First came Britain and France, then Australia and the United States. Now it is India's turn. The debate for having a 'super-rich' tax in India is getting intense ever since the chairman of the Prime Minister's Economic Advisory Council (PMEAC), C Rangarajan, mooted a proposal in this regard. According to Rangarajan, the time has come when the government should either look at imposing surcharge on income above a threshold or a higher tax slab to augment the government revenue and bridge the fiscal deficit.
However, India Inc has came out strongly against the proposed move to tax the super-rich, saying the move would discourage entrepreneurship and lead to professionals relocating to low tax domiciles such as Singapore, Dubai or London.
India's tax revenue base has remained stagnant over the years. The country's tax to GDP ratio, an important indicator to measure tax administration, has remained abysmal. As per reports, the ratio has nudged downwards from a high of 11.9% of GDP in 2007-08 to 10.1% of GDP in 2011-12. This is a poor indicator reflecting inefficiencies prevailing in the system considering the overall growth rates have improved barring the last two fiscal.
The tragedy of the Indian tax system is that the honest tax payer is savagely attacked again and again. The dishonest tax payer seldom pays his tax dues. The areas of tax evasion and generation of black money are well known. Have we made any attempt to check tax evasion in sectors like liquor, real estate, cinema and private professional colleges? These categories continue to indulge in large-scale tax evasion without any action by the IT Department. By taxing the super-rich, we will only place a further premium on dishonesty and punish the honest tax payer.
If the object is to earn greater revenue, then taxing the super-rich will be counterproductive. The marginal gain in revenue will be temporary and there will be greater loss of revenue through lower collection of indirect taxes. It will be better if the Central Government re-examines the myriad wasteful welfare schemes. A 5% reduction in these will not only eliminate the need to tax the super-rich, it may even result in reducing rates of our indirect taxes.
For information on how to pick stocks that have the potential to deliver big returns, download our special report now!
Read the latest Market Commentary
What else is happening in the markets today? Dig in...
Indian share markets end on a flat note with the Sensex ending up by 35 points and the Nifty ending up by 18 points.
BSE Sensex is trading up by 214 points, while the NSE Nifty is trading up by 76 points.
Indian share markets open higher. The BSE Sensex opened up by 363 points, while the Nifty is trading higher by 112 points.
ONGC share price has hit a 52-week high. It is presently trading at Rs 121. BSE 500 Index is up by 0.7% at 20,123. Within the BSE 500, ONGC (up 5.2%) and BEML (up 13.1%) are among the top gainers, while top losers are DHFL and CORPORATION BANK.
GRINDWELL NORTON share price has hit a 52-week high. It is presently trading at Rs 975. BSE 500 Index is up by 0.8% at 20,123. Within the BSE 500, GRINDWELL NORTON (up 5.5%) and BEML (up 11.8%) are among the top gainers, while top losers are DHFL and CORPORATION BANK.
ASTRAL POLY TECHNICK share price has hit an all time high at Rs 2,332 (up 3.6%). The BSE CAPITAL GOODS Index is up by 1.4%. Among the top gainers in the BSE CAPITAL GOODS Index today are ASTRAL POLY TECHNICK (up 3.6%) and HONEYWELL AUTOMATION (up 2.5%). The top losers include KALPATARU POWER (down 0.8%).
View More Indian Share Market NewsLast time the smallcap index crossed 19k a big correction followed. Here's what makes it different this time.
In this video, I'll show you how to get started on the path to daily trading profits.
This could be the biggest wealth creator of the decade.
In this episode of the Investor Hour, India's #1 trader, Vijay Bhambwani, talks to us about the stock market, his new targets for gold and silver, the best long-term investment opportunity, and a lot more.
More
Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Are higher taxes on super rich justified?". Click here!
Comments are moderated by Equitymaster, in accordance with the Terms of Use, and may not appear
on this article until they have been reviewed and deemed appropriate for posting.
In the meantime, you may want to share this article with your friends!