The Greater Fool Theory of Real Estate

Oct 19, 2016

Some regular readers of the Diary have been asking on the social media as to why I have stopped writing on real estate.

Actually, I haven't, it's just when it comes to real estate, I have had nothing new to say for a while. But today's piece is about real estate. Not that this has something very new to say, but the story that I came across was interesting enough to be discussed in detail.

First and foremost, I would like to thank Pune based Ashish Deshpande, Director, Paradigm Wealth Managers, for bringing this to my notice. So here is the story.

On the insistence of a friend, Deshpande went to check out a new real estate development in Wadala in Mumbai.

His friend could only afford the one bed room hall kitchen (BHK) that was on offer. And how much did it cost? Rs 1.8 crore. Deshpande got chatting to the builder's sales guy and asked him, how many end users were actually buying the one BHK apartments. The sales guy, not surprisingly, answered 90 per cent. I mean, what else could he have said. He is expected to sell apartments not philosophise about them.

Of course, like a good sales guy, he was lying. Deshpande then asked the sales manager to imagine the profile of the guy who would in a position to pay Rs 1.8 crore to buy an apartment to live in it. Let's do a little maths to get into a little more detail here.

A bank or a housing finance company would finance up to 80 per cent of the value of the apartment. This means a home loan of Rs 1.44 crore (80 per cent of Rs 1.8 crore). Let's say the individual who wants to buy this apartment goes to the State Bank of India. He takes on a twenty-year home loan at 9.25 per cent per year.

How much does the EMI on this amount to? Rs 1,31,885 per month. How much does a person need to earn per month for the bank or the housing finance company, to give him the required home loan? Assuming around 40 per cent of the salary goes towards the EMI, the monthly salary would have to be around Rs 3.3 lakh. This would mean an annual pay of around Rs 40 lakh.

 Advertisement [VIDEO]: 58 Minutes with Vivek Kaul... The "India Crisis" that I have been warning you about in my previous emails just got worse. In fact, to help me explain to you the potential danger this crisis puts you and your family in... We invited lauded journalist Vivek Kaul to speak with me at our Equitymaster offices in Nariman Point. Click HERE to see that video and learn: What India's demographic dividend really looks like What industries India really needs to focus on to get on top What the government is really concerned with Why you should begin to protect your financial assets and family immediately *Plus valuable information on the current real estate market Click HERE to watch the full 58-minute video.

How many people actually earn that kind of money? Further, the individual would also have to arrange for a downpayment of Rs 36 lakh (Rs 1.8 crore - Rs 1.44 crore). How many people have such a saving? Also, would you expect someone earning as much as Rs 40 lakh per year to live in a one BHK apartment? Would take a very desperate person to do that.

Deshpande offered this logic to the sales manager (not in as much detail). Then the manager let the cat out of the bag and said that most of the people purchasing one BHKs were buying it as a second home. People buy second homes typically to put it on rent to make a regular income, avail of the huge tax deduction that is available or to simply invest money and stay put. Or they simply have some money lying around and they don't know what to do with it.

Rental yields (annual rent divided by the market price of the apartment) are currently around 2 per cent. So why would anyone in their right mind buy a home to put it on rent? Even after tax returns on fixed deposits, for those in the 30 per cent tax bracket work out to around 5 per cent.

When it comes to saving tax, the strategy perhaps makes some sense. In case of a second home loan (and third and fourth and so on) the entire interest paid on a home loan is tax-deductible as long as a notional rent is added to the income.

But what complicates matters in this case is that the delivery of the apartment is not scheduled up until 2020. That essentially increases the risk given that there are a whole host of under construction properties that haven't been delivered over the last few years.

Also, the apartment comes with the condition that it cannot be sold before possession is granted. So this basically means that it is a five-year investment and can be sold only by around 2021. So what is a reasonable rate of return for an investor to expect in this case? Deshpande works with a simple rate of return (and not compounded) of 8 per cent per year. This would mean an absolute rate of return of 40 per cent over a period of five-year.

This basically means that five years later the apartment should be worth at least Rs 2.5 crore (actually Rs 2.52 crore to be very precise). If we include stamp duty and other charges (which also need to be recovered) the apartment should fetch at least Rs 2.75 crore in 2021.

A simple rate of return of 8 per cent per year might just work in this case because the buyer is also getting a huge deduction for the interest that he pays on the home loan. But what if someone is looking at least at a compounded rate of return of 10 per cent per year? Then the price of the apartment has to be around Rs 2.9 crore in 2021. And this is without taking the stamp duty into account.

Now, imagine one BHK apartments selling for Rs 3 crore in 2021? These are the numbers we are looking at. What if there are no buyers? As Deshpande puts it: "in the absence of an end user your investment becomes a fixed deposit fetching 2% return annually with principal not in sight or at least at big risk."

