Zomato: Worth a Bite?

Jul 15, 2021

13,214% return.

That's the number which flashes on your screen when you do a simple google search on 'Infosys share performance since listing'.

However the relevant question for me is this...

How many people could abandon their traditional thought process of investing in old economy stocks and bet on a group of young friends who quit their jobs to start a software company?

Words like 'Software', 'Outsourcing' was alien language to a majority of the baniya's on Dalal Street who were obsessed with old economy companies like cement manufacturers and textile companies in the 90s.

The traditional old economy valuation methods were incapable of valuing a company in a new industry.

To add to this, the fear in the Indian stock market during 1993 was at its peak as Bombay was hit with multiple bomb blasts.

The result?

--- Advertisement ---
Govt's 257 Bn Rupees Boost for EVs- Your Chance for Potentially Wild Profits

A few days back, the government announced that it will be pumping a whopping 257 billion rupees into electric vehicle initiatives by 2025.

We urge you to become a part of the EV gold rush that's happening now and gain the early mover advantage.

We have closed in on 3 EV stocks which could potentially hand you over insane profits in the long run.

We will be revealing all the details in one of our upcoming special online event.

Sign Me Up For the FREE Event
------------------------------

Infosys IPO was undersubscribed. Morgan Stanley had to bail them out by picking a 13% stake at Rs 95/share. It's only in hindsight that words like multibagger and wealth creator were associated with Infosys.

Why am I telling you this today?

This story is so close to my heart because Infosys changed my family's fortunes.

Back those days, my father, a practising Chartered Accountant, was always inclined to make a career in the stock market. However, the investing environment during the early part of 1990's was uncertain.

Today, there is massive data and research available to everyone. It wasn't the case then.

He saw an opportunity.

Being a Chartered Accountant, reading balance sheets was his forte. However, he had to tweak his skills from a post mortem analysis required in auditing, to a diagnosis based approach.

Just like many people, he overlooked Infosys as a 'fad' or a passing trend. This led to him building an old economy portfolio.

In fact, till 1994, the narrative was that Infosys was too expensive. After all, it traded at PE multiple of 100.

However, as fate would have it, a casual interaction with a friend who resided in Bangalore and knew the management, changed his views completely. The departure from typical valuation metrics to industry opportunity was the deciding factor.

Learn: How to Potentially Accumulate Rs 7 Crore in Wealth Over the Long-term

After months of reading about the sector and the companies in it, he finally developed the conviction to invest. He was convinced in Indian Information Technology and Infosys as a company.

In stock market, conviction is one thing but taking a sizeable bet on a conviction is vital.

He sold his entire portfolio of old economy stocks and invested in IT stocks. These stocks accounted for 80% of his portfolio during 1995-2000.

As they say, the rest is history.

These days, a lot is being spoken about valuing the so call 'new generation business' which have been in existence for barely a decade.

The street is divided on what valuation methods to assign to them. They have carved out an industry in itself - Platform Business.

Take Zomato for example. Its IPO is currently open for subscription.

The management of Zomato acknowledges the fact that discounts are an important part of the business strategy and is likely to continue.

The naysayers have their arguments ready. How can a loss-making business with no time line for profit, be valued?

Also isn't it magical that Zomato's valuations have gone up 75% in 4 months from US$5.2 bn to US$9 bn i.e. the IPO valuation.

--- Advertisement ---
Meet Rajeev Thakkar: The Man Who Introduced Us Indians to Global Stocks...

Rajeev Thakkar is A Successful Stock Market Investor and CIO of a Top-Ranked Mutual Fund...

He is also among a few rare Indian mutual fund managers who invest not just in Indian stocks...BUT STOCKS ACROSS THE WORLD.

And his keen eye for hunting out undervalued companies by employing a disciplined approach has been instrumental in his fund's stellar performance.

... Thanks to a new approach he developed: Value Investing 3.0

Find out how can you apply the principles of Value Investing 3.0 to protect or grow your wealth when you Register for The Equitymaster Conference Right Now
------------------------------

Let's look at the food delivery space...

This sector has been in existence for less than a decade. The opportunity here is massive but unknown. Covid has accelerated the industry's growth by at least 2-3 years.

With smart phones and internet penetration becoming 'necessities' the potential for food delivery business like Zomato and Swiggy to penetrate to rural India is massive.

Their ability to raise money so easily is a luxury which traditional business don't have.

Also, being a tech platform business, the scope of acquiring unrelated business and scaling them up presents additional opportunities.

So does this resemble the Infosys story?

In terms of the opportunity you bet it does.

IT sector back then was a completely new animal for investors. The opportunity was massive but unknown.

Very few people could have predicted the dominance of Indian IT companies in the global landscape.

The cost advantage which IT companies leveraged to grow can be compared to the ease of financing from VCs and private placements which these platform companies are blessed with.

So what do I think?

While the size of the opportunity for tech platform resembles the IT revolution, the most important element is missing - Profits.

Majority of IT companies were growing at a rapid pace but they had profitable growth.

Tech platforms however are loss making.

The loss is being funded by venture capitalists and private equity players. The hope is, going forward, they will go the Amazon way.

It took Amazon 10 years to generate its first profit.

Amazon kept growing in size both horizontally and vertically. It entered unrelated business and dominated them.

The challenge for Zomato and other new generation businesses is to do the same.

Warm regards,

Aditya Vora
Aditya Vora
Financial Writer

Recent Articles

How Many Stocks in Your Portfolio Can Go Down in 2022? December 6, 2021
Should you be prepared for some rough weather ahead?
Ride the EV Revolution with HDFC Bank December 3, 2021
Why should investors take it for granted that India's Tesla will be one of the major auto stocks?
Omicron: How to Position Your Portfolio December 2, 2021
Taking decisions based on speculative news is injurious to your portfolio.
Is this India's 'Reliance Power' Moment? Here's How to Prepare for it December 1, 2021
Investors forget that market cycles are inevitable and there's no such thing as a free lunch.

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Zomato: Worth a Bite?". Click here!

3 Responses to "Zomato: Worth a Bite?"

shanmugam raju

Jul 26, 2021

Dear Aditya
expected a more clearer reply, need a more clear picture in the future posts pl
Regards
Shan

Like 

Prashant M. Deshpande

Jul 19, 2021

Dear Aditya,
Thanks for the extremely cautious approach. The message is clear... Don't Buy... wait for 10 years!!
As we are talking about emerging/ new generation businesses, I would like to know about RJ's Nazara Technologies. I haven't seen/heard anyone in Equitymaster talking about it.
Regards,
Prashant

Like (1)

Rahul S Brahmachari

Jul 15, 2021

Dear Aditya,
I'm a tad bit disappointed as I've been expecting some assertion even if they need to be shrouded with statutory disclaimers and qualifiers like "Personal Belief".
It feels like the salt/sauce is missing.
Expecting a bit bolder approach in future.
All the best!
Cheers,
Rahul.

Like (1)
  
Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Zomato: Worth a Bite?". Click here!