessible to everyone is projected to be a major growth driver for years to come.
This economic boom spells good news for NSE as well as BSE. While existing investment products like stocks and derivatives will remain popular, it's just the tip of the iceberg.
The recent surge in retail investor participation shows a clear hunger for new offerings.
Both companies are perfectly positioned to cater to this growing demand with their innovative products and services.
Happy Investing!
--- Advertisement ---
Investment in securities market are subject to market risks. Read all the related documents carefully before investing
Which businesses are most likely to emerge stronger over the next 3 to 5 years?
After screening thousands of listed companies, comparing industries, and examining balance sheets...
Our research team discovered some of the strongest opportunities in what we call... Essential Stocks.
Opportunities like this do not remain hidden forever.
Disclaimer: This article is for information purposes only. It is not a stock recommendation and should not be treated as such. Learn more about our recommendation services here...
Yash Vora is a financial writer with the Microcap Millionaires team at Equitymaster. He has followed the stock markets right from his early college days. So, Yash has a keen eye for the big market movers. His clear and crisp writeups offer sharp insights on market moving stocks, fund flows, economic data and IPOs. When not looking at stocks, Yash loves a game of table tennis or chess.
Image source: same design/www.istockphoto.com
Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "BSE vs NSE: Who Will Have the Last Laugh?". Click here!
Comments are moderated by Equitymaster, in accordance with the Terms of Use, and may not appear
on this article until they have been reviewed and deemed appropriate for posting.
In the meantime, you may want to share this article with your friends!