A red light is a suggestion - The Honest Truth By Ajit Dayal
» INVESTING IN INDIA  
Investing in India - Honest Truth by Ajit Dayal
A red light is a suggestion A  A  A
PRINTER FRIENDLY | ARCHIVES
24 SEPTEMBER 2009


It is now official: people from New Delhi are rude.

Not only do they move around with guns in their cars to shoot women who question male drivers on why they cut lanes, but Delhi drivers are ill mannered.

----------------- Don't Miss -----------------
Ajit Dayal brings The Path To Profit - A Simple Journey For Your Investments to Mumbai!
To be held at The Indian Merchants Chamber (Churchgate), on Tuesday, 29th of September, 6:30 PM Onwards.
Request for a FREE invite today! Click here!

------------------------------------------

The commissioner of Mauritius, according to DNA, said, "Delhi drivers are very bad. They do not drive in lanes. Please ask them to drive in lanes."

"We cannot expect mega city policing (to) function properly if people do not change their behaviour. We still find vehicles jumping red lights, and police vehicles...too jump lights", Union Minister P. C. Chidambaram said at a function to inaugurate 22 police stations. This was a report in DNA on September 23, 2009.

To be fair, this jumping a red light - or not driving in a lane - is not a sickness confined to people from New Delhi.

It is an Indian problem.
It is a national habit.

And it comes from years of being ingrained with the most Indian of Indian traits.

"A red light", explained a friend of mine "is a suggestion."

Those six words capture the Indian-ness of being Indian.

If there is a law, don't treat it like a law.
If there is a rule, don't treat it like a rule.

Consider it to be a suggestion.

A suggestion that you can casually ignore and, if you are in the mood for it, happily break to any degree you are comfortable with.

The rules of the game
I marvel at the ease by which we pray to all our gods every morning and then go about doing some not-so-goodly acts for the rest of the day.

When one is so ready to break the letter of the law, of what use is the spirit of the law?

For years every mutual fund house in India - barring Quantum Mutual Fund - continued to play ball with a distribution channel that was working overdrive to shift investors from one new fund offering to another.

A chunk of this advice to switch from one fund to another was probably a function of the fees paid to the distribution channel. This made many "large" funds shrink in size as their "bought" assets were auctioned off to the next new fund offering.

At Quantum Mutual Funds, we did not suffer this deflation of assets.

Our funds were not sold by any distribution channels: we pay no commissions.
Our funds are bought by long term investors who understand and appreciate what we have built: a fund house that always cared for the investors even when the rules allowed certain practices.

Table 1: Staying on in a Fund was probably not a suggestion.
  Quantum Long Term Equity Fund A representative fund which raised money with the help of distributors
Assets as of March 31, 2006 Rs 10.9 crore Rs 3,096 crore
Returns from March 13, 2006 till September 22, 2009 +66.80% +63.51%
If no money was allowed to enter or leave the Funds, then the Assets on September 22, 2009 should have been... Rs 18.2 crore (the initial assets multiplied by the return) Rs. 5,062.3 crore (the initial assets multiplied by the return)
...but the actual AuM as on August 31, 2009 is... Rs 37.4 crore Rs 2,663.9 crore
..therefore, since investors can enter or leave the Fund... Rs 19.2 crore extra came into the Fund - over and above what the pure performance of a "closed end" fund would have been This fund is "missing" Rs 2,398.4 crore. If this fund was a "closed end" fund and if no investor was allowed to leave the Fund, then this Fund would have had an AuM of Rs. 5,062.3 crore. But since investors - presumably advised by their distributors - were free to leave, this Fund leaked Rs 2,398.4 crore...and ended up with a corpus of Rs 2,663.9 crore.

From the data in Table 1 above, we can see that the typical fund that used the typical distribution channel probably paid 2% to raise the assets (so, 2% of Rs 3,096 crore = Rs 61.92 crore).

This fund house probably ended up paying an exit fee of another 1% when the investor left (so, 1% of the "missing" Rs 2,398.4 crore = Rs 23.98 crore).

The typical distributor that worked for the typical fund probably earned Rs 85.90 crore (Rs 61.92 crore on the entry load and Rs 23.98 crore on the exit load).

Not bad for a hard day's work.
The problem was that this Rs 85.90 crore came from the investor's pocket.
Yes, from your pocket.

These numbers may not be accurate, and they are based on assumptions and ignore dividends paid out by the fund house and does not capture the precise dates when investors may have exit the fund. But they are representative of what did happen.

The table is representative of all the orange and yellow and red lights that were broken.
And the lanes that were constantly being cut.

SEBI steps in
Just as the Home Minister is trying to get drivers in Delhi to get their act together, SEBI has stepped in to make sure that sensible rules are in place.

So, there are a lot of green lights in the industry now.
Go-go green, to be precise, for those who are driving in their lanes.

