Free Reports

What Vehicle Sales Tell Us About Notebandi

Feb 20, 2017

28

A few days back I got an email from a reader. This email essentially said that the world had moved on from demonetisation/notebandi and it was time that I did as well.

Well, people do get bored. So, does the media.

And in the process, they stop following issues that they did once. As fatigue sets in, this essentially leads to a situation that issues do not get followed to their logical conclusion.

It's like a daily soap opera which keeps undergoing multiple changes in plots, depending on what the viewers want. Or rather depending on what the managers running the show think the viewers want.

The trouble is that my writing is not like that. Also, now we have some data points to properly analyse notebandi and its impact on the Indian economy.

And it would be rather stupid of me to stop writing on the issue right now. Hence, my writing on notebandi is likely to continue in the months to come and who knows, possibly even years.

So, dear reader, that was that. Let's now cut to today's edition of the Diary.

Take a look at Figure 1. It shows the two-wheeler sales over the last five months.

Figure 1:

Figure 1 clearly shows that there has been a downward trend in two-wheeler sales since September 2016. Notebandi only accentuated this trend. Having said that there has been some recovery in sales in January 2017.

Two-wheeler sales are a very important data point. They show the spending potential of many Indians. They also have a very high correlation with India's informal economy, which doesn't get captured very well in the gross domestic product(GDP) numbers.

As Ritika Mankar Mukherjee and Sumit Shekhar of Ambit Capital write in a recent research note: "History suggests that there exists a strong correlation between the nominal GDP generated by the informal sector and... two-wheeler sales data." And given that two-wheeler sales have shown a largely downward trend lately, what can be said? As Mukherjee and Shekhar point out: "The latest data... shows a marked deterioration underway in the informal sector of the economy."

Advertisement
  Multibagger Stocks Guide
(2017 Edition)
 
   
  In this report, we reveal four proven strategies to picking multibagger stocks.0

Well over a million copies of this report have already been claimed over the years.

Don't miss it for anything.
Go ahead, grab your copy today. It's Free.
As soon as you sign up, You will start receiving The 5 Minute WrapUp,
a Free-for-life newsletter from Equitymaster

NO-SPAM PLEDGE - We will NEVER rent, sell, or give away your e-mail address to anyone for any reason. You can unsubscribe from The 5 Minute WrapUp with a few clicks. Please read our Privacy Policy & Terms Of Use.
 

As mentioned earlier, the informal sector is not captured well enough in the GDP numbers. As the Economic Survey of 2016-2017 points out: "It is clear that recorded GDP growth in the second half of FY2017 [October 2016 to March 2017] will understate the overall impact because the most affected parts of the economy-informal and cash based-are either not captured in the national income accounts or to the extent they are, their measurement is based on formal sector indicators. For example, informal manufacturing is proxied by the Index of Industrial Production, which includes mostly large establishments. So, on the production or supply side, the effect on economic activity will be underestimated."

Given this, data points like two-wheeler sales become very important in gauging the real impact of notebandi on the Indian economy. Let's see how the data for the remaining two months (February and March 2017) comes out. But from four months of data that is available for the second half of this financial year, it can safely be said that things aren't looking good on this front. And this should be a huge reason to worry. As per Mukherjee and Shekhar, "The informal sector accounts for ~40% of India's GDP and employs close to ~75% of the Indian labour force."

Now let's look at domestic passenger car sales between September 2016 and January 2017. Take a look at Figure 2.

Figure 2:

As Figure 2 shows, the domestic passenger car sales have recovered much more quickly than two-wheeler sales, in the aftermath of demonetisation. The January sales were only 4.5 per cent lower than the September sales. In case of two-wheelers, the January sales were still 30.6 per cent lower than the September sales.

What does this tell us? It tells us very clearly that rural India was impacted much more by demonetisation. It tells us that the not so well off have been more impacted much more by demonetisation than the well off. As writer Amit Varma put it in a recent speech: "In all this, the rich got away... You see a reflection of this in automobile sales. They have plummeted for two-wheelers and three-wheelers, but SUV sales are steady. The rich got away."

And that is something worth thinking about.

