Why I Haven't Recommended Any Adani Group Stock Yet

Jun 23, 2021

Rahul Shah, Editor, Profit Hunter

Adani group stocks have had a fantastic run over the last 12-15 months.

Just to put things in perspective, leave aside the current controversies for a minute and consider this...

Even the worst performing Adani group stock - Adani Ports - has done better than the BSE Small cap index, the best performing benchmark.

Adani Ports is up 180% since March 2020 lows as compared to 160% gains achieved by BSE Small Cap.

Also, the best performing group company - Adani Total Gas Ltd - has managed to do in 1 year what the Sensex can perhaps achieve in 20.

Even after the recent correction, the stock is up an incredible 14.6x since the lows of March 2020.

Other group companies have also done well. Adani Enterprises, Adani Power and Adani Transmission, have all seen their market values go up by 10.8x, 4.1x, and 6.5x, respectively.

--- Advertisement ---
Replay Available: Super Smallcaps Summit

Today, we went LIVE with Richa Agarwal's Super Smallcaps Summit.

Richa revealed details about the 3 'dark horse' stocks that could potentially hand you hundreds or even thousands of percent in gains over the long term.

However, you missed the Exclusive event for some reason.

And because we don't want you to miss out on this rare opportunity, we have a replay of the event arranged for you.

Click the link below to watch the replay now.

Watch the Replay

or click here to read the transcript
------------------------------

Little wonder, the Adanis are now among the richest people in the world.

I have chosen to stay out of this wealth creation opportunity though.

I haven't recommended a single Adani company to my clients since this big market rebound.

The reason for this is in the table below.

Adani Group: Is the Hype Justified?

Parameters Adani Enterprises Adani Ports Adani Power Adani Total Gas Adani Transmission
Earnings Trend (Rs/share)          
FY14EPS 20.2 8.4 -0.7 1.9 -
FY15EPS 17.7 11.2 -2.8 3.7 -0.1
FY16EPS 9.2 14.0 1.7 3.2 3.3
FY17EPS 9.0 18.9 -16.0 3.9 3.8
FY18EPS 6.9 17.7 -5.5 6.3 10.4
FY19EPS 6.5 19.3 -2.6 2.1 5.1
Valuation ratios          
Earnings Yield (%, based on avg EPS betn FY14 & FY19) 8.4% 5.9% n.a. 4.1% 2.0%
PBV ratio (x, 31 Mar 2020) 4.0 2.6 1.5 6.4 13.6
Business Quality          
Avg ROE (%, last 5 years) 4.1 20.1 -108.7 20.1 18.7
Avg D/E (x, last 5 years) 1.1 1.3 -27.4 0.7 3.7
Source: ACE Equity, Equitymaster

You see, just as a bond has a coupon and a fixed deposit has an interest rate, a stock has an earnings yield (inverse of the PE ratio).

An earnings yield of 6% means that the company has an EPS of Rs 6 per share and is trading at Rs 100 in the stock market.

Now, you want your earnings yield to be at least equal to that of fixed deposits or bonds if not more.

I normally prefer an earnings yield that's at least 50% higher than fixed deposits. So, if fixed deposits pay 6% interest, I want the earnings yield to be at least 9% if not more.

WATCH NOW: 3 Super Smallcap Stocks You Don't Want to Miss Out On

It's important to base your earnings yield on average EPS over the last few years than a single year.

Average earnings over multiple years is a better representation of the true earnings potential of the company.

This way, I am protected with a margin of safety. So, even if a company records a 20%-25% fall in earnings, my earnings yield is still equal to or slightly greater than the yield on fixed deposits.

If you look at the table, only Adani Enterprises had earnings yield significantly greater than the 6% fixed deposits that banks are giving these days.

Its earnings yield stood at 8.4% based on the average EPS of the last 6 years.

All the other companies had yields significantly lower than the interest rate they were getting on competing asset class i.e. fixed deposits.

However, I wasn't quite happy with the business quality of Adani Enterprises.

Its average return on equity was a poor 4% for the last 5 years and it also had debt that was higher than equity on an average.

You see, I don't want my companies to earn a return on equity (ROE) of 35%-40% on a consistent basis. Very few companies are capable of doing that.

--- Advertisement ---
Electric Vehicles - Introducing Equitymaster's Latest Research Project

Over the last several years, a secret project has been underway at Equitymaster.

It's been a massive undertaking with some of our best research analysts devoted to it.

Collectively, hundreds of manhours have been invested in it.

And this project has revealed some shocking truths...

Despite estimated 15-times growth in just 10 years, the ordinary approach of tapping into EV opportunity may turn out to be a disaster.

