Investors make mistakes. Here's one... - Views on News from Equitymaster

Helping You Build Wealth With Honest Research
Since 1996. Try Now

  • MyStocks


Login Failure
(Please do not use this option on a public machine)
  Sign Up | Forgot Password?  

Investors make mistakes. Here's one...

Jun 22, 2009

It wouldn't be wrong to call Suzlon a baby of the bull market. The stock, subsequent to listing(October 2005), enjoyed some pretty euphoric valuations for the next two years. As can be seen from the chart, with an average P/E of about 40, Suzlon was a darling of the stock market during those two years of 2006 and 2007.

Source: Prowess
The reason? The company was growing, and growing fast. For the five years from FY02 to FY07, the company managed to grow its sales and profits at a scorching CAGR of 72% and 50% respectively. That was enough for Suzlon to garner a very strong fan following. With such a strong upward trend of earnings, people happily paid an average P/E of 40 for the stock during that period.

This 'upward trend of earnings' has been the nemesis of many a stock market investor. A good showing on this front for a period 5, 4 or even 3 years are many a times regarded as an assurance of uninterrupted future growth and a warrant for projecting the curve of profits indefinitely upward. Especially when the general stock market sentiment is positive. This rising trend of earnings is used as a reason to draw many positive conclusions about the company, thus fueling some very optimistic future projections.

But like Benjamin Graham has pointed out in the past, there lie some hidden but very real dangers in projecting such trends into the future. More specifically, there are several reasons why we cannot be sure that a trend of profits shown in the past will continue in the future. In the broad economic sense, there is the law of diminishing returns and of increasing competition which must finally flatten out any sharply upward curve of growth.

There is also the flow and ebb of the business cycle, from which the particular danger arises that the earnings curve will look most impressive on the very eve of a serious setback. And that was the exact case with Suzlon. The world was awash with liquidity during that time. Thus Suzlon, who's products (wind turbines) require heavy capital investments, found no dearth of ready customers. Similarly, due to the upturn of the business cycle, debt was easily available, and that too at attractive rates. This further, made it easy for the company to leverage itself to achieve even higher rates growth and returns.

This extremely favorable environment was perfect for Suzlon's aggressive decision making, and thus showed up very impressively on the company's numbers. As mentioned above, the earnings curve can look most impressive on the very eve of a serious setback. That's exactly what happened, and the subsequent crash in the stock's price was a very painful reminder of that very fact.

The above mentioned dangers in projecting trends into the future always exists. But it is just that during bull markets which extend for a number of years, the 'trend-of-earnings' phenomenon tends to become only a pretext to excuse mass speculation under the guise of 'investment'. Indeed, the profit-mad public becomes quite willing to accept the flimsiest evidence of the existence of a favorable trend, and project it indefinitely into the future. And as we all know, happy projections can lead to some very silly prices.

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Investors make mistakes. Here's one...". Click here!

13 Responses to "Investors make mistakes. Here's one..."


Dec 4, 2009



Dec 3, 2009



Nov 27, 2009



Nov 25, 2009



Nov 18, 2009



Oct 21, 2009



Sep 14, 2009


Shirish Joglekar

Jun 23, 2009

I agree with many of the comments posted. I find that many times, one EM article contradicts another written within a week or so. Seems like left hand doesn't know what right hand is doing. EM needs to remove these anomalies in their reports. Everybody who takes the risk of recommending a stock can make mistakes and EM is no exception! However, many times I like their contrarian views.


Bearish Bull

Jun 23, 2009

Hey, but the fact is that after Equitymaster's recommendation of Suzlon with a target of 404, the stock had in fact gone up to touch a high of nearly 460 before the fall!!


R Sathyamurthy

Jun 23, 2009

Yah! investors think that trends continue. But people who have read Ben Graham and worship Warren Buffet also forecast income and profits to grow continuously without interruption, in the research reports put out by them with a "Buy" recommendation.

Fact of the matter is that people can easily think about growth and upmoves, it is difficult to predict when the fall will come. That is why it is better to select a good stock and stick with it rather than buy and sell attitude which is often propagated - even at EquityMaster.

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Investors make mistakes. Here's one...". Click here!

More Views on News

How to Participate in India's Drone Revolution (Profit Hunter)

Oct 20, 2020

The Chinese drone market is 14 times that of India's. Billions may flow into Indian drone companies too. Don't miss out on this wealth creating opportunity.

Equity Mutual Fund Cut-Off Timing Restored. Find out What it Means for Investors (Outside View)

Oct 20, 2020

SEBI has restored the cut-off timing for subscription and redemption in mutual fund schemes with effect from October 19, 2020, except for debt and conservative hybrid schemes.

PSU Stocks Are Looking Positive Now (Fast Profits Daily)

Oct 19, 2020

Has the market changed its opinion on PSUs?

Will the Government's Attempt to Boost Consumption Succeed? (Outside View)

Oct 19, 2020

On October 12, 2020, the government came up with a stimulus package to give a boost to consumption which has taken a hit due to the COVID-19 pandemic.

I Trust Tanushree to Do a Jim Rogers and Unlock Huge Gains from Defence Stocks (Profit Hunter)

Oct 19, 2020

The set up that made Jim Rogers famous is now up for grabs in India.

More Views on News

Most Popular

Benjamin Graham Deep Value Stocks

The insights from a man who pioneered arguably the most successful form of investing there is.

My Latest Stock Recommendation (Fast Profits Daily)

Oct 9, 2020

How I picked an exciting stock using trends from both the commodity and equity markets.

The 'Seedhi Baat, No Bakwaas' View on ITC (Profit Hunter)

Oct 12, 2020

Is ITC an investment or a speculation at current levels?

How to Shortlist the Best Stocks for Trading (Fast Profits Daily)

Oct 7, 2020

In this video, I'll show you how to identify a confluence of factors in the market which will point you to the best stocks to trade.

The Inflection Point for Defence Stocks is Getting Closer (Profit Hunter)

Oct 9, 2020

Few Indian defence companies could use their engineering capabilities to eventually become global leaders.


Covid-19 Proof
Multibagger Stocks

Covid19 Proof Multibaggers
Get this special report, authored by Equitymaster's top analysts now!
We will never sell or rent your email id.
Please read our Terms


Oct 20, 2020 01:52 PM