Are Investors Losing Confidence in Franklin Templeton Mutual Fund - Outside View by PersonalFN

Helping You Build Wealth With Honest Research
Since 1996. Try Now

  • MyStocks


Login Failure
(Please do not use this option on a public machine)
  Sign Up | Forgot Password?  

Are Investors Losing Confidence in Franklin Templeton Mutual Fund
Mar 8, 2021

April 23, 2020 is the date that shocked about 3 lakh investors in debt mutual funds. It was the day when Franklin Templeton Mutual Fund took a drastic step of winding up six debt mutual fund schemes overnight citing poor liquidity condition in debt markets due to COVID-19 crisis.

The chaos and confusion kicked in among investors who were unable to access their money invested in these schemes. Investors were concerned about what would happen to their hard-earned money. Would they ever get their money back? If yes, then when and how?

In May 2020, SEBI appointed Chokshi & Chokshi to conduct a forensic audit after the fund house wound-up these six debt mutual fund schemes, which had combined assets worth Rs 26,000 crores. The forensic audit report submitted to SEBI in August 2020 was an eye opener. The audit report revealed some top executives at the fund house, their family members, directors on the AMC's board, trustees, and entities linked to the fund house had redeemed their holdings in the stressed schemes shortly before they were frozen for redemptions.

As per sources, SEBI has recently sent a show-cause notice to the asset management company, key personnel and trustees. The market regulator has started adjudication proceedings into the alleged breach of Fraudulent and Unfair Trade Practices (FUTP) regulations against the officials, who are supposed to appear before SEBI over the next few weeks. The notice alleges code of conduct violations, failure of risk management processes and the inability to discharge their fiduciary responsibility towards investors in the six debt mutual fund schemes.

--- Advertisement ---
On May 17, we are holding a FREE event to reveal Equitymaster's Great Indian Wealth Project

At this event, we'll reveal the details of your first stock for a potential Rs 7 crore in long-term wealth.

Since there are limited seats, we urge you to register at the earliest.

Click here for free sign-up

This is a question on the integrity of some of the top executives at the fund house who had access to unpublished information about the upcoming liquidity challenge. In the month of March 2020 and before April 23, 2020, some of the key personnel, their family members, trustees and entities linked to the fund house had redeemed their holdings together worth Rs 56 crore, before announcing the shutdown of the schemes.

The key personnel include Mr Vivek Kudva - Head of Asia Pacific at Franklin Templeton, his wife Ms. Roopa Kudva who is the managing director at Omidyar Network India, and his mother. Even the president of the asset management company, Mr Sanjay Sapre, his wife, and some of the directors had withdrawn a small portion of their investment in these schemes during the period.

The associate company of Franklin Templeton, Mywish Marketplaces Pvt. Ltd., that has common directors, too had redeemed a significant portion of its investments in the stressed debt schemes. Notably, some of these schemes were running into negative cash balance and had resorted to bank borrowing to meet the redemption pressure.

The repayment status of investor's money in stressed debt funds

Investors have been unable to access their money in the six debt mutual fund schemes of Franklin Templeton mutual fund that were wound up last year. Many investors even parked their retirement corpus in these schemes with an aim to generate decent returns, and were relying on them to meet their day to day needs. They have to wait to get back their money stuck in these schemes.

Now after waiting for more than 10 months, there is some respite for investors. Last month, Supreme Court dismissed all petitions challenging the validity of the e-vote for winding up of six debt mutual fund schemes, thus paving way for liquidation and eventually, the distribution of assets to the unitholders in the respective schemes.

FREE Event: Discover Your First Stock for a Potential Rs 7 Crore in Long-term Wealth

The apex court has appointed SBI Funds Management to undertake the liquidation and distribution of assets. As per the court's order, the fund house has disbursed the first tranche of money, i.e. Rs 9,122 crore (cash available for distribution as of January 15, 2021) to the aggrieved unitholders during the week of February 15, 2021. After the disbursement of the first tranche, the six debt schemes still have securities worth Rs 17,000 crores, of which the fund house has accrued around Rs 1,180 crore in cash as on February 26, 2021.

Investors in five out of six schemes that have turned cash positive have received a portion of their money. These are Franklin India Ultra Short Bond Fund (disbursed 49.66%), Franklin India Low Duration Fund (disbursed 62.63%), Franklin India Short Term Income Fund (disbursed 8.37%), Franklin India Credit Risk Fund (disbursed 25.25%), and Franklin India Dynamic Accrual Fund (disbursed 39.78%).

Distribution of funds from Franklin India Income Opportunities Fund, which had an AUM of Rs 1,742 crore as on January 29, 2021 and an outstanding borrowing at around 5% of the AUM, can only commence once it has repaid its borrowings.

--- Advertisement ---
How to Earn a Fortune in Gold, the Smart Way

Gold is on 'the verge of a decadal run' says Vijay Bhambwani, India's #1 Trader and Editor of Fast Profits Daily at Equitymaster.

He says gold has the potential to generate staggering gains in the coming years...And those who are betting on gold right now will hit the jackpot.

But wait.

While gold is an attractive investment destination, there's a very specific way to play this opportunity...

