Sign up for Equitymaster's free daily newsletter, The 5 Minute WrapUp and get access to our latest Multibagger guide (2017 Edition) on picking money-making stocks.

This is an entirely free service. No payments are to be made.

Download Now Subscribe to our free daily e-letter, The 5 Minute WrapUp and get this complimentary report.
We hate spam as much as you do. Check out our Privacy Policy and Terms Of Use.
Tax the foreigners. Then give us freedom. - Views on News from Equitymaster
  • E-MAIL
  • A  A  A
  • Apr 8, 2000

    Tax the foreigners. Then give us freedom.

    First, lets get some facts straight. As someone involved in the fund management business and advising a few Mauritius-based funds, my view is that the tax-man in India who gave a capital gains tax bill to a few fund managers has done the correct thing - legally.

    At the time of setting up Mauritius-based vehicles, a legal opinion presented to me clearly stated (unless age has killed my memory beyond repair) that: 1) it is okay to set up a Mauritius-based company to take advantage of the double taxation facilities, 2) but beware how that Mauritius arm deals with its Indian affiliate or related Indian entity - because the treaty classifies who does, and who does not, enjoy the benefit of the preferential tax treatment.

    And it was that "beware" which everyone ignored. The "beware" was this: If, for example, Fund ABC is set up in Mauritius and if Fund ABC has an Indian office called India ABC, then India ABC cannot make decisions on behalf of Fund ABC because then, under the terms of the treaty, Fund ABC will be assumed to be having an operation in India and would fall under Indian tax laws.

    However, India ABC could give advice to Fund ABC by sending Fund ABC recommendations, suggestions but could not decide for Fund ABC. Therefore, India ABC cannot call a broker and buy/sell shares on behalf of Fund ABC. So, those who followed the law made sure that India ABC only sent a recommendation to Fund ABC that it was advisable to buy shares of ACC, Birla, or whatever and made sure that Fund ABC then called the broker and placed the order to buy/sell shares directly. But instead of following the law, most India ABCs began to call brokers directly and gave instructions as if they were Fund ABC.

    If this distinction between an active and passive role is still one of the conditions of the treaty with Mauritius then, clearly, the tax man has done the right thing by serving notice on the India ABCs and the Fund ABCs to cough up a tax payment. I have not seen anything to suggest that this condition was waived in any amendments of the treaty since my last interaction with it in 1996.

    Now, having laid the facts on the table and complimenting the tax man for doing the right thing, letís get to the larger broader issue: what is this capital gains tax all about? And that is not an issue with the tax man but, really, with the Ministry of Finance. For years the foreigners have been saying that paying a tax on capital gains is downright silly. India is competing for capital and in a world with over 60 stock markets, being one of the few that charges some sort of tax on capital gains is reason enough to dissuade foreign money flows into India.

    But this "foreign" argument is not as solid as it sounds because:

    1. foreigners are no angels carrying money to give us for free, they want returns. Whether we have SEBI registrations, or no SEBI registrations, a US$ 10,000 charge for the registration or whether it is for free, if we have capital gains tax or not: if the foreign portfolio managers smell a chance to make money, they will invest in India. Zero capital gains tax will certainly make India a more attractive market but maintaining capital gains will not see the US$ 11.5 billion FII money declining to zero.
    2. foreigners pay capital gains tax in other countries: Australia, Poland, Spain and Thailand being some of them, though many foreign investors get exemptions or credits due to their status as a pension fund or due to a Double Taxation Agreement.

    The Ministry of Finance should do away with capital gains taxation not because the foreigners want it removed but, rather, because we Indians are fed up of capital gains tax and the material loss to the Ministry of Finance is, well, immaterial. By the time you add indexation and offsetting opportunities, the capital gains tax that the Ministry gets must be less than 1% of all tax revenues.

    But there is another reason to knock of capital gains tax: Create more business in India. At present, the Indo-Mauritius tax treaty probably supports about Rs 1 billion (US$ 23 million) of annual expenses on salaries, hotel expenses, and airline costs as every foreign company like Fund ABC has to have Mauritius-based accountants, lawyers, and board meetings! Let the foreign funds spend that money at the hotels in India (psst...buy Indian Hotels!) and on airlines, lawyers, and accountants in India (pssst...forget computer scientists, marry your daughter off to a CA.) And then there is the scandalous trading in GDRs that generates over Rs. 11 billion (US$ 250 million) in profits for foreign brokerage groups without giving a chance to the Indian brokers to compete for that GDR business. If capital gains tax is removed, then foreigners will be happy to buy local stocks and that will push that entire revenue stream into India.

