Free Reports

There's No Free Lunch in Economics

Sep 25, 2017


So here is a small story, which you, dear reader, should probably try and remember all through your life.

There are four mithaiwallahs (sweetshops) in a colony (You can call them cookie shops or cake shops or bakeries, if you want to. It doesn't change the argument that I am trying to make in anyway).

A fifth mithaiwallah, who is loaded with money, decides to set up shop. Given that his mithais(sweets) are more or less same to what everyone else is offering, he needs to offer something more to attract customers. So, he offers free mithais, up to one kg, every day, for the first 2 months.

Given that we all love a good deal, soon, there is a queue in front of his shop everyday. And not surprisingly, the business of the remaining four mithaiwallahs collapses. There is only so much mithai that people can consume. (I mean they can go briefly overboard on this front, but then there are health consequences that they would have to bear).

The four mithaiwallahs decide to compete with the new kid on the block. They are not as loaded with money as the fifth one to be offering stuff for free, so they cut prices of their mithais. The hope is that at lower prices the consumers who have ditched them, will come back to them. After all, they have shared a healthy relationship over the years.

And come to think of it, it is their fault as well. For a very long time, they have operated like a cartel, and have kept prices high. Given that the four mithaiwallahs are all related, the gains have been shared all within the family.

So, not surprisingly, when the fifth mithaiwallah sets up shop, the consumers who are seeing the benefits of competition for the first time, go running to him. I mean, if someone sells you products of the same and better quality for a lower price, why wouldn't you buy stuff from him. The money thus saved can be spent somewhere else. At the end, there is only so much money going around and that has to be judiciously spent.

Soon, the four mithaiwallahs come to the realisation that cutting prices isn't taking them anywhere because the fifth mithaiwallah continues to offer mithais for free. He is bleeding but in the process, he is ensuring that they are bleeding as well.

The fifth mithai wallah has owned government ration shops for many years and has made pot loads of money selling cheap rice, wheat and sugar, in the open market at higher rates. Hence, he is loaded with money and can outlast the four mithailwallahs he is competing with. In order to compete the four mithaiwallahs also start offering some mithais in a limited amount for free. They are left with no other option. If they have to compete they have to offer stuff for free.

But as a result, they have to dilute the quality of their mithais. In their line of business, quality and quantity rarely go together. The consumer realises this shift in quality. This is not to say that the fifth mithaiwallah was offering good quality mithai. It's just that he was offering it free. The fall in quality of the four mithaiwallahs leads to a situation where the consumers who were sticking on to them because of their better quality, also decide to desert them.

  FREE Report
Download Now
  The GST Tax - The Good, The Sad and The Terrible Vivek Kaul's inquiry into the GST shatters the myths that the mainstream media is floating. It's a must read.

Download your FREE copy today and learn the hidden truth about the GST and how it could impact the system, and you.

Download This Special Report Now. It's Free.

Soon, because of offering free stuff, they are losing money hand over fist. The wait for the customers to turn up has become endless. Of course, with no money coming in, they find it difficult to repay the loans they had taken from the local bank to build their shops.

Very soon, one of the mithaiwallah defaults on a loan. Soon, the others join them. And the local bank has a problem.

Meanwhile, the fifth mithaiwallah, seeing that his competitors are in trouble, starts cutting down on the free stuff on offer and raises prices. He figures out that soon he will be the only one left with any cash and the market will be all his. So, best to start cashing in on it.

He is the last man standing in the market and can price mithais, any way he wants to. The people are already addicted to his free mithai, cannot do without it and hence, have to pay whatever he asks for.

With the bank tottering, the depositors start making noise, and the local government has to come to their rescue, and ends up in financial trouble as well. This basically means that the taxpayer has to bailout the bank.

Dear Reader, you will see a version of this story, play out over and over again. The point being there are no free lunches in economics. Never!

There is always a cost that the system has to pay. Hence, if something looks too good to be true, maybe it is.

Vivek Kaul is the Editor of the Diary. He is the author of the Easy Money trilogy. The books were bestsellers on Amazon. His latest book is India's Big Government - The Intrusive State and How It is Hurting Us.

Disclaimer: The views mentioned above are of the author only. Data and charts, if used, in the article have been sourced from available information and have not been authenticated by any statutory authority. The author and Equitymaster do not claim it to be accurate nor accept any responsibility for the same. The views constitute only the opinions and do not constitute any guidelines or recommendation on any course of action to be followed by the reader. Please read the detailed Terms of Use of the web site.

Recent Articles

A New Infrastructure Boom March 26, 2019
Selva Freigedo talks about the potential in 5G network and how it could transform the way we communicate.
A 40 Somethings Guide to YouTube Hits March 20, 2019
Vivek dwells into a new YouTube phenomenon.
As the Economy Slows Down, Maruti and Two-Wheeler Companies Cut Production March 19, 2019
The country's largest car maker has cut production by more than a fourth.
In Supporting Demonetisation, RBI Behaved Like an Old Uncle Not Willing to Take a Stand March 13, 2019
The minutes of the meeting of the RBI Board which happened before demonetisation have been released.

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "There's No Free Lunch in Economics". Click here!

8 Responses to "There's No Free Lunch in Economics"

Harishkumar Shetty

Sep 28, 2017

A Brilliant One Sir.Thank You.


Ashit Thaker

Sep 26, 2017

Absolutely true . People will never understand this, even if they understand The greed always lures .
There is always a price to pay . A farmer will get a loan waver but might loose a child when the same Govt does not provide oxygen. Or the gain might be sum1's and Loss of sum1 else. But, when one does not see direct loss from his/her pocket the loss is not registered, not felt ...and becomes a fool . As the saying goes
" what the eye does not see the heart does not grieve"

But grieve it has to later on

Ashit Thaker



Sep 26, 2017

looks like JIO story ;only the last part has still to be played outFree economysometimes brings its own compulsions.growth must be both profitable and sustainable;balance of topline and bottomline is lacking in some of our industry segments.



Sep 26, 2017

if the earlier mithaiwalas don't invest in new recipes ( technology), a new mithaiwala will take advantage and invest in that. In business one cannot remain complacent.



Sep 25, 2017

I think Vivek is saying the story about JIO and other telecom operators..

Like (1)

Mahesh Kumar Sharma

Sep 25, 2017

I fully agree with the point made.If anybody offers something for free.It is certain that there is some hidden agenda. Everybody knows it but even than most fall prey to our politicians who promise everything for free and are looting the nation.Just see their pay and perks and retirement benefits after being in job just for 5 yrs .

Like (1)


Sep 25, 2017

Organizers of A national meeting taking place in the capital seem to have disregarded versions of the story. After all, if FIIs and other well wishers underwrite your party and your lunch then use your connections to stash your profits offshore to buy up favorable influence.

Like (1)

B. Shah

Sep 25, 2017

You have said the obvious that is going on in India. Despite taking collatrals/pledging of borrower's assets, banks are not able to recover money from them. More laws are still needed and more money has to be pumped in to banking system to save them. This will generate more NPAs. What sort of country are we? What about taking to task bank officials, particularly C/MD who have advanced these loans? Further they and govt want bank rates to go down, so that more loans are given. This is vicious circle and has to be broken by someone other than politicians. B-BJP (Business:Babu-Judiciary-Politician)nexus will play on ever and ever

Like (1)
Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "There's No Free Lunch in Economics". Click here!