Of godliness and goodness - The Honest Truth By Ajit Dayal
Investing in India - Honest Truth by Ajit Dayal
Of godliness and goodness A  A  A

An interesting news item in DNA: many of India's top financial gurus went to Puttapurthi to seek the darshan of Sathya Sai Baba and - this is important - to attend "a conclave of the Sri Sathya Sai University on ethics in the world of finance".

----------- For the Women in your life - The Investment Guide for Women -----------
We know that there are not many women subscribers at Equitymaster.com but with so many women breaking the glass ceiling in the global corporate world and heading private sector banks in India, it's time for 'The Investment Guide for Women'. So if you'd like your wife to be a little more enthusiastic about saving, your daughter to take an active interest in planning her financial life, or your friend to make better informed investment decisions... just sign up for the 5 Minute Wrapup - it's FREE - and you'll get 'Rendezvous with Money - The investment guide for women' - right away in your inbox, also FREE! You may send it with our compliments to as many women as you like!


So, it is now official.
Ethics does matter in finance.
And, probably worried about the lack of ethics in finance, the universities of the gods are now ensuring that someone somewhere is focused on ethics.
Maybe the trusts of the god men bought a bunch of mis-sold financial products and are now demanding salvation of their corpus.

The list of attendees, according to DNA, were "Reserve Bank (of India) governor Duvvuri Subba Rao, his predecessor Y V Reddy, financing wizards Uday Kotak, K. V. Kamath, Kalpana Morparia, Aditya Puri, Gunit Chadha, Ajay Srinivasan, Meera Sanyal, and a clutch of other Finance Street honchos".

An impressive list - and there were more - who DNA described as "a who's who of the finance world".

It must have been a wonderful event - and I wish I had been there.
Not because we are anywhere part of the "who's who of the finance world" (ants do not have that privilege of such grand titles) but to understand whether the attendees listed were there as faculty - or as students.

Were they teaching ethics in finance?
Or were they learning it?
Or just discussing the need for ethics in finance?
And how to go about implementing any final decision on ethics in finance?

This conclave is actually a really important event.
More important than the Planning Commission's 5,145th meet on infrastructure; more important than the 865th meet on gas pricing; more important then the 87,532nd telephone call that bails out real estate developers and continues to keep property prices way out of reach of most of us.
Ethics, after all, is the moral foundation on which any action rests.
Any meeting - built on the correct foundation - is unimportant if that foundation is strong.
So an ethical politician would make the phone call to the PSU banks not to bail out the real estate developer; foreclose on their properties; and sell the apartments to those who need it at rock bottom, distress prices.

Unfortunately, there is no coverage on what transpired at this crucial conclave.

Maybe someone will write the 1st white paper on this.
If I was invited, I could have thrown some more light on the discussions.
(Hey, wait a minute, maybe that was why I was not invited???)

Visiting my guru
But, though I wished I was part of this conclave, I am lucky since I had just sought darshan from my own guru.

Professor Jack Behrman was my teacher at the University of North Carolina in Chapel Hill. He is not a god or a saint. But he is a good man. He taught a class called "ethics in business". A little broader than the Puttaparthi's "ethics in finance" conclave.
It was a "core" course - every MBA student had to take it.

The classrooms at UNC Chapel Hill were of the theatre style - chairs curved in each row arranged in a slope.
Professor Behrman was a slim person - but an overpowering personality in my life. But when it was time to head for "Behrman's class", the American students were filling up the classroom - from the back. They wanted to be as far away from the professor. They were, after all, here for an MBA. Did ethics have a role in business?
Their view was clear: they sat in the back rows.

A few idiots like me sat in the front row.
Eager to understand how we could shape our lives in an ethical framework.

But I met my guru on August 6th.
I was in New York meeting companies from Brazil and Mexico.
I asked Professor Behrman to see if I could fly down to Chapel Hill to see him and spend some time with him?
"Sure, Ajeeet" he said.

And so I flew to meet Professor Behrman.
We spent a wonderful 3 hours talking about where the world is.
And whether there is any ethics in finance.

"Professor Behrman", I joked, "remember all those people who sat at the last row of your class? They are probably the same folks who probably ended up working in Enron, WorldCom, AIG, Bear Stearns, and Lehman..."

And, as I read about this conclave, I wonder: it would be interesting to know where the "India's top financial gurus" sat.
Were they in the front row?
Or the back?
Were they there to learn or to teach?
Were they there for attendance - or to really seek salivation?

Well, let's see. Time will tell whether what one learns from your parents, your professors, and your mentors finds its way into a daily habit - or is part of a requirement to attend a "core" course.

