Why Income Tax Will Stay - Vivek Kaul's Diary
Free Reports

Why Income Tax Will Stay

Jan 16, 2018


Every year, before the annual budget is presented, suggestions are made to scrap the income tax paid by individuals. The economist/politician Subramanian Swamy has also said so in the past. The logic typically offered is that the individual income tax forms a very small part of the total taxes collected by the government, and hence, it should be scrapped.

Let's look at Table 1, which

Table 1:
Assessment year Individual income tax as a proportion of total taxes collected by the government Individual income tax as a proportion of GDP
2012-2013 12.67% 1.24%
2013-2014 13.52% 1.38%
2014-2015 16.86% 1.68%
2015-2016 15.18% 1.50%
Source: Author calculations on data from Incometaxindia.gov.in.

Table 1 has data up to assessment year 2015-2016. Income tax for the money earned in the financial year 2014-2015, would have been paid in the assessment year 2015-2016. The budget documents of the government of India do not list out the total income tax paid by individuals, separately. Hence, the latest numbers for the total income tax paid by individuals, isn't available in the public domain.

These numbers are separately declared by the income tax department, on a non-regular basis.

What does Table 1 tell us? It tells us that the income tax paid by individuals, forms a small portion of the total tax collected by the government, during any given year. This is the logic offered by those who say that individual income tax needs to be scrapped. More than this, once the taxes are scrapped, people are likely to spend the money not paid in the form of income tax, in various ways. They might decide to go on a holiday or redo the house or go out and eat more often.

Hence, when this extra spending happens, the incomes of many other people will go up and they are also likely to spend more as well. Thus, the multiplier effect will work. This will ultimately benefit businesses, which will make higher profits, and hence, pay more income tax on their profits. Further, the government is also likely to collect more indirect tax. And net net, scrapping income tax for individuals won't make much of a difference, for the government.

Also, this is likely to force the government to cut down on frivolous expenditure. It is also likely to force the government to get rid of many loss-incurring public-sector enterprises, which continue to bleed. Basically, it will force the government to cut down on what I have been calling Big Government in many of my previous pieces.

All this makes perfect sense, but in theory. Now let's take a look at Table 2, which basically lists out individual income tax in rupee terms.

Table 2:
Assessment year Total individual income tax (in Rs crore)
2012-2013 1,12,112
2013-2014 1,39,500
2014-2015 1,91,208
2015-2016 1,88,031
Source: Incometaxindia.gov.in.

While, income tax from individuals, might look very small as a proportion of total taxes collected by the government, but the absolute amounts on their own are not small at all. In fact, let's take a look at the assessment year 2015-2016. The total income tax from individuals during this year stands at Rs 1,88,031 crore. This money is enough to finance the budget of many departments of the government of India. And this is money that the government is collecting for sure.

If the government scraps this, where will it get this money from? By now, the income tax paid by individuals must have easily touched Rs 2,50,000 crore. As supporters for scrapping individual income tax point out, the government is likely to earn more money from corporations paying higher income tax on their higher profits. Also, it is likely to collect more indirect tax as people end up spending more money.

The word to mark here is likely. No government is going to want to take such a big risk. Every government likes some amount of certainty when it comes to the taxes that it collects. Also, it has been suggested that if scrapping income tax for individuals is not possible, income tax can be done away at the lower levels of income.

This is where things get even more interesting. Take a look at Table 3. Table 3 basically plots the total taxes paid by individuals paying an income tax of greater than zero but lower than and equal to Rs 1,50,000. This is the lowest bracket for which the income tax department provides data.

Table 3:
Assessment year Total income tax paid by individuals paying an income tax of > 0 and <=1,50,000 (in Rs crore) Total individual income tax (in Rs crore) Proportion of total income tax
2012-2013 23,551 1,12,112 21.01%
2013-2014 37,107 1,39,500 26.60%
2014-2015 43,964 1,91,208 22.99%
2015-2016 44,615 1,88,031 23.73%
Source: Author calculations on data from Incometaxindia.gov.in.

While, the individuals paying an income tax of less than or equal to Rs 1,50,000, pay a very low average income tax every year (around Rs 25,000 in assessment year 2015-2016), on the whole it adds up to a substantial amount. This is what Professor CK Prahalad called the fortune at the bottom of the pyramid. For assessment year 2015-2016, it amounted to a total of Rs 44,615 crore, which would have again enough to finance the budgets of several government departments.