Vivek Kaul is the Editor of the Diary and The Vivek Kaul Letter. Vivek is a writer who has worked at senior positions with the Daily News and Analysis (DNA) and The Economic Times, in the past. He is the author of the Easy Money trilogy. The latest book in the trilogy Easy Money: The Greatest Ponzi Scheme Ever and How It Is Set to Destroy the Global Financial System was published in March 2015. The books were bestsellers on Amazon. His writing has also appeared in The Times of India, The Hindu, The Hindu Business Line, Business World, Business Today, India Today, Business Standard, Forbes India, Deccan Chronicle, The Asian Age, Mutual Fund Insight, Wealth Insight, Swarajya, Bangalore Mirror among others.

Disclaimer: The views mentioned above are of the author only. Data and charts, if used, in the article have been sourced from available information and have not been authenticated by any statutory authority. The author and Equitymaster do not claim it to be accurate nor accept any responsibility for the same. The views constitute only the opinions and do not constitute any guidelines or recommendation on any course of action to be followed by the reader. Please read the detailed Terms of Use of the web site.

Recent Articles

Why Economists Are Morons December 9, 2017
Why are most modern economists such nincompoops? The quick answer: because it pays.
Bitcoin is the Best Offshore Bank Account December 8, 2017
The biggest advantage bitcoin has over offshore banks is that it's truly offshore. Not just off Britain's shores, but off every country's shores.
A Long Bear Market in Bonds Is Coming... December 8, 2017
Taking a long-term view, you can see that stocks move in great waves lasting about 30 years from peak to peak.
You Can't Print Real Wealth December 7, 2017
Real wealth must be earned... by someone.

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "What Vehicle Sales Tell Us About Notebandi". Click here!

20 Responses to "What Vehicle Sales Tell Us About Notebandi"

MURALI

Feb 24, 2017

The rural population definitely suffered a bit more than Urban. However, rural population were also very careful about spending in this 3 -4 months. Let us wait till April and match the data and it is likely that the people who delayed their spending may do it in April +. Till then, we need to wait. It is possible that the demand has been put on hold and moved to later months.

Like 

SASHIKUMAR K S

Feb 22, 2017

Dear MR.Vivek
Please understand that generally people do not buy vehicles during the fag end of the year for the
simple reason that the year of registration is an important aspect while the vehicle goes for resale later on.
This chart has no relationship to notebandi. Please analyse the trend in the previous years also and i strongly
presume that it would have been the same. True, notebandi created some side effects but let us give the government some more time and see the outcome. Ordinary citizens are not bothered about it any more and have moved on.

Like (2)

Ved Parkash

Feb 21, 2017

Dear Vivek. Pl do continue to write on the subject. it is very interesting even for a non economist , non financial guy like me. With due respect to my fellow reader - he can ignore the articles he does not find meaningful but for me it certainly is informative and impacts my thinking as well as my decision making.
Regards,
Ved

Like (2)

jAYANT GHARPURE

Feb 21, 2017

I disagree with your's as well Ambit hypothesis. to me Notebandi has nothing to do with drop in Sales 2 wheeler & 4 wheelers - may be some impact in 2 wheelers from class of people who don't have regular income 7 who save money as & when earned. There is no reason for not buying vehicles when easy financing options were available or when one has sufficient Bank balance is available. there was no restriction on cheque transactions.

I also remember one TV debate where Maruti Chairman made statement that Maruti had better sales in Dec 16 than in Dec15.

to me drop in vehicle sales reflects attitude of consumer & points to some underhand dealings in financing generating Black money

It will interesting to know how many vehicles are finance by Cash transaction.


Like (1)

Subba Rao

Feb 21, 2017

That the "demonetisation"drive impacted the lower rungs of the Indian society is by now well established and understood by most of us. This the section of the society that does not have access to the various non-cash options such as Credit card, Netbanking, Mobile Wallets etc etc. Also, this is the section of the society that largely earns on daily / weekly basis and the amounts in question are small. In a scenario where even those who could afford to go cashless ended up hoarding cash being unsure of how things would pan out, the poorer sections were the hardest hit. It was evident when one went to the neighbourhood markets or spoke to auto drivers, vegetable vendors and others. Detailed "analysis" such as these may drive home the same point that most of us sub-consciously knew.