    So, here is some advice for the Ministry of Finance: if Fund ABC and India ABC did something incorrect, punish them and collect a tax.

    Meanwhile, bite the bullet, and make all investments and transactions in shares of listed companies exempt from capital gains tax for resident Indians - and by the way, extend that facility to the foreign investors, too.



    Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Tax the foreigners. Then give us freedom.". Click here!


    More Views on News

    Insider Leaks Equitymaster Stock Picks (The 5 Minute Wrapup)

    Jul 25, 2017

    Equitymaster HQ has been infiltrated. Valuable stock ideas have been leaked. Who's responsible?

    Raymond and Other 'For Profit' Companies Who Don't Care about Shareholder Returns (The 5 Minute Wrapup)

    May 27, 2017

    What happens when minority shareholders are short-changed in the normal course of business?

    Why Commission Driven Model In Mutual Funds Should Be Eliminated... (Outside View)

    Feb 15, 2017

    PersonalFN believes SEBI has taken a step back-apparently in the admission of it going overboard with the regulations.

    This Book Changed How I Looked at the World of Man and Money (Vivek Kaul's Diary)

    Aug 24, 2016

    And here's your chance to claim a free copy of this book...

    The Developed World is Dying because of Demographics, Debt, and Deflation (Vivek Kaul's Diary)

    Aug 12, 2016

    And Why India's demographic dividend could turn out to be a doubtful debt...

    More Views on News

    Most Popular

    Demonetisation Barely Made Any Difference to Tax Collections(Vivek Kaul's Diary)

    Aug 7, 2017

    The data tells us quite a different story from the one the government is trying to project.

    A 'Backdoor' to Multibaggers: It's Like Investing in Asian Paints Ten Years Ago(The 5 Minute Wrapup)

    Aug 10, 2017

    Don't miss these proxy bets on growing companies or in a few years you will be looking back with regret.

    Should You Invest In Bharat-22 ETF? Know Here...(Outside View)

    Aug 8, 2017

    Bharat-22 is one of the most diverse ETFs offered so far by the Government. Know here if you should invest...

    Signs of Life in the India VIX(Daily Profit Hunter)

    Aug 12, 2017

    The India VIX is up 36% in the last week. Fear has gone up but is still low by historical standards.

    7 Financial Gifts For Your Sister This Raksha Bandhan(Outside View)

    Aug 7, 2017

    Raksha Bandhan signifies the brother-sister bond. Here are 7 thoughtful financial gifts for sisters...

    Copyright © Equitymaster Agora Research Private Limited. All rights reserved.
    Any act of copying, reproducing or distributing this newsletter whether wholly or in part, for any purpose without the permission of Equitymaster is strictly prohibited and shall be deemed to be copyright infringement.

    LEGAL DISCLAIMER: Equitymaster Agora Research Private Limited (hereinafter referred as 'Equitymaster') is an independent equity research Company. Equitymaster is not an Investment Adviser. Information herein should be regarded as a resource only and should be used at one's own risk. This is not an offer to sell or solicitation to buy any securities and Equitymaster will not be liable for any losses incurred or investment(s) made or decisions taken/or not taken based on the information provided herein. Information contained herein does not constitute investment advice or a personal recommendation or take into account the particular investment objectives, financial situations, or needs of individual subscribers. Before acting on any recommendation, subscribers should consider whether it is suitable for their particular circumstances and, if necessary, seek an independent professional advice. This is not directed for access or use by anyone in a country, especially, USA or Canada, where such use or access is unlawful or which may subject Equitymaster or its affiliates to any registration or licensing requirement. All content and information is provided on an 'As Is' basis by Equitymaster. Information herein is believed to be reliable but Equitymaster does not warrant its completeness or accuracy and expressly disclaims all warranties and conditions of any kind, whether express or implied. Equitymaster may hold shares in the company/ies discussed herein. As a condition to accessing Equitymaster content and website, you agree to our Terms and Conditions of Use, available here. The performance data quoted represents past performance and does not guarantee future results.

    SEBI (Research Analysts) Regulations 2014, Registration No. INH000000537.

    Equitymaster Agora Research Private Limited. 103, Regent Chambers, Above Status Restaurant, Nariman Point, Mumbai - 400 021. India.
    Telephone: +91-22-61434055. Fax: +91-22-22028550. Email: info@equitymaster.com. Website: www.equitymaster.com. CIN:U74999MH2007PTC175407

    Become A Smarter Investor In
    Just 5 Minutes

    Multibagger Stocks Guide 2017
    Get our special report, Multibagger Stocks Guide (2017 Edition) Now!
    We will never sell or rent your email id.
    Please read our Terms