Steel: Who's performed better? - Views on News from Equitymaster

Helping You Build Wealth With Honest Research
Since 1996. Try Now

  • MyStocks


Login Failure
(Please do not use this option on a public machine)
  Sign Up | Forgot Password?  

Steel: Who's performed better?

Aug 25, 2008

In last few articles, we have discussed the performance of P&L accounts and balance sheet of Tata Steel and SAIL . In this article, let us see how have the stock prices of these companies moved between the period 2003 and 2008 (till date) and compare them with each other in terms of returns. The chart below shows the returns the investor got from investing in the stocks of both the companies between the period 2003 and till date (Aug - 08).

We see from the graph that if one had invested Rs 100 in Tata Steel in Dec 2003, he would have earned returns at a CAGR of 17% while a similar investment in SAIL during the same period would have grown to Rs. 274, a CAGR in the region of 24%.

As we know, share prices are nothing but indicators of an investor's expectations of a company's future earnings. So if we see from the graph, investors expected both the companies to grow in a similar fashion till 2006. However, the period after that witnessed a sharp diversion in the share prices of both the companies with SAIL significantly outperforming its private sector counterpart. The strong spike in the share prices of SAIL from 2006 till 2007 was a result of its strong realizations and expansion plans to double its capacity. Moreover, firm realisations aided the company's growth. Tata Steel on the other hand went out of favour due mainly to the leveraged buy-out of Corus, which analysts felt would put pressure on its near to medium term cash flows. However, the stock price recovered once the funding became clear and the company continued to rake in profits in view of the favorable industry environment.

However, since the start of calendar year 2008, the stock prices of both the companies have mirrored the overall poor sentiment for Indian equities. SAIL has been hit the hardest, with its market value eroding by as much as 50%. The weakness in the stock could also be attributed to mounting cost pressures both on the operational as well as capex front. The earnings of Tata Steel standalone on the other hand continued to rise. This might be the reason it was not as badly hammered as its public sector counterpart. What also helped was the past track record of the company and its ability to maintain strong margins even in the down turn of economic cycle.

To conclude, while it pays handsomely to invest in the weakest company when the sector is ripe for a turnaround, one has to time the entry and exit perfectly in order to extract maximum benefits out of the same. With the benefit of hindsight, we can no doubt say that 2003 was one of the best periods to invest in SAIL and one should have exited at the peak of 2007, but in reality it may be one of the toughest decisions to make. Hence, rather than relying on market timing, it pays to stay invested in a company that has a long track record of consistent profit growth and stable margins.

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Steel: Who's performed better?". Click here!


More Views on News

Do Metal Stocks Really Track Metal Prices? (Views On News)

Sep 11, 2021

A close look at the performance of base metals and key companies in that sector.

A Peek into Tata Steel's Stellar June Quarter Performance (Views On News)

Aug 13, 2021

Tata Steel's June quarter profits were higher than the full-year profits reported for fiscal 2021.

TATA STEEL 2020-21 Annual Report Analysis (Annual Result Update)

Jul 8, 2021 | Updated on Jul 8, 2021

Here's an analysis of the annual report of TATA STEEL for 2020-21. It includes a full income statement, balance sheet and cash flow analysis of TATA STEEL. Also includes updates on the valuation of TATA STEEL.

Tata Metaliks Share Price Jumps 8% After Turning Profitable (Views On News)

Jul 14, 2021

A peek into Tata Metaliks' stellar June quarter performance.

Shyam Metalics IPO: Key Points to Consider (Views On News)

Jun 12, 2021

Shyam Metalics is commanding a strong grey market premium ahead of its IPO next week.

More Views on News

Most Popular

Infosys vs TCS: Which is Better? (Views On News)

Nov 26, 2021

In the post pandemic era, the top two IT companies in India are fighting to capture the growing demand for IT.

This Multibagger Stock Zooms 20% After Dolly Khanna Buys Stake (Views On News)

Nov 24, 2021

Shares of this edible oil company zoomed over 50% in three days after ace investor bought around 1% stake.

6 Popular Stocks that Turned into Penny Stocks (Views On News)

Nov 27, 2021

A look at popular stocks that crashed big time and never recovered, i.e. which went from 'Multibaggers to Multibeggers'.

MobiKwik IPO Opens for Subscription Soon. Key Things to Know Before Subscribing. (Views On News)

Nov 20, 2021

The Rs 19 bn issue is set to hit the market soon.

5 Indian Companies Embracing Blockchain Technology (Views On News)

Nov 23, 2021

Blockchain adoption in India was slow in the past. Now, the technology is being well received.


Become A Smarter Investor
In Just 5 Minutes

Multibagger Stock Guide 2022
Get our special report Multibagger Stocks Guide (2022 Edition) Now!
We will never sell or rent your email id.
Please read our Terms


Dec 3, 2021 (Close)


  • Track your investment in TATA STEEL with Equitymaster's Portfolio Tracker. Set live price alerts, get research alerts and more. Get access now...
  • Add To MyStocks