Helping You Build Wealth With Honest Research
Since 1996. Read On...

The Long View

You have 12 funds. You have one diversification risk.

Open your mutual fund portfolio. You have 12 funds. Generally, Large cap fund, Flexi cap fund, ELSS for tax saving, Small cap fund because your friend said it could double. Focused fund, Blue-chip fund, Value fund, Balanced Advantage fund and even thematic fund such as manufacturing fund.

It feels good. You feel safe. You feel you have diversified. The reality is different.

You probably own the same Bank 10 times or a petro chemical giant in around 8 of them. In case of a popular small to mid-cap name, it is perfectly possible that you own it in all 12

We have 61 AMCs, 683 equity schemes (Source: ACE MF. as of September 2026) and effectively 250 stocks which are liquid particularly as the AUM of the scheme increases. The schemes outnumber the stocks by more than two to one. While the number of listed stocks are around 6,807 (Source: CMIE September, 2026), the top 250 are considered more liquid based on a decent daily trading volume. Not having enough investable stocks to invest but continuous inflow of AUM creates another kind risk which we will talk about some other day.,

Take any 5 large or flexi-cap funds and you will find:

The same names, just shuffled in order. The overlap between two top flexi-cap funds is generally around 70-80%. You are not buying a new fund. You are buying the same stocks at a new NAV.

Why does this happen?

Because the fund manager is not incentivized to be different. He is incentivized to not be wrong.

If he underperforms the Nifty for 2 quarters, you will redeem or he will be intensely questioned by his board. So, he hugs the index or a few names. The result is the same fifty names, across hundreds of schemes. The advisor recommending those funds has a different incentive. More funds means more transactions. But the portfolio underneath stays largely the same.

So, what does real diversification look like? It is not 12 or more funds. It is 4 different kinds of potential return engines.


1. Asset Diversification, Not Scheme Diversification.

Real diversification is owning different assets that respond to different economic scenarios

If you own 12 equity funds, you own one asset class: Indian equity risk. When Nifty falls 20%, mostly all 12 fall around 18-22%. That is not diversification. That is duplication.

Real diversification may be:

  • 30% to 60% Indian equities for growth- this in turn diversified across styles e.g. growth vs value or one well researched large or mid cap fund and a smaller portion in small cap- assuming your risk appetite is moderate
  • 15%- 20% to international equities - because a large part of the global opportunity set lies outside India
  • A certain portion to below avenues could be considered
    • Debt / Arbitrage seeking relative stability
    • Gold - because when war or inflation hits, equity doesn't save you
    • Real economy assets - REITs, InvITs, quality private credit

You need assets that don't move together.


2. A real diversified portfolio has:

Within equity itself, not all stocks behave the same way.

  • Large cap seek for potential stability
  • Mid cap for potential of earnings growth
  • Small and micro cap for scarcity - companies that have no competition


3. Style and Time Diversification.

This is the most ignored.

Most funds are long-only, buy and hold, growth style. They all buy what is going up.

Real diversification needs opposing styles:

Example: -

  • A value fund that buys what no one wants
  • A contrarian fund that buys when others sell
  • A growth fund that has a philosophy of investing in stocks even at expensive valuations as long as there is robust growth

And time diversification: Some money should be in assets that compound in 10 years or more - e.g. equity. Some could be in assets like REITs and InvITs that distribute income at regular intervals. Your 12 funds may take many years to blossom, but real life needs cash every 30 days.

(The above asset allocation and portfolio diversification is provided solely for illustration and understanding purpose only and should not be construed as an investment advice or a recommendation. Any investment decision should be based on individual objectives, risk tolerance and investment horizon.)


4. Manager Diversification

A deeper look also reveals a fourth problem: manager diversification.

You don't need 12 managers who think alike or scout for names in the same pool.

You need 3-4 managers with completely different DNA:

  • One who is a deep fundamentalist
  • One who is a quant / data-driven
  • One who understands the small cap space well

If your managers all look and think alike, you are not diversified.

So how do you fix it. You could start by asking your advisor the hard questions - what is actually different between these funds, and why do I own each one? Or you could work with a portfolio manager to build a portfolio that is truly diversified from the ground up.

Aim to go from 12 funds with 1 risk to probably 6 funds with different 5 risks. Your portfolio will become boring. And boring is what will take you towards your goals.

Because true diversification is not when everything goes up together.

True diversification is when something is always going up while something else is going down. That is what lets you sleep and stay invested.

Not available for investors in U.S.A., Canada, countries forming part of the European Economic Area (EEA), U.K., Switzerland, Australia.

From Equitymaster · Partner content

The same process.
Now managing your family's wealth directly.

For families with ₹1 Crore or more in investable surplus. 35 years of Quantum research discipline applied personally to your portfolio. Nitasha Shankar responds personally.

Learn More →

Disclaimer: This communication contains references to portfolio management services offering of Quantum Advisors Private Limited, an affiliated entity of Quantum Information Services Private Limited.

Disclaimer: This article is for information purposes only. It is not a recommendation and should not be treated as such.

  • The views expressed herein constitute only the opinion and do not constitute any guidelines or recommendation on any course of action to be followed by the viewer. This is not meant to serve as professional guide.
  • Investments in securities market is subject to market risks. Readers are advised to seek independent professional advise and read the offering documents carefully before making any investment decision. Past performance is no guarantee or assurance of future results. This should not be construed as recommendation to buy or sell in any sector/ stock or mutual fund.
  • Quantum Advisors Private Limited (QAPL), a SEBI registered Portfolio Manager and Quantum Information Services Private Limited (QIS), a SEBI registered Research Analyst are affiliated entities. These entities are functionally and operationally independent of each other and are governed by their respective regulations.
  • QAPL has its own inhouse research and investment team for all its strategy offerings. QAPL seeks "Research Inputs" or "Research Services" of non-binding nature from QIS with respect to mutual funds and equity stocks and also marketing and promotion services for one of its strategy offerings viz., Quantum OCIO Strategy. Towards these services, QAPL pays QIS a composite compensation that is linked to the management / advisory fees earned by Quantum Advisors from the assets managed or advised under the OCIO strategy, and the same is paid out of the management / advisory fees that QAPL receives from its clients under the OCIO Strategy.

I.V. Subramaniam

I.V.Subramaniam, known as Subbu, has managed India-focused portfolios at Quantum Advisors for over two decades, for domestic investors and some of the world's largest institutional clients. He brings 33 years of market experience to every investment decision.

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "You have 12 funds. You have one diversification risk.". Click here!