The honest distributor and the honest financial planner (there are a lot of them and we would love to work with them - please email us at Info@QuantumAMC.com to see how we can work together) will now be able to advise their clients with no distractions.
They will be paid a fee directly by the investors.
No more opaque payment structures that made lane cutting a way of life.

In the past few years, these honest advisors and distributors saw the "competition" taking away their honest business. They were at pains to warn their dwindling client base about the risks of following the aggressive fund-flipping strategies that commission-driven distributors were recommending.

So SEBI has banned the concept of entry loads.

On exit loads, there is a debate.
There is uncertainty.

Are mutual funds allowed to pay distributors any exit loads - from the pool of money that belongs to investors?
Or do all payments for the exit loads have to come from the mutual fund house? A fund house earns management fees, it is free to give as much of it (or as little of it) to any distributor.

While the industry awaits these clarifications on the exit load, the steering wheel is ready for a sharp turn.
And the foot is ready to be pressed onto the accelerator.

"You know us", said a senior person in the distribution industry, "We will find a way to make money."

So, there you have it.
The red light is a suggestion.
Lane cutting is a national birthright.

Meanwhile, Quantum Mutual Funds will stop at all the red lights - and avoid cutting the lanes.
Though, I must confess, we have Raju: driving around in South India.

No, he is not related to the Satyam family, but given his desire to cut lanes and break lights....CLICK HERE TO READ THE PATH TO PROFIT BLOG...

Suggested allocation in Quantum Mutual Funds (after keeping safe money aside)
Quantum Long Term Equity Fund Quantum Gold Fund
(NSE symbol: QGOLDHALF)
Quantum Liquid Fund
Why you
should own
it:
An investment for the future and an opportunity to profit from the long term economic growth in India A hedge against a global financial crisis and an "insurance" for your portfolio Cash in hand for any emergency uses but should get better returns than a savings account in a bank
Suggested allocation 80% 20% Keep aside money to meet your expenses for 6 months to 2 years

Disclaimer: Past performance may or may not be sustained in the future. Mutual Fund investments are subject to market risks, fluctuation in NAV's and uncertainty of dividend distributions. Please read offer documents of the relevant schemes carefully before making any investments. Click here for the detailed risk factors and statutory information"


Note: The Honest Truth is authored by Ajit Dayal. Ajit is a Director at Quantum Advisors Pvt Ltd and Quantum Asset Management Company Pvt Ltd.. Views expressed in this article are entirely those of the author and may not be regarded as views of the Quantum Mutual Fund or Quantum Asset Management Company Private Limited. To write to Ajit, please click here.


Read our Privacy Policy and Terms Of Use.
Get The Honest Truth directly
in your mail box.
Just enter your e-mail address» 

Read our Privacy Policy and Terms Of Use.

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "A red light is a suggestion". Click here!

4 Responses to "A red light is a suggestion"

Harish

Oct 6, 2009

I think, its best service by mr. ajit dayal. and all services of equitymaster is best, no doubt about that. thanks very much by associating with you...

Thanks and regards
Harish S. Kawalkar

Like 

K Anant Rao

Sep 29, 2009

Dear Ajit,

Read your views on "The Honest Truth"... Good one..
It reminds me a case of "lender always looses the game"..
Take a case.. I bought a flat for 8 Lacs in 2004 and my bank financed me 6.4 lac @ a fixed rate of 8%. Today my flat is worth 24 lacs but what wud the Lender have earned so far who may lend the amount to bank at say 7% rate of interest. assuming 100bps of spread to the bank.
If all the borrowers default, the Govt. wud bail them out with stimulus packages butno one bothers about the fear of the lender. After all the Govt. can print money..
If Ben Johnson used Steriods to win the 100m dash in Seoul Olympics 1988 it was wrong.. but if Govt. used Steriods in the name of inffusing life into economy.. thats fine..
Keep the good work..
Regards,
K Anant Rao

Like 

Param

Sep 24, 2009

Ajit,
I think you also need to bring out the "Trailing Fee" out in the open. This is similar to the insurance agent getting commission without providing any service. It is usually 0.5%-0.75%, so people don't notice it, but with your Vanguard experience, I'm sure you recognise that every cost matters over long term compounding.
When you say you would love to work with distributors, I hope you don't intend to bring the Trail Fee disease in QMF.
Regards, Param

Like 

Vivek Gupta

Sep 24, 2009

Ajit
I think you need to write a piece on ULIPs because after the ban by SEBI on ebtry load in mutual funds distributors and guys from insurance industry are in an overdrive to SELL investors ULIPs wherein they charge huge premium allocation charge (entry load)... Kindly pen down your views on this..

Regards,
Vivek Gupta

Like 
  
Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "A red light is a suggestion". Click here!