The big money or the sure money - Views on News from Equitymaster

Helping You Build Wealth With Honest Research
Since 1996. Try Now

  • MyStocks

MEMBER'S LOGINX

     
Login Failure
   
     
   
     
 
 
 
(Please do not use this option on a public machine)
 
     
 
 
 
  Sign Up | Forgot Password?  

The big money or the sure money

Sep 23, 2008

The debate is perhaps as old as the stock markets themselves and it goes something like this, "In order to outperform the markets over a sustained period of time, should one stay invested in small/medium caps (SMCs) or stick to only large caps?" The battle lines have already been drawn. On one side are the supporters of SMCs who swear by their ability to throw up a few multibaggers every now and then. While on the other side are the supporters of large caps where the chances of a permanent loss of capital stand reduced to a great extent. On the flip side, SMCs can make you lose tons of money while one is seldom likely to unearth a multi bagger from the universe of large caps.

  • Also read: Small caps: How have they performed?

    United they fall...
    As far as aggregate performance is concerned and if the history of the last five years is any indication, don't even think of investing in SMCs. This is because the out performance of the small cap index is so small that it does not even cover the higher risk that an investor takes while investing in these companies. Infact, the other index i.e. the mid cap index has actually underperformed the large cap index between Dec 2003 and now. Thus, on an aggregate basis, SMC indices are not the indices of first choice from a long-term perspective.

    ....and divided some stand tall
    Now the question that begs itself is, what about taking a bottom up approach and investing on a case-by-case basis? Our answer to this query would be the ever so diplomatic 'IT DEPENDS'. And it really does depend on a few things. The most critical would be one's circle of competence. If a person is a passive investor and his idea of research is weekend reading, then we believe he is better off sticking to large caps. This is because unlike SMCs, where the companies need to be thoroughly researched, large caps already come with equipped with proven business models and management. Hence, the chances of going wrong on these parameters stand reduced to a great extent. What only remains to be done is understanding the business model thoroughly and checking whether the large cap is available at a reasonable valuation. Furthermore, if entered into at decent valuations, the chances of 30%-40% downside are a lot less in large caps as compared to SMCs.

    SMCs on the other hand mostly come equipped with untested management and if it's a technologically inclined company, then the products might also be difficult to comprehend for an average investor. Thus, in order to unearth the next multi bagger from this universe, one needs to have a very good feel of qualitative parameters like the caliber of management and also the market potential of the products. Please bear in mind that for every 'Infosys' or a 'Google' there have been hundreds of other wannabes. The key is to have the ability to differentiate the men from the boys.

    Now a word or two on the returns. It should be obvious to anyone that if successful, SMCs can grow at a much faster rate than the large caps for long-periods of time thus leading to a concomitant rise in market values. However, betting on the wrong horse could lead to equally devastating results on the downside. Although this pitfall is eliminated in large caps, they more or less come with a limited upside unless bought at dirt-cheap valuations.

    Conclusion
    To conclude, there have been both success stories as well as huge failures in both the cases. The key is to identify one's circle of competence and invest accordingly. Investment legend, Warren Buffett had summed it best when he said, "The really big money tends to be made by investors who are right on qualitative decisions but, at least in my opinion, the more sure money tends to be made on the obvious quantitative decisions."

  • Also read: Lessons from Warren Buffett

  •   

    More Views on News

    6 Stocks With High Financial Leverage (Views On News)

    Aug 23, 2021

    Interestingly, two Adani group companies top the list while a Tata group company also makes the cut.

    Top 3 Agriculture Stocks to Keep Your Eye On (Views On News)

    Jun 28, 2021

    Top agriculture stocks that should have your attention now.

    5 Popular Stocks with Zero Promoter Holdings (Views On News)

    Jun 21, 2021

    List of stocks that have zero promoter holdings, where FPIs hold stake.

    How to Use P/E Ratio in Investing. podcast (Views On News)

    Sep 16, 2021

    P/E ratio is deceptively simple tool for valuations. Here's how not to read it, and make use of it for better investing decisions.

    Does the Expense Ratio Matter to Select the Best Mutual Fund Schemes? (Outside View)

    Sep 16, 2021

    PersonalFN explains how important it is to look at expense ratio when selecting a mutual fund for your portfolio.

    More Views on News

    Most Popular

    Small is Big: The Blueprint to Get Rich with Small-cap Stocks

    All you need to know about successful investing in the smallcap space.

    5 Small-cap Stocks with Zero Debt (Views On News)

    Sep 3, 2021

    In this article, you will get a list of 5 debt free small-cap companies that are worth tracking.

    Sansera Engineering IPO: Key Points to Consider (Views On News)

    Sep 8, 2021

    This IPO is a pure OFS and the company is looking to raise Rs 12.8 bn at the upper price band of Rs 744.

    5 Stocks that Turned Rs 1 Lakh into Rs 1 Crore (Views On News)

    Sep 7, 2021

    Patience is one of the biggest virtues you need to have if you want to become a crorepati in the stock market.

    Put the Odds in Your Favour to Find Smallcap Multibaggers (Profit Hunter)

    Sep 3, 2021

    A handy checklist to find multibagger smallcaps.

    More

    Become A Smarter Investor
    In Just 5 Minutes

    Multibagger Stock Guide 2021
    Get our special report Multibagger Stocks Guide (2021 Edition) Now!
    We will never sell or rent your email id.
    Please read our Terms

    S&P BSE SENSEX


    Sep 16, 2021 (Close)

    MARKET STATS