Bharti vs. Idea: How the valuations stack up? - Views on News from Equitymaster

Helping You Build Wealth With Honest Research
Since 1996. Try Now

  • MyStocks


Login Failure
(Please do not use this option on a public machine)
  Sign Up | Forgot Password?  

Bharti vs. Idea: How the valuations stack up?

Apr 10, 2012

In our previous articles we went through the market share of Bharti and Idea and realized that Bharti is the undisputed market leader in the Indian mobile markets. In the next article we compared the operational numbers for both the companies. Here again Bharti has been leading in the numbers but Idea has been slowly and steadily narrowing the gap. In our final piece in the series, we would focus on the valuations and what the future holds for the two companiesLet's first see how the stock prices of the two companies have performed. Though Bharti Airtel has been around for a while, Idea Cellular came up with an IPO only in Mar-07. Therefore, our analysis would be done from Mar-07 onwards

Source: ACE Equity

Clearly, both Bharti as well as Idea have underperformed the broader markets from September 2009 to date. But the interesting thing to note here is that both stocks have pretty much moved in tandem with each other till recent times. Very recently, the stock of Idea has outperformed that of Bharti Airtel.

A major reason for this is the general negative sentiment surrounding the telecom sector and an even more pronounced negative sentiment surround the incumbent Bharti. As competition on the tariff front started to wane of, it severely hurt the prospects of the smaller companies which were competing purely on the price front and hence bleeding in their financials. At the same time, companies like Idea Cellular took a bold step to start increasing tariffs gradually. Despite this, the company's active subscriber base continued to expand. In fact, the company gained favorably on the MNP (Mobile Number Portability) front. By the end of FY12, the Supreme Court cancelled the 2G licenses of the new players. This again worked in the favour of Idea's stock price as it became one of the favoured ones to gain from the plight of the losing companies. Experts and investors expect the company to gain the subscriber shares from the companies whose licenses have been cancelled. Another aspect that worked in the favour of the company to some extent was the slower than expected turnaround in Bharti Airtel's African operations. As investors continued to grow wary of the incumbent, they started to focus more attention on the other listed player i.e. Idea Cellular. This has shown in the recent outperformance of the stock vis-a-vis the incumbent.However, it would be important to compare companies on the basis of their valuations.

Valuations BhartiIdea
Market capRs. M1,253,185330,388
Price to earnings*Times26.943.6
Price to book value*Times2.52.6
Price to sales*Times1.81.8
* Based on trailing 12 months' data  Prices as on April 4, 2012 Source: Company data

The valuations of Bharti Airtel are clearly more attractive than that of Idea Cellular.


Let us see how the two companies stack up in terms of their financials.

Growth BhartiIdea
Net Profits%10.5%15.7%
*CAGR growth from FY07 to FY11

Key Ratios BhartiIdea
Return on Equity%9.5%5.9%
Net Debt to EquityTimes1.51.0
* As on end of December 2011 Source: Company data

Though Idea has delivered superior growth numbers but when it comes to returns to the shareholders, Bharti emerges as a clear leader. But Bharti has much more debt on its books as compared to Idea. One of the reasons behind this is the acquisition made by the company in Africa. Despite the visible turnaround in operations, Africa business has not really panned out at the pace that the company had initially estimated. It is important to note that the company has plans to repay the debt through the internal accruals soon.

The path forward

Going forward, the future for both the companies is attractive. Though the growth in the Indian telecom sector may not be as spectacular as that seen in the past, but even then there is still plenty of steam left. Data services, value added products and 3G are expected to drive the next phase of growth for the sector. Both the companies have already launched their 3G services and have signed the roaming agreements with operators in circles where they do not have 3G spectrum. (Important to remember that these roaming agreements have been questioned by the telecom regulator).

For Bharti in particular, the African operations have started to yield positive results albeit at a slower pace than what was initially estimated by the management. At some point of time in the future, these operations would start to incrementally contribute towards the company's operations. Idea on the other hand has operations limited to the country. To that extent its growth would be decided by the fate of the overall sector.

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Bharti vs. Idea: How the valuations stack up?". Click here!

2 Responses to "Bharti vs. Idea: How the valuations stack up?"

george k mathew

Nov 5, 2012

Some of the recent study that came in the Business Line paper says Idea is better than Airtel in terms of growth. kindly comment


Pradeep Kumar Nair P

Apr 10, 2012

The chart on Financials is showing IDEA doing better, barring the RoE number, but your statement says Bharti has outperformed Idea!!!!!

Like (1)
Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Bharti vs. Idea: How the valuations stack up?". Click here!

More Views on News

BHARTI AIRTEL 2020-21 Annual Report Analysis (Annual Result Update)

Oct 20, 2021 | Updated on Oct 20, 2021

Here's an analysis of the annual report of BHARTI AIRTEL for 2020-21. It includes a full income statement, balance sheet and cash flow analysis of BHARTI AIRTEL. Also includes updates on the valuation of BHARTI AIRTEL.

Bharti Airtel's Humongous Rights Issue to Open on 5 October. Key Points Investors Should Know (Views On News)

Sep 23, 2021

Shares of Bharti Airtel trade near record high ahead of rights issue.

This Company has Quietly Built an Enviable Startup Portfolio (Views On News)

Sep 22, 2021

The startups era has just begun, and it will provide massive opportunities to those who can spot the right trends at the right time.

Top Stocks Riding the 5G Wave in India (Views On News)

Dec 3, 2021

The 5G revolution is unfolding at a faster rate than you would expect. Here's how you can hop on to this ride.

1,300% in One Year - Are You Kidding Me? (Views On News)

Nov 29, 2021

An amount of Rs 1 lakh invested in the midcap stock a year ago would have turned into Rs 15 lakh today.

More Views on News

Most Popular

Basics of Value Investing

Value investing is very simple in essence. But you need to know the rules of the game. Here are some interesting articles tha...

India's Best Semiconductor Stocks Views On News (Views On News)

Jan 7, 2022

Modern wars are fought with semiconductors. India's best semiconductor stocks have big tailwinds from defence and manufacturing.

10 Indian Companies with the Fastest Growth in Dividend Payouts... (Views On News)

Jan 10, 2022

These companies have been consistently paying higher dividends for several years.

Tata Steel vs SAIL: Which Stock is Better? (Views On News)

Jan 13, 2022

With government initiatives set to boost the steel sector, find out who has a better chance of coming out on top.

Looking for Consistent Compounding Stocks? Here's a Watchlist for You (Views On News)

Jan 6, 2022

These companies have generated mind boggling returns for investors over the years.


Become A Smarter Investor
In Just 5 Minutes

Multibagger Stock Guide 2022
Get our special report Multibagger Stocks Guide (2022 Edition) Now!
We will never sell or rent your email id.
Please read our Terms


Jan 18, 2022 (Close)


  • Track your investment in BHARTI AIRTEL with Equitymaster's Portfolio Tracker. Set live price alerts, get research alerts and more. Get access now...
  • Add To MyStocks