A way that ensures you rake in maximum profit and perhaps hit the jackpot...while minimizing potential pitfalls. Thankfully, Vijay - India's #1 Trader - can guide you step-by-step in the upcoming gold rush and help hit the jackpot just at the right time.

Sure, you don't want to be an average trader. That's not how you make a fortune.

Here's how you can get Vijay's guidance...

Should investors trust Franklin Templeton Mutual Fund?

The debt debacle at the fund house was primarily a result of high conviction and over confidence of the CIO and the fund managers towards lower rated debt papers and actively taking higher credit risk to generate higher yield. The winding up decision of these six debt schemes in April 2020 due to illiquidity, had already raised questions on the risk management process followed at the fund house.

If that was not enough, the actions of key personnel at the fund house failing to keep the clients' interest first and jumping the ship at the first hint of trouble raises question on the top managements integrity and commitment towards investors.

The question also arises on the role of the risk management at the fund house.

  • Did it fail to raise the flag in time after realising the debt portfolios were highly illiquid?
  • Or, did it lack independence and was operating under undue pressure of the key personnel?
  • Why did the top management not take timely action to mitigate the risk?

The act of some key management personnel is unacceptable, if they are actually involved in front running based on unpublished information, while about 3 lac investors were left without access to their money. Certainly, many investors have already lost their trust and confidence and have serious doubts about the process the fund house follows while managing their money.

Investors looking at quality need to first evaluate how comfortable they are holding their money in a fund house where the risk management is questionable and the key management personnel have been named in following unethical practices.

As the management at the fund house seems to have failed in keeping their clients' interest first, chances are that many investors may lose confidence in the fund house after this act, and may hesitate to invest their hard-earned money in funds belonging to Franklin Templeton.

Trust takes years to build, seconds to break, and forever to repair. ~ Anonymous

Editor's Note: PersonalFN's SMART Score process of rating mutual funds gives high weightage to systems and processes followed at the respective fund house. We don't hesitate in penalising funds belonging to fund houses that lack integrity and where the management is involved in unethical acts or practices. This helps us arrive at high quality reliable funds that follow stringent systems and processes. My mutual fund research service 'FundSelect' is backed by SMART Score process, which helps me pick and recommend some of the best mutual funds.

PS: If you are looking for quality mutual fund schemes, we suggest you try PersonalFN's premium research service, FundSelect. Currently, with new subscription to FundSelect, you could also get Free Bonus access to PersonalFN's Debt Fund recommendation service DebtSelect. Read full details here...

Author: Vivek Chaurasia

This article first appeared on PersonalFN here.

Join Now: PersonalFN is now on Telegram. Join FREE Today to get 'Daily Wealth Letter' and Exclusive Updates on Mutual Funds

PersonalFN is a Mumbai based personal finance firm offering Financial Planning and Mutual Fund Research services.


The views mentioned above are of the author only. Data and charts, if used, in the article have been sourced from available information and have not been authenticated by any statutory authority. The author and Equitymaster do not claim it to be accurate nor accept any responsibility for the same. The views constitute only the opinions and do not constitute any guidelines or recommendation on any course of action to be followed by the reader. Please read the detailed Terms of Use of the web site.

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "Are Investors Losing Confidence in Franklin Templeton Mutual Fund". Click here!


More Views on News

How Did Mindtree Perform in Q4FY21? (Company Info)

Apr 20, 2021

Here's the rundown on the company's latest quarterly results.

Tata Dividend Yield Fund: Seizes Opportunities from High Dividend Yield Stocks (Outside View)

May 7, 2021

PersonalFN analyses the features of Tata Dividend Yield Fund and explains the potential this fund has to offer to its investors.

My Secret to Find Breakthrough Stocks (Fast Profits Daily)

May 7, 2021

I've used this trading technique for many years with great success. I'm sharing it with you today.

The Key to Profit from India's EV Revolution (Profit Hunter)

May 7, 2021

Stocks you must consider investing in before buying your first electric vehicle.

Axis Healthcare ETF: Seeking Capital Appreciation from Sectoral Exposure (Outside View)

May 6, 2021

PersonalFN analyses the features of Axis Healthcare ETF and explains the potential this fund has to offer to its investors.

More Views on News

Most Popular

Time to Buy Smallcaps? (Fast Profits Daily)

Apr 30, 2021

In this video, I'll show you why I favour smallcaps over the Nifty.

The Next Smallcap Winners (Profit Hunter)

Apr 30, 2021

Price is the only due diligence one might require to buy this business.

Sell in May and Go Away? (Fast Profits Daily)

Apr 28, 2021

Does the concept of selling stocks in the month of May, work in the Indian market?

This Fund Manager Has Taken the World by Storm. Will You Invest With Her? (Profit Hunter)

Apr 26, 2021

Should you invest with this Rockstar fund manager who has outperformed in a big way?


India's #1 Trader
Reveals His Secrets

Secret To Increasing Your Trading Profits Today
Get this Special Report,
The Secret to Increasing Your Trading Profits Today, Now!
We will never sell or rent your email id.
Please read our Terms


May 7, 2021 (Close)