Like (1)

Muthuswamy N

Feb 20, 2017

4424571259 I thought you as an organization is for long term instead of short term benefits. You have always maintained you are!

But on notebandhi your stance is completely opposite. Why do you take a stand like this? Drop in sales in one month is not going to bring the heavens down. Don't fall into the trap of linear thinking that once you have taken a stand you should keep up the same stand for times immemorial. The public at large has lost interest on this. Don't do the blunder of media that keep on and on in a role that they arrogate to themselves of informing the public. The public has heard both sides of the story and come to a conclusion. There is no point in beating a dead snake.

Like (3)

SRIKANTH M

Feb 20, 2017

Vivek,

have been reading your articles over the last year or so.
Depressing to find a DISTINCT Bias over the last few articles .
Are you saying that Notebandi is Bad ?
No Corrupt Govt Official has been affected ?
No Politican has been affected ?
The data mining on the monies deposited in the banking system is all null and void ?
I reserve my comments.
Off late am getting to a view that reading your articles a waste of time as I am seeing a subtle push down of your thoughts with an agenda in place.

Like (3)

S.Rangarajan

Feb 20, 2017

No wonder, the notorious agents have asked you to stop writing about demonetization, which is only one among the innumerous misdeeds. This is only the first step and many more steps will follow like letting loose ugly elements like Swamy and finally, if necessary, the elements of the various senas under their control. Even after 50 days, this govt. and RBI are not prepared to disclose the details of how much of demonetised money has comeback. Our great [anti] national media is maintaining deadly silence and the only hope, for honest citizens of this nation, is people like you. Crores of innocent, poor and honest citizens had been standing in queue for long hours for more than 50 days, most of the times in-vain. More than 170 innocent people have died, while standing in queue. As a mark of respect to those departed souls and crores of innocent citizens, please continue your Service to your MOTHERLAND.

Like (3)

Sam

Feb 20, 2017

your comments are spot on. here is another interesting side effect of notebandi - the increase in number of cheque bounce cases especially in tier III towns etc. i am sure if we can find some data, it will check this fact out. the problem is that post notebandi, most small businesses had no choice but to accept cheques and in many cases those bounced. people have 2 choices now - run after the buyer or go to court. another challenge in villages is that even today, there is hardly 1 branch for 3-5 villages and getting cash out is a problem despite limits going up. banks are still short of cash.

Like (3)

C S JACOB

Feb 20, 2017

The author is right in his assessment of the adverse effect of Notebandi on the two-wheeler sales. Car sales were less affected. The Bajaj Auto MD, Mr Rajeev Bajaj, was outspoken in his criticism when he said that it was not the implementation alone, the very idea of Notebandi was wrong. The sales of two-wheeler came down by 15-20 percent in the last two months as against an expected rise of 8-10 percent registered during these months. FMCG is another sector affected by demonitisation. Several small and medium scale industries have been affected likewise- Tiruppur, Banares, Moradabad, Surat, Bhiwandi etc, for want of cash in the system. If one looks at the hard data, the reasons for the setback to the economy would be amply clear.

The currency in circulation in the last ten years has been around 12 percent of the GDP and has been growing at a rate of 15 percent p.a. It stood at Rs 17.9 trillion before Nov 8. It is common sense that, if 87 percent of it (Rs 15.4 tn) was invalidated overnight, thereby bringing the currency in circulation to just two percent of the GDP, the economy cannot function as before. The remonitisation has been a slow process; as on Feb 3 the currency in circulation was only Rs 10.5 tn. As this would include some old currency, the RBI is yet to release Rs 8 tn to the public in order to reach the pre Nov 8 level. In the last month, the addition of notes was below Rs 0.4 trillion per week, a point made by the author in his previous coloumn. Therefore, it would take another 20 weeks (end June) before the status quo ante was restored.

The govt, no doubt, would collect some additional tax from the unaccounted cash disclosed in the process replacing old notes with new. However, the process would be arduous and protracted and lead to corruption on the part of the tax collectors. Also there was no way of compensating those who lost wages, sales and profits due to Notebandi. It needs to be noted that even the tax evaded cash was contributing to the GDP by creating goods and services as well as employment.

Like (3)
   Next>>
Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "What Vehicle Sales Tell Us About Notebandi". Click here!