Refighting the 'Civil' War - Vivek Kaul's Diary
Free Reports

Refighting the 'Civil' War

May 12, 2017

27

SALTA, ARGENTINA - Public life is always a hoot...

People of sound mind and reasonable judgment in their personal lives take on characters full of unwarranted confidence and intolerant insistence in public.

The couple whose son has a 'drug problem' wants the government to start a nationwide treatment program.

The guy who can't get his town sanitation department to pick up the trash in front of his house wants to clean up a government on the other side of the world.

The woman who is not sure she will need an umbrella is convinced the planet is warming up.

It's always easier to solve someone else's problem than your own. That's one of the great advantages of living overseas: Public life is full of other people's problems.

Old Stones

Imagine if a group of Americans proposed to abolish the First Amendment, take away your favourite monuments, or introduce devil worship at your church.

You would be outraged.

But when similar outrages happen in a foreign language...they are mostly amusing and puzzling.

The show is a comedy, not a tragedy. As our friend Nassim Taleb puts it, we have no 'skin in the game'.

Overseas, we lack the cues, the context, and the emotional connections to take them seriously.

We read the headlines; we shake our heads and smile. The local myths and mysteries have no power over us.

So it was that when a group of leftist demonstrators marched through Salta yesterday, we didn't know what to make of it.

'What was that all about?' we asked.

Meanwhile, scuffles broke out in New Orleans on Monday. On one side were demonstrators eager to pull down the statues of war heroes Robert E. Lee, Jefferson Davis, and PGT Beauregard. On the other side, demonstrators were there to protect them.

ABC News:

  • Multiple people were arrested on Sunday as hundreds of protesters clashed over the fate of Confederate monuments in New Orleans, police said.

    Three protesters were arrested and charged with disturbing the peace on Sunday afternoon near Lee Circle in New Orleans after a fight broke out at a Confederate monuments demonstration, according to the New Orleans Police Department...

    More than 700 people attended demonstrations on Sunday on both sides of the city's plans to remove three remaining Confederate monuments.

Then, on Tuesday night, vandals defaced the monument to PGT Beauregard, draping a sign on it that said: 'This is historical violence, we say no.'

We're not sure what that was supposed to mean. But we know where our sympathies lie: with the stones.

--- Advertisement ---
This Could End the India Story

If there is one thing that worries me about India's prospects...

It's the jobs crisis.

The 33,000 Indians who are joining the work force every day...only to find there are hardly any jobs to go around.

The net result is that there's a sea of unemployed and not so usefully employed people out there...and it's becoming bigger every day. Alarmingly.

At some point in time, this is going to tip into a massive crisis which could spill into our streets. And have serious implications for our future...the future of our families.

Now, we don't know when this will happen...but with every passing day, we believe we are coming closer to that day.

In fact, given the layoffs in IT, and impact of automation, that day may come sooner still.

Yes, like we have often said, this is a potentially scary situation.

And one which you cannot turn away from...

That's why we strongly recommend you read our detailed report on this crisis and find out what it could mean for you...
------------------------------

War of Liberation

Confederate General Robert E Lee was one of the greatest soldiers in American history. Compared to him, the gilded generals now frequenting the White House - Mattis, McMaster, Kelly - are little more than paper pushers.

But let's look at PGT Beauregard, the hero of the First Battle of Bull Run.

Born on a sugar plantation in St Bernard Parish, Louisiana, little Pierre Gustave Toutant Beauregard didn't speak English until his parents sent him to New York to learn it.

Thence, he got an appointment to West Point and began his military career thereafter. He served his country in the Mexican-American War...and then served as superintendent at West Point.

But when Louisiana declared independence, what was he to do? Defend the homeland? Or fight against it?

We begin by correcting a common misunderstanding. Many people call it the 'Civil War', which is not only oxymoronic but also incorrect.

A civil war is a fight between two or more factions for the control of the government. The war that took place between 1861 and 1865 was nothing of the sort.