So where does that leave us? It brings us back to the Greater Fool Theory of Real Estate. Or the theory on the basis of which people are still betting on real estate. The expectation is that at the end of the holding period of five years (in this specific case) one will always be able to find a greater fool who is willing to buy real estate at an even higher price. In more general cases, the expectation is to find a greater fool who is willing to buy.

If that is how you like to invest, then all I can say is best of luck. Or maybe you have a lot of black money lying around. And there is still no place better than real estate to launder it.

Vivek Kaul is the Editor of the Diary and The Vivek Kaul Letter. Vivek is a writer who has worked at senior positions with the Daily News and Analysis (DNA) and The Economic Times, in the past. He is the author of the Easy Money trilogy. The latest book in the trilogy Easy Money: The Greatest Ponzi Scheme Ever and How It Is Set to Destroy the Global Financial System was published in March 2015. The books were bestsellers on Amazon. His writing has also appeared in The Times of India, The Hindu, The Hindu Business Line, Business World, Business Today, India Today, Business Standard, Forbes India, Deccan Chronicle, The Asian Age, Mutual Fund Insight, Wealth Insight, Swarajya, Bangalore Mirror among others.

Disclaimer: The views mentioned above are of the author only. Data and charts, if used, in the article have been sourced from available information and have not been authenticated by any statutory authority. The author and Equitymaster do not claim it to be accurate nor accept any responsibility for the same. The views constitute only the opinions and do not constitute any guidelines or recommendation on any course of action to be followed by the reader. Please read the detailed Terms of Use of the web site.

Recent Articles

A New Infrastructure Boom March 26, 2019
Selva Freigedo talks about the potential in 5G network and how it could transform the way we communicate.
A 40 Somethings Guide to YouTube Hits March 20, 2019
Vivek dwells into a new YouTube phenomenon.
As the Economy Slows Down, Maruti and Two-Wheeler Companies Cut Production March 19, 2019
The country's largest car maker has cut production by more than a fourth.
In Supporting Demonetisation, RBI Behaved Like an Old Uncle Not Willing to Take a Stand March 13, 2019
The minutes of the meeting of the RBI Board which happened before demonetisation have been released.

13 Responses to "The Greater Fool Theory of Real Estate"

Chandravinod Pathak

Nov 1, 2016

Great article "The Greater Fool Theory of Real Estate". Your article is well researched and through in maths number.It has inspired me to write as under.

I wonder, how developer could put his money in such a project.

I would like you to write an article with the developers view . The developer must have worked out the profits he will make or losses he will suffer. There must be some catch in it.

Please, if you decide to write on this, give me credit for it. This is in the lighter note.I will appreciate if you acknowledge my comments with your comments.

KD

Oct 28, 2016

ACE investor Jhunjhunwala is asking people to buy house. What do you think?

Uma

Oct 27, 2016

You have hit the nail on the head. Rental yield hint at oversupply. But the 'bubble' refuses to burst. I think real estate moves in tandem with bullion. Gold price reflects actual inflation/ devaluation of currency. While the rupee did become almost worthless in last 10 years, the real estate prices have far surpassed gold prices. It has to correct, otherwise nobody will be able to sell.

S Sharma

Oct 20, 2016

To pay an EMI of 1.3 Lakhs/month, 40 Lakh per year should be the tax paid annual salary. Gross salary should be 60 Lakhs per annum.

Like (2)

DN

Oct 20, 2016

Dear Vivek Sir,

Please suggest if it is OK to share your articles on social media?
At present an option to share instantly is not available on your webpage.

Regards,

Like (2)

Rajat

Oct 20, 2016

well said !!

Like (2)

KD

Oct 20, 2016

There was article in economic times that job market is shrinking for last four years. In this job market there is no way residential real estate can increase. Moreover, in few years India will become un-livable. There will kidnapping and extortion.

Like (2)

Dr.UN Nandakumar

Oct 19, 2016

Quite an interesting article from sustainability perspective.

Like (2)

Abhishek aggarwal

Oct 19, 2016

His salary needs to be 60 lakhs. You have assumed 3.3 lakh as in hand.for 3.3 lakhs to be in hand, the fixed salary alone has to be 65 lakhs :)

Like (1)

Rishi

Oct 19, 2016

Very true but somehow prices have held on and not crashing. Some people argue that space is a constraint in Mumbai. On the contrary there are vast tracts of mill land still available and old developments which can be re-developed. The Govt. is also to blame for high Ready Reckoner Rates as well as taking high premium for FSI etc. Guess its a matter of time before the price will give way. State of in-equilibrium cannot be maintained for ever.

Like (1)