And maybe that is part of who we are.
We worship a god every morning - and then live the life we live.
We worship a god for 10 days and then immerse him in the sea.
May the good that we learn always stay with us and not be left to drown in murky waters. May ethics in finance no longer be a weekend conclave but what we live in our daily lives.

Thank you, Professor Behrman, for showing me that there is another way.

Suggested allocation in Quantum Mutual Funds (after keeping safe money aside)
Quantum Long Term Equity Fund Quantum Gold Fund
Quantum Liquid Fund
Why you
should own
An investment for the future and an opportunity to profit from the long term economic growth in India A hedge against a global financial crisis and an "insurance" for your portfolio Cash in hand for any emergency uses but should get better returns than a savings account in a bank
Suggested allocation 80% 20% Keep aside money to meet your expenses for 6 months to 2 years

Disclaimer: Past performance may or may not be sustained in the future. Mutual Fund investments are subject to market risks, fluctuation in NAV's and uncertainty of dividend distributions. Please read offer documents of the relevant schemes carefully before making any investments. Click here for the detailed risk factors and statutory information"

Note: The Honest Truth is authored by Ajit Dayal. Ajit is a Director at Quantum Advisors Pvt Ltd and Quantum Asset Management Company Pvt Ltd.. Views expressed in this article are entirely those of the author and may not be regarded as views of the Quantum Mutual Fund or Quantum Asset Management Company Private Limited. To write to Ajit, please click here.

Read our Privacy Policy and Terms Of Use.
Get The Honest Truth directly
in your mail box.
Just enter your e-mail address» 

Read our Privacy Policy and Terms Of Use.

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Of godliness and goodness". Click here!

13 Responses to "Of godliness and goodness"


Sep 6, 2009

the article is beautifully presented, kudos to you.
the other day i came across a email from the head of the of the institute to all the field level executives forwarding the newspaper details of the ethical conclave., which was further circulated down to operations. purpose of mail ,action contemplated absent.it is a wild guess how many have cared to go through the contents.
my only wish is the people read the other side of the ethics conclave at least to be updated & informed.
continue doing the good work . with all best wishes.


Manoj Mukhi

Sep 5, 2009

Excellent one Mr. Dayal,
Actually yesterday I visited the Head office of our Own BMC in Mumbai for the first time in my life & I am telling you I was not able to sleep the whole night. Beceause One thing that was missing there was ethics & u see in what mess as a city we r today. I think it is the most important thing in any type of business ,U dont need an MBA degree to survuve but definetly u need to be ethical then your business will survive automatically.
Thanks & Good Day.


Sameer Singhvi

Sep 3, 2009

Dear Sir, like market we also have very short memory. We tend to forget all that was taught in early school days. And thats cause of misery for most of us. I have realised one thing in my small corporate career Competition is massive but if I compete I will always be unhappy. I need to innovate, thats the only thing in my hand. Ethics and competition just can't go hand in hand, as people are continiously raising there bechmarks of survival....survival not only in Industry but survival of there EGO...may industry, which is ultimately made of individuals practice spirituality, not for show off or for momentary realxation, but to understand and realise that whether its Elephant or Ant in industry....he is an individual detached from it and will ultimately need 6ft land in the end. This may increase ethical practices...
Please keep up your good work....



Sep 3, 2009

God Is Great
in performing our day to day activities we should follow atleast some morals from vedic scriptures like srimad Bhagavad Gita, and Bhagavat without understanding this two important literature one cannot perform his worldy duties honestly because all the human characteristics and qualities are explained in this holy books, so I kindly request all the businessman and all types of people in the society should follow and preach the gospel of Gita in our life.
Thanking you.



Sep 2, 2009

it was very nice and pleasing to note your appreciation and concern for good ethics and sharing your views of your mentor . god bless u .


Mandeep Dang

Sep 2, 2009

True"Sach ka Samna" hame karna parega


A Chopra

Sep 2, 2009

May be about 10 years back I attended an executive development program at IIM - Kolkata and during an exercise we were asked to go thrugh a story and give our comments about the behaviour of the people in that. I talked about the unethical behaviour of one person but was clearly told by the instructor not to talk about ethics in business. I do remember it was certainly before ENRON, and I sincerely hope that attitudes have changed since then.


Praveen Nambiar

Sep 2, 2009

Its so refreshing to see an article coming straight from the heart , Ethics has to be part of all spehres of our lives and especially in finance.
very well written and expressed !


M G Sharma

Sep 2, 2009

Wrong is always wrong it can never be made right . nobody can change the fruits of your karma not even God . There is no salvation from the theory of karma. Good or bad results are the fruits of your Karma which in turns are guided by your will your thinking your greed your knowledge .


M S Bakshi

Sep 2, 2009

Mr Dayal,
Please do share with your readers any information you get on what happened in this conclave.

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Of godliness and goodness". Click here!