The story of Tata Steel & the credit crisis - Views on News from Equitymaster

Helping You Build Wealth With Honest Research
Since 1996. Try Now

  • MyStocks


Login Failure
(Please do not use this option on a public machine)
  Sign Up | Forgot Password?  

The story of Tata Steel & the credit crisis

Sep 17, 2009

A while back we wrote an article discussing the different factors that influence the price of a stock. We began by saying "The prices of stocks constantly fluctuate as buyers and sellers haggle towards a mutually agreeable price to buy or sell at any point of time. But can it be that the fundamental worth of each of those companies is actually changing every minute? And is that fundamental worth the only thing that determines the changes in the prices of stocks?" What better case study than India's premier steel company Tata Steel to answer those question. Its price over the last one year or so has been nothing short of a rollercoaster ride, with some very extreme fluctuations in either directions. It touched just about Rs 1,000 in October 2007. Astonishingly, within a span of just one year, by December 2008 it had fallen to a low of Rs 149. A company that was being valued at Rs 603 bn in the market was suddenly being valued at only Rs 108 bn within the matter of a year, a fall of over 80%. At that price, Tata Steel was trading at a P/B of merely 0.4 times!

So, Corus was performing badly and was said to continue to do so for some time. The economic outlook was uncertain and most major economies were forecasted to perform badly for the next year or so. That's it, nothing else had changed. It was the same company, with the same management, and the same business, but was now being valued at dramatically low levels. Could there be any justification for that? The adjoining chart may offer some clues.

Note: The price of Tata Steel has been divided by 30
for the sake of appropriate graphical presentation with the theme of the article.
Data Source: CMIE Prowess

The fall in price that ostensibly seemed due to a grim outlook, actually had many more layers to it. One of them was most definitely the heavy selling activity from FIIs (foreign institutional investors) in a very short period of time. These institutions presumably had to meet many commitments back home. Redemption pressure from their own investors and an extreme liquidity crunch in their home countries could be two such reasons why they had no option but to sell, even if that meant receiving very bad valuations for their stock. And so began the distressed selling where FIIs reduced their shareholding in the company from 20.55% at the end December 2007 to a low of 12.98% at December end 2008, causing company's share price to get beaten down to some very irrationally low levels. So there's the culprit!

What is also interesting to note is how the momentum of buying and selling by FIIs caused a momentum in the share price that lasted much after the buying and selling by these entities stopped. For example, when FIIs were aggressively buying between March 2007 and June 2007, the rise in the share's price lasted much after the buying stopped.

The story is somewhat similar on the downside. An explanation for that could be that when the price of a stock is seen rising or falling in a big way for an extended period of time, speculation becomes rife in the stock, with speculators trying to cash in on the momentum. However, after a certain point, the speculator's themselves start affecting the stock's price in what can be called a self-fulfilling prophecy, until the time that such a price (either too high or too low compared to fundamentals) is no longer sustainable.

Did all this have anything to do with Tata Steel's business or its standing as a company? No. Did that stop it from affecting its share price? No!

And so, the moral of the story is that the price quote of a stock you see everyday does not always reflect the fundamental worth of the company. A intelligent investor will always do well to take advantage of these differences from fundamentals by either buying or selling the stock when the price gets way out of sync with its fundamentals.

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "The story of Tata Steel & the credit crisis". Click here!

2 Responses to "The story of Tata Steel & the credit crisis"

mohit suri

Sep 21, 2009

perfect reasoning company is strong and results of corus will show from 2012 onwards



Sep 20, 2009

very good and exact reasoning of movement if tata steel price

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "The story of Tata Steel & the credit crisis". Click here!

More Views on News

Top 5 Recent IPO Developments You Should Know (Views On News)

May 12, 2021

So far in 2021, IPOs in India have raised nearly US$ 3 bn, the best start to the year since 2018.

How Did Mindtree Perform in Q4FY21? (Company Info)

Apr 20, 2021

Here's the rundown on the company's latest quarterly results.

5 Big IPOs to Look Forward to in 2021 (Views On News)

Jun 19, 2021

A peak into the hype around the IPOs of internet companies like Zomato and Paytm

HDFC Banking and Financial Services Fund: Emphasizes on the Growing Sector (Outside View)

Jun 18, 2021

PersonalFN analyses the features of HDFC Banking and Financial Services Fund and explains the potential this fund has to offer to its investors.

Can You Make More than 100 Times Your Investment? (Profit Hunter)

Jun 18, 2021

The open secret to multiplying your money in forever stocks.

More Views on News

Most Popular

Differences Between Trading and Investing

A simple to guide to understand the difference between investing and trading

Hotel Stocks Will Reward Investors (Fast Profits Daily)

Jun 8, 2021

This is why I'm bullish on the hotel and hospitality sector.

My 'Unlock' Investments (Fast Profits Daily)

Jun 11, 2021

The best unlock investments you can make in the market.

The Most Visible Sign of India's Revival is on Two Wheels (Profit Hunter)

Jun 9, 2021

Investing in the best stocks could result in wealth compounding on a massive scale.

How I Discovered a 400-Year-Old Open Secret to Extreme Wealth (Profit Hunter)

Jun 11, 2021

Charlie Munger's open secret about investing success.


India's #1 Trader
Reveals His Secrets

Secret To Increasing Your Trading Profits Today
Get this Special Report,
The Secret to Increasing Your Trading Profits Today, Now!
We will never sell or rent your email id.
Please read our Terms


Jun 18, 2021 (Close)