Imagine a company that keeps cutting prices, offers free shipping, spends heavily on technology and infrastructure, and reports very little profit despite growing rapidly.
Most investors would have questions.
Why isn't the company making more money? When will all this spending translate into profits? And what happens if competitors start offering lower prices?
Nick Sleep, a relatively unknown British investor, looked at Amazon and saw something very different.
He believed that Amazon's low profits were not necessarily a weakness. They could be the foundation of an extraordinary business.
That insight helped Sleep and his investment partner, Qais Zakaria, turn Nomad Investment Partnership into one of the remarkable investment success stories of its time.
Between September 2001 and December 2013, Nomad delivered a cumulative return of 921.1% before performance fees, compared with 116.9% for the MSCI World Index. Amazon was one of its defining investments.
To understand Sleep's insight, we need to go back to the early days of Amazon.
Jeff Bezos founded Amazon in 1994 as an online bookstore. It went public in 1997.
At the time, the internet was still a relatively new commercial frontier. Investors were excited about its potential, but the dot-com bubble eventually burst, wiping out enormous amounts of market value.
Amazon survived, but it was not an obvious investment for someone looking for a comfortable, profitable business.
It was expanding into new product categories, building warehouses, improving its technology and trying to make online shopping more convenient.
All this required money.
And rather than simply charging customers more to improve its profit margins, Amazon kept investing in ways to make shopping cheaper and easier.
Many investors viewed this as a problem. They wanted to know when Amazon would start maximising its profits.
Sleep asked a different question.
What if Amazon was deliberately sacrificing today's profits to build a business that could become much more powerful tomorrow?
That was the beginning of a very different investment thesis.
The insight: Scale economies shared
Sleep gave this business model a name: scale economies shared.
The idea sounds simple, but its implications are profound.
Most businesses try to keep the benefits of growth for themselves.
Suppose a retailer sells a product for Rs 100 and buys it for Rs 80. Its gross profit is Rs 20.
As the retailer grows, it may negotiate better prices from suppliers. Its purchase cost might fall from Rs 80 to Rs 70.
The retailer now has a choice.
It can continue selling at Rs 100 and keep the additional Rs 10 as profit.
Or it can reduce the selling price to Rs 90 and pass the entire saving to customers.
Sleep recognised the power of the second approach.
Lower prices attract more customers. More customers generate greater sales volumes. Greater volumes improve the company's bargaining power and spread fixed costs across more transactions.
Those savings can then be passed on through even lower prices.
And the cycle starts again.
Lower prices lead to more customers. More customers lead to greater scale. Greater scale makes lower prices possible.
This creates a powerful feedback loop.
A company may sacrifice profits in the short term, but the resulting customer loyalty and cost advantage can make it increasingly difficult for competitors to catch up.
Amazon was building precisely this kind of advantage.
Why this could make Amazon extraordinarily valuable
Consider the difference between two retailers.
Retailer A wants to maximise its profit margin on every transaction.
Retailer B wants to become the place where customers can consistently find the products they want at attractive prices, with convenient delivery.
Retailer A may look more profitable today.
Retailer B may be building a much larger customer base.
As the second retailer grows, it can negotiate better terms with suppliers, invest in distribution infrastructure and improve its technology. Those improvements can make its service more attractive and lower its costs.
Customers return because they know they can find good prices and convenience in one place.
Over time, the retailer becomes more difficult to compete with.
This was the opportunity Sleep recognised in Amazon.
He was not merely betting that more people would shop online. He was betting that Amazon's business model could reinforce itself as the company grew.
The distinction matters. An ordinary growth company becomes bigger by selling more.
A powerful scale-economies-shared business can become bigger while simultaneously improving the advantages that protect it from competition.
The difficult part was having patience
Understanding the business model was only half the battle.
Sleep also needed the temperament to hold the investment while the market questioned it.
Amazon's share price suffered badly during the 2008 financial crisis. Nomad's own portfolio fell 45.3% that year.
Imagine watching a major investment lose a substantial part of its market value while commentators question whether the business can justify its valuation.
It would be tempting to sell and wait for the uncertainty to pass.
Sleep instead focused on whether Amazon's competitive position was deteriorating.
In his 2008 letter to investors, he argued that Amazon's business was progressing despite the collapse in its share price. He saw an opportunity in the disconnect between the company's long-term prospects and the market's pessimism.
This is an important distinction.
Sleep was not ignoring risk. He was asking whether the falling share price reflected a deterioration in the business or simply a change in market sentiment.
If the underlying business continued to strengthen, a lower share price could create an opportunity rather than a reason to panic.
The results speak for themselves
By December 2013, Nomad had generated a cumulative return of 921.1% before performance fees since its inception in September 2001.
In other words, US$ 1 invested at inception would have grown to approximately US$ 10.21 before performance fees.
The MSCI World Index had turned the same US$ 1 into approximately US$ 2.17.
These were partnership-level returns, not returns attributable exclusively to Amazon. Nomad held other successful investments, including Costco, which shared important features of the same business philosophy.
Nevertheless, Amazon became one of Sleep's most important investments because it illustrated the extraordinary potential of the model.
Sleep and Zakaria eventually closed Nomad in 2014, returning capital to their investors. Sleep's final recommendations included continuing to hold Amazon, Costco and Berkshire Hathaway.
His conviction was remarkable: he believed that allowing exceptional businesses to compound over long periods could be more rewarding than repeatedly selling and searching for the next opportunity.
Can we use this insight to find our own multibaggers?
The lesson is not that every company cutting prices will become an Amazon.
Low prices can destroy a business if the company lacks cost advantages, financial resources or customer loyalty. Growth can also consume capital without generating attractive returns.
The important question is whether lower prices and reinvestment are creating a stronger business.
When analysing a company, ask three questions:
1. Does growth improve its competitive position?
Does the company gain purchasing power, spread fixed costs or improve its distribution network as sales increase?
2. Are customers benefiting from the company's growth?
Are prices becoming more attractive, service improving or products becoming more convenient? Do these benefits encourage customers to return?
3. Can the company sustain this cycle for many years?
Does it have the financial strength, management discipline and business model required to keep reinvesting without destroying shareholder value?
If the answers are encouraging, low profit margins today may not tell the whole story.
Sometimes they are evidence of a company investing in its future.
That is the insight Nick Sleep found in Amazon. He looked beyond the profits Amazon was reporting and focused on the economic machine it was building.
The biggest opportunity was not simply that Amazon could sell more. It was that every additional sale could help make Amazon a stronger competitor.
And that is a lesson worth remembering when searching for the next multibagger.
--- Advertisement ---
Investment in securities market are subject to market risks. Read all the related documents carefully before investing
Which businesses are most likely to emerge stronger over the next 3 to 5 years?
After screening thousands of listed companies, comparing industries, and examining balance sheets...
Our research team discovered some of the strongest opportunities in what we call... Essential Stocks.
Opportunities like this do not remain hidden forever.
Disclaimer: This article is for information purposes only. It is not a stock recommendation and should not be treated as such. Learn more about our recommendation services here...
Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "3 Ways to Beat the Market: What if Low Profits Are Hiding a 10-Bagger?". Click here!
Comments are moderated by Equitymaster, in accordance with the Terms of Use, and may not appear
on this article until they have been reviewed and deemed appropriate for posting.
In the meantime, you may want to share this article with your friends!