Free Reports

Why Public Sector Companies Have Made Losses of More Than Rs 1 Lakh Crore

Mar 10, 2016


Buried in the inside pages of the Economic Survey of 2015-2016 released on February 26, 2016, is a very interesting data point.

The accumulated losses of sick public sector enterprises as of March 31, 2014, stood at Rs 1.04 lakh crore. This essentially means that the government of India has pumped a lot of money into these companies over the years to keep them going.

The Survey does not point out whether the accumulated loss number of Rs 1.04 lakh crore takes the time value of money into account. What is the time value of money? Let's say 10 years back the public sector enterprises made a loss of Rs 2,000 crore. The government took on this loss and compensated them for it. The value of the Rs 2000 crore the government handed over to these loss making enterprises, ten years later, would be much greater than Rs 2,000 crore. (This example is for illustrative purpose only).

My guess is that the loss number of Rs 1.04 lakh crore does not take the time value of money into account. If it had, the loss number would have been much higher. The question is why have the public sector enterprises lost so much money over the years?

Charles Wheelan has the answer in Naked Economics - Undressing the Dismal Science. He gives the example of Hindustan Fertilizer Corporation. As he writes: "By 1991, the Hindustan Fertilizer Corporation had been up and running for twelve years. Every day, twelve hundred employees reported to work with the avowed goal of producing fertilizer. There was just one small complication. The plant had never actually produced any saleable fertilizer. None. Government bureaucrats ran the plant using public funds; the machinery that was installed never worked properly."

Further, the workers came in every day and the government kept paying their salaries. As Wheelan writes: "The entire enterprise was an industrial charade. It limped along because there was no mechanism to force it to shut down. When the government is bankrolling the business, there is no need to produce something and then sell it for more than what it cost to make."

 Modi 2016: An Agenda For Revival
 The Modi Report The landslide victory of 2014 handed Modi more than just a clear mandate...It handed him immense responsibility of a nation dreaming of great progress.

From the euphoria of Achche Din the mood in India has swung to cautious disappointment and now we are in 2016...

Who will answer the question how Modi can turn this ship around and get India back on track?

Vivek Kaul has the answer and he has put it all down, along with his deepest thoughts on the challenges India faces, in our latest special report titled - Modi 2016 - An Agenda For Revival.

And the best part is that he wants to give you this special report for free!

So, don't delay...Click here to download this special report right away!

If the government keeps making up for the losses of any company, what incentive do the management and the employees have to turn it around? None. A good comparison here are the public sector banks, in which the government has infused Rs 1.02 lakh crore of capital between 2009 and September 2015.

There is another point that needs to be made here. Up until the 1990s when the government ran most businesses in the country, the smartest lot either left the country or worked for the government.

As the economy opened up 1991 onwards, people started looking at other options as the number of jobs offered by the private sector in sectors as diverse as banking to telecom, exploded. The private sector also offered extra incentives to their best performers. The government meanwhile continued follow a uniform pay scale.

As Wheelan writes: "This uniform pay scale creates a set of incentives the economists refer to as adverse selection." What does the term mean in this context? The most talented professionals who earlier worked for the government now had the option for working for the private sector where there pay was closely linked to their productivity unlike the government.

On the flip side, as Wheelan puts it "for the least talented, the incentives are just the opposite." They know that working for the government would mean a fixed salary and regular increments over the years, which will not 'really' depend on their performance.

Hence, those who have ended up working for the government over the last couple of decades where definitely not the best of the lot.

The fact that the government has been ready to bailout the loss making public sector enterprises and the best people don't work for it anymore, has led to a situation where the losses have just kept piling up.

In sectors where the private sector has been allowed entry it has flourished and the government companies have had to take a backseat. As the Economic Survey points out: "The Indian aviation and telecommunication sectors of today are unrecognizably different from what they were 20 years ago, with enormous benefits for the citizens. Public sector companies now account for a small share of the overall size of these sectors."

Despite, the public sector enterprises being a small insignificant part of many sectors and with many of these companies making losses, the government continues to operate them and take on their losses. A major reason remains the fear of taking on the trade unions.

In fact, many of these loss making companies own large tracts of land and can be a huge revenue spinner for the government. As the Economic Survey points out: "Most public sector firms occupy relatively large tracts of land in desirable locations. Parts of this land can be converted into land banks and made into vehicles for promoting the 'Make in India' and Smart City campaigns. If the land is in dense urban areas, it could be used to develop eco-systems to nurture start-ups and if located in smaller towns and cities, it could be used to develop sites for industrial clusters."

I hope the government shuts down these loss making companies and starts selling the large tracts of land that they own.

Postscript: In a major embarrassment to the Modi government, the opposition parties got an amendment passed to the President's most recent address to the Parliament. How is this significant? In yesterday's column I had discussed how the Modi government continues to be precariously placed in the Rajya Sabha. And given this I don't see it getting the Goods and Services Tax Bill passed through the Rajya Sabha.

