This Mutual Fund Rule Could Make Small Caps Profitable Again!

May 4, 2018

Richa Agarwal, Research analyst

I've often spoken to you about your edge over big investors in the small cap space - that big investors avoid small caps because of low liquidity. And you, as a small investor, have an advantage because you can jump right in.

But to be honest, dear reader, your edge has been shrinking over time.

That's kind of hard to swallow, I imagine. You must be wondering if you have taken enough advantage of this edge while you had it... Let me explain why you can STILL benefit if you just pay attention now.

Over the last three to four years, there has been a significant influx of money in the stock market via mutual funds. One of the key reasons for this is the rise of the retail investor.

Ankit Shah, also known as the Equitymaster Insider, recently shared the below chart with his readers highlighting this trend.

The Phenomenal Rise of the Retail Indian Investor

The big question is - where is all this money going?

The following statistics could give a clue.

Since January 2014, the Sensex has gained 66%. The Midcap index is up 153%.

--- Advertisement ---
[BUSTED] The 'Hot Stock' Myth...

For the past 16 years, the Bombay Investing Society has stood against getting rich with the 'Next Hot Stock'...

And while maintaining its stand, has successfully guided over 7,000 of its members towards double, even triple digit returns!

Don't believe us?

Click here to know more...

But the real performer has been small cap index, up 177%. It has outperformed Sensex by nearly three times.

With more money chasing the stock market, and only a limited number of stocks in the large and mid-cap space, the small cap space is not that sacrosanct anymore.

Mutual funds have been encroaching on your turf (even under the schemes that are not meant to focus on small caps) in search of higher returns.

This explains the phenomenal rise in the stock prices of small cap stocks, which, in most cases is not backed by earnings recovery. With excess money being diverted to this space, most small cap stocks - the good, bad and ugly - are trading far above their intrinsic values.

For retail investors in the small cap space, this has led to (unjustified) high returns (stock performance) in the small cap space. Small cap multibaggers have been all over the news (it's a different matter that these gains are on a slippery terrain).

On the flipside, it has also made small caps less attractive for serious long-term value investors.

Because of huge liquidity, small cap valuations have soared.

Fresh buying opportunities are almost non-existent, especially in quality small caps. If at all there are buying opportunities, the upside has shrunk.

But all this is going to change for the better. And you can thank the market regulator for that.

A few months ago, the market regulator came up with reclassification norms and minimum investment requirements that will force restructuring in the mutual funds' (MF) portfolio.

In October 2017, the regulator issued a circular directing MFs to group their equity schemes under large, mid, and small-caps, based on market capitalisation of the stocks the scheme has invested.

Here is how the regulator has reclassified the space:

  • Large Cap: 1st -100th company in terms of full market capitalization.
  • Mid Cap: 101st -250th company in terms of full market capitalization.
  • Small Cap: 251st company onwards in terms of full market capitalization.

Coming to investment requirements for MFs...

  • An equity large-cap fund will have at least 80 % large-cap stocks (top 100 companies in terms of market capitalisation).
  • Mid-cap fund will have at least 65 % investment in mid-cap stocks (ranked between 100 and 250 in market-cap), and
  • Small-caps would cover all other companies.

With this move, the regulator aims to bring uniformity and transparency across various MF schemes. It will indeed help a common investor understand and compare the schemes better, and make the decision to choose a particular scheme simpler.

But a lot of mutual fund managers are not happy.

Over and above the existing pressure to perform, new norms would lead to unwarranted churn in the portfolio. Not to mention rebalancing every six months (depending on shifting market caps), and higher transaction costs. They may even have to cut down the number of schemes. That's because no asset management company can have more than one fund per category.

As mutual funds gear up to be compliant and restructure portfolios, there is likely to be a considerable selling in the small cap space. As per the industry experts, around 44% of MF schemes are likely to readjust portfolios to comply with new norms.

Further, the churning of portfolio is expected to lead to an investment of about Rs 190 billion in mid-cap stocks, at the cost of large- and small-caps.

And that's something to celebrate.

Reason - such selling is likely to bring some quality small caps in the buy zone.

That's an opportunity we have been eagerly waiting for, to come up with even more actionable recommendations on solid small caps.

That said, bear in mind that there could be a period of short term volatility where stock prices correct in small caps. The best way to sail through this period will be knowing your companies and the managements very well, so that you do not press the panic button at a time when you should be buying more.

Richa Agarwal
Richa Agarwal (Research Analyst)
Editor, Hidden Treasure

PS: In a time when most small caps are too overvalued to even think about, Richa Agarwal, a leader in the small cap space, has a few recommendations you should still make part of your portfolio today. Get access to them now by subscribing here.

Recent Articles

Smallcap Index up 150%! Here's Why I Believe There's More Steam Left May 11, 2021
As much as I'm excited of the select opportunities in the smallcap space, I would like to warn you about the potential pitfalls.
What's Your Exit Plan if there is a Big Crash in the Market? May 10, 2021
If there is a big crash in the market, what will you do with your stocks?
The Key to Profit from India's EV Revolution May 7, 2021
Stocks you must consider investing in before buying your first electric vehicle.
Are the Stock Markets Deaf to Covid Agony? May 6, 2021
Why are markets discounting the economic impact of Covid?

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "This Mutual Fund Rule Could Make Small Caps Profitable Again!". Click here!

2 Responses to "This Mutual Fund Rule Could Make Small Caps Profitable Again!"

Harish Priyani

May 4, 2018

Where can we get a list of Large Cap, Mid Cap and Small Cap companies available at one place? Further it is stated that MF's have to rebalance their portfolios to comply half yearly? Which are the two dates are which compliance will be checked ? Is it 1st April and 1st October ?

Like (2)

Ganapathy Sastri

May 4, 2018

The classification should have been done with some overlap among the three caps. For example this would have given some flexibility to each of the three caps:

Large Cap: 1st -120th company in terms of full market capitalization.
Mid Cap: 101st -350th company in terms of full market capitalization.
Small Cap: 251st company onwards in terms of full market capitalization.
Also I hope regulator has given reasonably long rope in eliminating stocks that do not meet the criteria to be in that cap.

Like (3)
Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "This Mutual Fund Rule Could Make Small Caps Profitable Again!". Click here!