Shakespeare once said, "A rose by any other name would smell as sweet". But, in the case of the Indian microfinance industry, this phrase did not work too well. If you call yourself a microfinance institution (MFI), armed with a social cause, you will get slammed if you only chase profits. Maybe, this will work in your favour for a while. But soon enough, the basic rules of economics start to kick in. More on this point later.
Andhra Pradesh (AP) alone accounts for around 30-40% of India's overall US$ 6.5 bn microfinance portfolio. It is also the birthplace of a number of big name microfinance companies including SKS Microfinance, Spandana, Share, Asmita etc. It is the proverbial cash cow of the business in the country.
Source: Financial Times website |
The entire microfinance model is based on group lending. If one borrower defaults, the others have to carry their weight. Rather than facing the shame of default, some of the women borrowers turned to suicide. When these numbers racked up, the authorities started crying foul. But, 2010 was not the first time that this happened. The first case of suicides due to aggressive operations happened in the same state of AP in 2006. A number of branches were shut for operations and the industry faced a temporary crisis.
But, the crisis did not go away. Lending rates were still prohibitive. Borrowers were overleveraged. And, post the listing of SKS Microfinance, a lot of unresolved issues came to the fore. Anyway, this time, the government finally took matters into its own hands. In October it passed an Ordinance to help regulate microfinance activity in the state. Recently in December, the government passed a Microfinance bill, with similar provisions. This bill is expected to be soon enacted into a law, but it faces strong opposition from the MFI network.
Some of the main features of the bill include a monthly instead of weekly collection period. They are also not allowed to lend to women self-help groups (SHGs) already serviced by banks. In order to prevent coercive lending practices, the MFIs are now only allowed to collect their repayments from a designated government location such as a village panchayat. Earlier, they could visit borrower's houses to recover money. There was no interest rate cap declared, however.
All these moves, since the passing of the ordinance materially impacted the operations of MFIs in AP. Collections dropped to 20% from 95% previously. SKS' shares were hammered on the exchanges. You may think that these moves would lead to the failure of the industry. But, after facing these challenges, the industry can, and will grow stronger.
Taking away the capital that helped a young woman set up a business in a village, is devastating. Once she has tasted the power of being an entrepreneur, the desire can never go away. Banks, PE, and Venture capital firms who lent money to the billion dollar industry, all cannot write off these loans as bad. They do see microfinance as a key growth driver for Indian financial sector.
The industry has to bounce back stronger than before. It will have to work around the new laws and regulations that will come up in AP and other states. The business model needs to be reworked. It needs to find that 'magic number'. The interest rate that is both reasonable and profitable. It will have to try and manage the delicate and difficult balance between social good and business profits. Having said that, the industry will take some time to become lucrative for shareholders.
Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Are MFIs a lost opportunity?". Click here!
1 Responses to "Are MFIs a lost opportunity?"
IFCI share price is trading down by 6% and its current market price is Rs 12. The BSE 500 is down by 1.3%. The top gainers in the BSE 500 Index are TV18 BROADCAST (up 6.6%) and MOTILAL OSWAL (up 6.1%). The top losers are IFCI (down 6.5%) and APOLLO HOSPITALS (down 5.3%).
For the quarter ended December 2020, HDFC has posted a net profit of Rs 29 bn (down 65.1% YoY). Sales on the other hand came in at Rs 116 bn (down 42.2% YoY). Read on for a complete analysis of HDFC's quarterly results.
For the quarter ended September 2020, BAJAJ FINSERV has posted a net profit of Rs 16 bn (down 20.0% YoY). Sales on the other hand came in at Rs 150 bn (up 5.8% YoY). Read on for a complete analysis of BAJAJ FINSERV's quarterly results.
Monopolistic railway financer with impeccable asset quality.
Does the company having 70% market share of the mutual fund registrar business have sound prospects?
More Views on NewsLast time the smallcap index crossed 19k a big correction followed. Here's what makes it different this time.
In this video, I'll show you how to get started on the path to daily trading profits.
An Indian company founded three decades ago in a garage caught my attention...
In this video, I'll show you how to allocate your capital as a day trader.
More
venkat
Dec 28, 2010Good article.I think MFI regulatori act is wrong step of AP govt, because its not usefull to either poor peole or MFIcompanies.At last poor people suffer.now they nessasary any capital for small bussiness,itis long process to issue the loan for MFIs.these peole go to localmoney lenders,with high intrest and corceive recovery,this type culture may leads to onother sucides,
my suggestion that AP govt think on MFI regulatory act.It is hurry-burry step to control to MFIs.