PSU Banks: A Goldmine or a Death Trap for Investors?

Mar 20, 2018

Rahul Shah, Editor, Profit Hunter

Buying what looks tantalizingly cheap can backfire sometimes.

Just ask Bill Miller.

Before the financial crisis of 2008, Miller was a hero, a rockstar amongst fund managers: It is not every day that a fund manager beats the benchmark index 15 years in a row!

The odds of that happening are one in a million... You have a better chance of being crushed by a meteorite than achieving the same feat as Miller.

And then Miller fell from grace.

Not only did his long streak end, he racked up such huge losses that by the time the year 2009 ended, he was trailing the benchmark index. That's more than two decades of outperformance going up in smoke in a matter of months.

The carnage in financial stocks proved to be his undoing.

Instead of making a dash for the exits when the crisis first reared its head, Miller jumped right into the fire.

He loaded up on financial stocks, asserting that investors are being far too timid and when the dust will settle, he will walk away with handsome gains.

The dust did settle but not before completely obliterating Miller's portfolio.

As per Miller's own admission, he was completely blindsided by the statistical cheapness of financial stocks.

He thought they had already fallen a lot, how much lower can they go?

Well, some of them went all the way down to zero.

As the Wall Street Journal highlighted,

  • This meltdown has provided a lesson for Mr. Miller and other "value" investors: A stock may look tantalizingly cheap, but sometimes that's for good reason.
--- Advertisement ---
10 Years of Remarkable Returns...

For the last 10 years, our Small Cap stock recommendation service has guided thousands of investors to retire rich and early.

To celebrate this decade of success, we want to guide thousands more readers to retire early & wealthy—and that's why, you now have a unique opportunity to claim 1 year access to our Small Cap service... virtually FREE!

But this unique opportunity ends on 31st March 2018.

So, you need to act fast...

Click here to take advantage of this opportunity NOW.

Is this applicable to the PSU banking space in India?

The stocks do look tantalizingly cheap. In fact, they haven't been this cheap in years.

But is the low valuation justified in view of the risks it is facing? Or are investors being too pessimistic and someone with a contrarian bent of mind can really make a fortune over the long term?

In my Microcap Millionaires service, we do recommend out of favour, beaten down stocks. But we also keep in mind the following Charlie Munger dictum.

  • All I want to know is where I'm going to die so I'll never go there.

It is this rule that has stopped us from recommending any banking stock right since the inception of the service.

In its four-year history, we have never ever recommended a single banking stock in Microcap Millionaires.

I am going to tell you why.

The problem with buying an out-of-favour bank is that there's always a risk there's a Bill Miller-like situation around the corner.

Banks are leveraged entities and therefore buying them when they are out of favour is like playing with fire.

Any adverse development and you could well be staring at a complete wipe-out of their net worth.

The stocks could go all the way to zero, thus eliminating any possibility of making a comeback when business conditions improve.

Bill Miller learnt this the hard way.

This doesn't mean you should too. You are certainly not going to die every time you invest in a troubled bank. But why take the chance?

Even a long series of positive numbers, however impressive they may be, evaporates when multiplied by a single zero.

There are few stocks more capable of evaporating your returns than an out-of-favour, leveraged entity like a bank.

So, no matter how mouthwatering the prospect of raking in big returns from PSU banks, it is one space you may do well to avoid.

If you still want to take exposure, make sure it is not so large so as to run your portfolio into the ground.

Happy Investing,

Rahul Shah
Rahul Shah (Research Analyst)
Editor, Profit Hunter

PS: Small cap guru Richa Agarwal's latest discovery is a stock she vigorously recommends - against all odds. Don't miss your chance to invest in it. Click here to get access to a free year of her small cap recommendation service.

Recent Articles

Wait! Don't Chase Smallcaps Now September 18, 2020
Let the markets take a breather before you jump in.
Why We Picked This Small-cap Stock for Our Hidden Treasure Subscribers September 17, 2020
This leading household brand will profit big time in a post covid world.
How to Profit from the Most Underrated Risk India Faces from China September 16, 2020
An Indian tech company will cash in by defending Indians against this risk.
A Rs 280 Billion Bonanza for Smallcaps? September 15, 2020
Will the new regulations mark the beginning of a bull run in smallcaps?

Equitymaster requests your view! Post a comment on "PSU Banks: A Goldmine or a Death Trap for Investors?". Click here!