Also, at lower levels, the idea is to get people to start paying income tax. Once they start doing that, they are more likely to continue doing it, in the years to come. Further, given that a major portion of these taxes are directly cut from salaries by companies and handed over to the government, the government has to do very little in order to collect this money. Hence, there is no reason for the government to scrap individual income tax, though theoretically it might make immense sense.

Also, the things that the government will have to do if it scraps individual income tax would require much more work than it is currently used to. And we all like to take the easy way out.

Vivek Kaul is the Editor of the Diary. He is the author of the Easy Money trilogy. The books were bestsellers on Amazon. His latest book is India's Big Government - The Intrusive State and How It is Hurting Us.

Disclaimer: The views mentioned above are of the author only. Data and charts, if used, in the article have been sourced from available information and have not been authenticated by any statutory authority. The author and Equitymaster do not claim it to be accurate nor accept any responsibility for the same. The views constitute only the opinions and do not constitute any guidelines or recommendation on any course of action to be followed by the reader. Please read the detailed Terms of Use of the web site.

Recent Articles

Of Social Media, Economics and Narendra Modi January 21, 2019
The opposition seem to be catching up to social media of the BJP.
After 2018's Falls, There Are Some Cheap Stock Markets January 18, 2019
Rob Marstrand takes a look at a few country stock markets that look pretty cheap these days. Which are these countries? Read on to find out.
The Great Leader Has Won the Cow-Teller Award and Now Wants a Case Study January 17, 2019
This is a spoof.
A Few Memories from My School Reunion in Ranchi January 16, 2019
Vivek talks about meeting his Xavier's schoolmates after 25 years.

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Why Income Tax Will Stay". Click here!

2 Responses to "Why Income Tax Will Stay"

N J Raj

Jan 18, 2018

I fully agree with Mr. G.S. Rao. to ensure full fledged growth and 'unbiased' development quickly need to abolish Income Tax in India. But sadly Congress or BJP and all other parties have similar policy interested in tax extortion. Our problem is Left centric govt. whichever party come to power which is a faulty and not survive in the long run. The Income tax and over taxing other like GST and other taxes leading to rise of parallel economy, criminalisation, injustice and many other problem, rising product and service cost, growth, unemployment and all kind of problem. When India don't have Income tax during king's rule, and there is less tax and only few paid, there was not much poor and beggar in India and the wealth was staying within India. If we want better governance and equitable development, we need to abolish income tax entirely. At present, higher taxes ensure maximum government, multiplication and duplication of many govt. dept. more surveillance on people and many other problem like rising litigation between govt. and people. All the problem can be resolved with a single decision abolish income tax and apply GST only 5%, then sale of spectrum and other things govt. will get hefty amount. Afterall govt. main slogan "Minimum Govt. ensure Maximum Governance" in any country. We don't need any invitation for corporate to come and invest in India. They themselves come and spend in India. No more peeping tomb from govt. Either BJP, Congress or the present leadership under Narendra Modi capable and sincere and courage to take decision to abolish income and bring down GST to 5%. If it is implemented, then India will be number 1 economy and more interesting things happen around the world. Collapse of tax heaven, the so called World Bank, IMF, ADB and other crony institutions. For the welfare of 1 to 2% of people, why should 98% people suffer.


G S Rao

Jan 17, 2018

Finally All taxes are passed through the products and services. Return on Investment for corporations or any economic entity is calculated after all taxes. For example, if you are earning Rs.100 today and Govt says from tomorrow you need to pay 90% income tax then you will ask your employer Rs.1000. Corporations price their products after taking into account all taxes. All taxes are passed finally to goods and services. The efficient form of taxation is indirect taxation. You need less Govt. and society at large to spend little time computing and paying taxes. You need not to waste huge human productivity in calculating and paying taxes. Collecting Rs 20 lakh crores per year of taxes through GST, Oil, Electricity, Spectrum, Resources etc. is far more is easy and productive than collecting money through lakhs of employees in Govt, all corporations and individuals spending huge amount of people and time on this avoidable activity. The only argument against this is that then the poor and rich will pay same amount of their share. If you want to benefit poor, better you give direct monthly credit to their bank account(Universal Basic Income). Don't try to potray that you are taxing rich higher. It can never happen as you are taxing only income and not wealth. As I said, Income prices in such a way that all taxes are passed through. If you want remove black money and corruption the best way is to simplify taxation and give direct money transfers to people of poverty.

Like (1)
Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Why Income Tax Will Stay". Click here!