Before you invest a single rupee in any EV stock, we recommend you study the results of our latest research project...

Just click here to get the details
------------------------------

For me, even a consistent ROE of 12%-15% just fine provided it's accompanied with low debt on the balance sheet. The debt to equity ratio should always be less than one.

Therefore, I go further with my analysis and try to dig deeper into the stock only if all the three conditions are met i.e. a good earnings yield, a reasonable return on equity and a conservative balance sheet.

None of the Adani group companies seem to meet all three of these conditions back in March 2020.

All the Adani group companies failed my valuation as well as business quality parameters back in March 2020.

So I decided against recommending them to my subscribers.

It can very well be argued that companies are valued based on the earnings they will generate in the future.

The reason the investors are so gung-ho about these companies is because all of them have a very bright future.

Well, that's a game that I don't prefer playing.

I like to recommend companies where I am getting enough bang for my buck right from day one. I want to see the companies maintain at least their historical earnings power if not exceed it.

However, these attributes seemed to be absent in the case of Adani group companies. I was being asked to shell out a hefty premium for earnings that these companies were likely to earn in the future.

And I wasn't comfortable with that.

These companies did not fit my circle of competence as Warren Buffett likes to call it. Therefore, I decided to give them a miss.

This doesn't mean I won't recommend these stocks at all. I certainly won't mind recommending them in the future provided they fulfil all the criteria I have laid out.

It's just that they don't seem to be doing so at the moment.

What do you think? Do you agree with me or do you believe there's a strong argument to be made in favour of investing in these stocks?

Let me know.

Warm regards,

Rahul Shah
Rahul Shah
Editor and Research Analyst, Profit Hunter

Recent Articles

The Magic Formula to Pick the Best Real Estate Stock September 27, 2021
The formula for investing in a fundamentally strong real estate stock at attractive valuations.
The Real Wealth in Electric Vehicles September 24, 2021
In India's EV megatrend you must carefully select the right stocks to create massive wealth.
Buy Better Stocks than Zee Entertainment September 23, 2021
To find the big profit opportunities in the market look beyond what media is serving you.
EVs Will Change the Fortunes of this 3% Return Sector September 22, 2021
Companies across industries are pouring in billions into this sector.

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Why I Haven't Recommended Any Adani Group Stock Yet". Click here!

21 Responses to "Why I Haven't Recommended Any Adani Group Stock Yet"

Virat Trivedi

Jun 23, 2021

100% agree & no regrets!
Thanks for analysis, though!

Like 

SANKARAN VENKATARAMAN

Jun 23, 2021

What Rahul Shah says is absolutely correct. But in the new service FOREVER STOCKS, most cos have high PE (certain cos. have PE close to 100) . I pointed out this and got reply Noted

Like (2)

Terence M Fernandes

Jun 23, 2021

Good Analysis for value investing

Like (2)

M V Lakshma Reddy

Jun 23, 2021

Agree

Like (2)

Radhakrishnan

Jun 23, 2021

Quality of management matters a lot You shouldn't chew more than you can swallow.Many have this opinion on RIL also.But to our dismay these companies creat maximum wealth in the shorterm.

Like (1)

GS Khandelwal

Jun 23, 2021

I am absolutely agree with your approach Mr. Rahul Shah. There is no fundamental match with financial numbers / performance with share price of the companies.

Like (1)

Rajendran

Jun 23, 2021

I completely agree with you Rahul. That's why I'm comfortable and safe in investing in Double Income. I am very happy with its performance

Like (1)

bhushan oke

Jun 23, 2021

I agree completely. However all stocks are not so straightforward cases. For growth stocks, valuations, particularly earnings yield, are disregarded if the other financials are good. Again the perceptions of growth can differ. For example, Equitymaster gave a sell call for Persistent at Rs 1300 when the PE crossed 32. The stock is quoting at Rs. 2500 now. The PE has not gone up so much and is at 44 due to enhanced earnings. On the other hand Equitymaster asked not to sell Tata Elxsi even at a PE of 62 based on expected future growth. One must consider that the growth forecasts can go wrong drastically and one may repent later not taking money off the table. It is indeed very difficult to do nothing through cycles of low and high valuations.

Like (3)

Puneet Duneja

Jun 23, 2021

I agree .

Like (3)

N N Kumar

Jun 23, 2021

Dear Mr Shah,
Agree with your logic and analysis.
Your posts are always educative and recommendations prudent.
In one or two cases while you recommend a buy another analyst recommend sell. The stock in point is Castrol.
Thank you.
Regards.
N N Kumar

Like (3)
<<Prev    Next>>
Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Why I Haven't Recommended Any Adani Group Stock Yet". Click here!