Instead, it was a war of national liberation. The Southern states seceded from the Union - a right announced in the founding document of the US, the Declaration of Independence.

Thereafter, they never sought any control or even influence over the remaining United States of America.

Government is always a way for the few to exploit the many. The southerners wanted no more than to be ripped off and bossed around by their own people.

Flattering Narrative

But it's been a long time since the war.

Facts degrade like carbon isotopes. Real knowledge declines by the square of the time gone by and the magnitude of the event in question.

In its place, a simplified myth provides a soothing explanation, leaving those who believe it dumber than they were had they known nothing at all.

So the stage was set when Donald J Trump came on the scene.

The New York Times:

  • 'People don't realize, you know, the Civil War, if you think about it, why?' he told his interviewer...

    Mr. Trump followed up on the comment in a tweet on Monday night, arguing that [Andrew] Jackson saw the Civil War coming and would have prevented it had he not died 16 years earlier.

Why?

Almost immediately, the great and the good rose to the challenge, denouncing Mr Trump for daring to challenge the flattering narrative.

In their minds, the 'Civil War' had but one cause. Even Chelsea Clinton let her Twitter fans know what it was immediately: 'slavery'.

This made the war unavoidable, just, and heroic. Whipping the South, at great cost, made sense because it wiped that stain from the national escutcheon.

That is the only politically acceptable narrative for the 'Civil War' today.

Mission to Protect

But the poor little Creole!

It was much more complicated for PGT Beauregard. He was trained as a soldier. His mission was to protect his country...as commanded by his civilian superiors.

Louisiana declared independence in January 1861. The Confederate States of America then offered to make him a brigadier general. What was he to say?

'No, thanks... I'll stick with the Yankees.'

Judged by today's sentiments, he might have refused service, citing slavery (a classic win-lose deal - slave owners won while slaves lost) as a deal breaker.

He might have led a demonstration, seated on the grass in front of the state house playing guitars and singing Kumbaya. He could have asked for gluten-free wafers in church, too.

But this was the 1860s, and his homeland was about to be invaded by a foreign army.

In the event, Beauregard cast his lot with his fellow Southerners. And when Lincoln sent his army into Virginia, he was ready for them.

The Yankees attacked at Bull Run, Virginia, in July 1861. Beauregard, in command of the Confederate Army there, counterattacked and drove them back to their barracks in Washington, DC.

Some military scholars believe Beauregard should have followed up with a move against the capital. He might have captured the White House and Congress...and brought the war to an early close.

Had he done so, who knows what would have happened?

Perhaps the nation would have been spared 1 million deaths. Maybe slavery could have been ended in an orderly, nonviolent way.

And maybe Lincoln's statues would now be hoisted up and carried away.

Regards,
BILL BONNER Founder, Agora Inc
Bill


Bill Bonner is the President & Founder of Agora Inc, an international publisher of financial and special interest books and newsletters.

Disclaimer: The views mentioned above are of the author only. Data and charts, if used, in the article have been sourced from available information and have not been authenticated by any statutory authority. The author and Equitymaster do not claim it to be accurate nor accept any responsibility for the same. The views constitute only the opinions and do not constitute any guidelines or recommendation on any course of action to be followed by the reader. Please read the detailed Terms of Use of the web site.

Recent Articles

Trump Takes a Beating August 18, 2017
Donald J Trump, a wrasslin' fan, took a 'Holy Sh*t!' blow on Tuesday.
Which Gods Will Bring Down the US Empire? August 17, 2017
Mr Trump is in the White House and the gods are in their heavens; what's not to like?
Will They Haul Off Trump's Statue, Too? August 16, 2017
All across the country, the old gods become devils. New, gluten-free gods take their places...
Farm Loan Waivers: Why Bad Economics Makes for Good Politics August 14, 2017
It is because the negative effects of the waivers aren't clearly visible.

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Refighting the 'Civil' War". Click here!