Morgan Stanley in a recent research note had claimed otherwise. They had said by July 2016, the BJP led NDA government should be in a position to get the GST Bill passed. Nevertheless, the point is that if the government cannot get even the President's address passed through the Rajya Sabha without an amendment, where is the question of it getting the GST Bill passed? Maybe Morgan Stanley can possibly explain that to us.

Vivek Kaul is the Editor of the Diary and The Vivek Kaul Letter. Vivek is a writer who has worked at senior positions with the Daily News and Analysis (DNA) and The Economic Times, in the past. He is the author of the Easy Money trilogy. The latest book in the trilogy Easy Money: The Greatest Ponzi Scheme Ever and How It Is Set to Destroy the Global Financial System was published in March 2015. The books were bestsellers on Amazon. His writing has also appeared in The Times of India, The Hindu, The Hindu Business Line, Business World, Business Today, India Today, Business Standard, Forbes India, Deccan Chronicle, The Asian Age, Mutual Fund Insight, Wealth Insight, Swarajya, Bangalore Mirror among others.

Disclaimer: The views mentioned above are of the author only. Data and charts, if used, in the article have been sourced from available information and have not been authenticated by any statutory authority. The author and Equitymaster do not claim it to be accurate nor accept any responsibility for the same. The views constitute only the opinions and do not constitute any guidelines or recommendation on any course of action to be followed by the reader. Please read the detailed Terms of Use of the web site.

Recent Articles

The Great Leader Has Won the Cow-Teller Award and Now Wants a Case Study January 17, 2019
This is a spoof.
Mohammed "Munna" Aziz and the Summer of 1989 November 28, 2018
Vivek reminisces a nearly three decade-old summer, spent listening to a Hindi film song.
I'm Looking for Companies Not Influenced by Farm Loan Waivers and Minimum Support Prices November 16, 2018
Are there any good companies in the agrochemical space worth looking at?
Should You Abandon Your Investment Strategy in This Falling Market? November 2, 2018
It is in these volatile times, when investors' mettle is tested the most...

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Why Public Sector Companies Have Made Losses of More Than Rs 1 Lakh Crore". Click here!

7 Responses to "Why Public Sector Companies Have Made Losses of More Than Rs 1 Lakh Crore"

satish babu s

Oct 5, 2016

i watched HMT MACHINE TOOS AND HMT WATCH FACTORY in bangalore from a close range for a long time. my understanding is that it is the bad management, political interference, nepotism and corruption that are responsible for the huge losses. the working class has always been hard working. according to a survey even the Mysore Lamps was shut down due to mismanagement for years. what ever is the reason it is finally the working class which has to suffer. this is the criminal joke in this so called largest democracy.



Mar 10, 2016

Mallayya incurred losses and left.How about organisations?
Surprised by national fertilisers issue.
Many more govt. Coys.and defence units/projects may be
In same situation.
More on this is welcome.
What constructive action plan
do you have to make govt.accountable?


gopaldas agrawal

Mar 10, 2016

Everyone loves his child much more than some other child.So the cooperative and Public Sector have virtually failed as they are Big White Elephant where near aand dear of govt or politicians enjoy life at the cost of exchequer.Govt job is not to do business but can act as a facilitator in doing business and its the duty of business man to do business and govt duty is to rule the nation and protect its people and its property from insider and external intruders and see that the rule of law is maintained in our nation.Govt doing busines is like a carpenter doing the job of mason and if he do he will certainly do mistakes and blunders.


Penugonda Prabhakar

Mar 10, 2016

Iam Penugonda Prabhakar How to came in Public sector bank one lakh crore loss. Agora consider in banks. In banks will com interest but how to came losses. Banks doing business in interest others taken. How to losses. All files consider Agora Research.

Yours Loving


Balakrishnan R

Mar 10, 2016

Dear Mr. Vivek,
The present central government, instead of co-working with the opposition, it is attacking them. In such a situation, how anything will be passed.


R Biswas

Mar 10, 2016

I completely disagree with you when you say and I quote "Hence, those who have ended up working for the government over the last couple of decades where definitely not the best of the lot". This shows that you have 30,000 feet from ground kind of view and completely detached with the ground realities. There are many (and I repeat many) that I myself personally aware of where so many talented people are still in government services inspite of all the lures of the private sector because they are completely aware of the fallacy of private sectors. How could you have the impression that it is all rosy in private sector ? Have you ever heard of a term called hire & fire ? In spite of putting everything in your contributions, you are simply fired because you are not part of the coterie ? Mr Kaul, I'm an ardent follower of your writings and bought & gone thro' your Easy Money trilogy even before many people were even aware of them, but of late I can see lot of views in your writing which can't be claimed to be impartial. Hope you would have a think thro'

Like (2)

Carlos de Souza

Mar 10, 2016

Excellent article by Vivek Kaul, as usual. Unbiased, hard hitting, objective, courageous.

Vivek is a rare gem as far as EquityMaster is concerned. Retain him as long as you can.

Like (2)
Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Why Public Sector Companies Have Made Losses of More Than Rs 1 Lakh Crore". Click here!